1
00:00:05,520 --> 00:00:08,000
Hello, welcome to Farmgate. 
I'm fit Locustane, the 

2
00:00:08,000 --> 00:00:10,760
editorof8.9.com, the land use 
news channel. 

3
00:00:10,760 --> 00:00:13,200
This is the third of our 
programmes investigating 

4
00:00:13,200 --> 00:00:17,480
Pathways A5 year EU Horizon 2020
funded research project that's 

5
00:00:17,480 --> 00:00:20,600
been running since 2021. 
In this programme we're going to

6
00:00:20,600 --> 00:00:24,080
discuss the scenarios work that 
provided the foundations for 

7
00:00:24,080 --> 00:00:26,840
pathways. 
The scenarios were designed as 

8
00:00:26,840 --> 00:00:30,280
plausible future storylines for 
how European livestock systems 

9
00:00:30,280 --> 00:00:33,120
might evolve under different 
economic, environmental, 

10
00:00:33,120 --> 00:00:35,040
technological and social 
conditions. 

11
00:00:35,120 --> 00:00:38,160
In particular, they helped 
researchers to test trade-offs 

12
00:00:38,160 --> 00:00:42,040
between different sustainability
goals and outcomes. 5 scenarios 

13
00:00:42,040 --> 00:00:45,720
were developed, feed no food, 
high animal welfare, rural 

14
00:00:45,720 --> 00:00:48,760
Renaissance, efficiency first 
and stock free Europe. 

15
00:00:48,840 --> 00:00:51,960
To discuss them, I'm joined by 
Doctor Pierre Marie Ober, 

16
00:00:51,960 --> 00:00:55,040
Director of Agriculture for food
Policies that the French Think 

17
00:00:55,280 --> 00:00:58,280
thank IDRI, by Doctor Tom 
Staton, a senior research fellow

18
00:00:58,280 --> 00:01:01,480
at the University of Reading, 
and by Doctor Jessica Boseau, A 

19
00:01:01,480 --> 00:01:04,440
postdoctoral research associate 
also at the University of 

20
00:01:04,440 --> 00:01:06,400
Reading. 
Now, Tom, you're just back from 

21
00:01:06,400 --> 00:01:08,400
the final Pathways event in 
Brussels. 

22
00:01:08,400 --> 00:01:11,080
What were your key takeaways? 
I think for me it's just a 

23
00:01:11,080 --> 00:01:14,840
reminder of how broad ranging 
the Pathways project is, because

24
00:01:14,840 --> 00:01:18,360
in these large continental 
projects we tend to get focused 

25
00:01:18,360 --> 00:01:20,080
on our own work and our own 
models. 

26
00:01:20,400 --> 00:01:23,360
And then when we come together 
in these once a year big project

27
00:01:23,360 --> 00:01:26,920
meetings, we just realized how 
much work is going on in the 

28
00:01:26,920 --> 00:01:29,880
project looking at different 
aspects of livestock 

29
00:01:29,880 --> 00:01:31,640
sustainability. 
Because when we're thinking 

30
00:01:31,640 --> 00:01:34,680
about the future of livestock 
sustainability in Europe, there 

31
00:01:34,680 --> 00:01:36,760
is a lot to consider. 
So there's the environmental 

32
00:01:36,760 --> 00:01:39,880
impacts, like the impacts on 
climate change, biodiversity, 

33
00:01:40,080 --> 00:01:43,600
pollution, land use, and there's
a whole range of social impacts.

34
00:01:43,600 --> 00:01:46,160
There's economic impacts. 
And then of course, there's food

35
00:01:46,160 --> 00:01:49,840
security, which is very high on 
the policy agenda across Europe 

36
00:01:49,880 --> 00:01:53,200
because of recent conflicts and 
geopolitical events. 

37
00:01:53,240 --> 00:01:55,760
And then there's the whole 
consumer side in, in terms of 

38
00:01:56,040 --> 00:01:59,080
the consumer demand for food, 
which is affordable and 

39
00:01:59,080 --> 00:02:02,560
nutritious and with high 
standards of animal welfare. 

40
00:02:02,680 --> 00:02:05,160
So when we're thinking about the
future of livestock in Europe, 

41
00:02:05,160 --> 00:02:07,520
which is what we're doing in 
Pathways and what we're talking 

42
00:02:07,520 --> 00:02:10,759
about today, there's no easy 
answers, there's no silver 

43
00:02:10,759 --> 00:02:14,080
bullets which can address all of
these issues simultaneously. 

44
00:02:14,200 --> 00:02:17,720
And so each future scenario that
we've developed in Pathways, 

45
00:02:17,720 --> 00:02:21,080
which we'll talk about, is good 
at addressing certain issues, 

46
00:02:21,520 --> 00:02:24,960
but they all kind of fall short 
in other areas. 

47
00:02:25,280 --> 00:02:27,720
So really a key take away for me
is thinking about how we can 

48
00:02:27,720 --> 00:02:31,120
blend the strengths of each of 
these scenarios going forward 

49
00:02:31,320 --> 00:02:34,400
and really finding that balance 
and that middle ground between 

50
00:02:34,400 --> 00:02:35,560
the scenarios. 
Yeah. 

51
00:02:35,560 --> 00:02:38,320
And so moving on to that 
scenarios work, can you sort of 

52
00:02:38,320 --> 00:02:41,920
broaden out that overview about 
the purpose of the scenarios or 

53
00:02:41,920 --> 00:02:44,200
the storylines as they're 
sometimes called within 

54
00:02:44,200 --> 00:02:45,360
pathways? 
Yeah. 

55
00:02:45,360 --> 00:02:48,320
So I think if we if we go back 
to the aim of the Pathways 

56
00:02:48,320 --> 00:02:52,520
project, which is essentially to
support a transition towards 

57
00:02:52,520 --> 00:02:55,200
more sustainable livestock 
production and consumption. 

58
00:02:55,520 --> 00:02:57,720
But the question is, what does 
that really look like? 

59
00:02:57,840 --> 00:03:00,280
And that's very subjective. 
So, you know, if I were to ask 

60
00:03:00,280 --> 00:03:03,560
the four of us, what does that 
look like, I'd get 4 different 

61
00:03:03,560 --> 00:03:06,080
answers at least. 
Yeah, at least. 

62
00:03:06,080 --> 00:03:07,760
Yeah. 
And so the idea of the scenarios

63
00:03:07,760 --> 00:03:11,040
work is to to try to capture 
some of that range of different 

64
00:03:11,160 --> 00:03:14,320
viewpoints and visions for the 
future of livestock 

65
00:03:14,320 --> 00:03:17,240
sustainability in Europe. 
So let's try and get to grips 

66
00:03:17,240 --> 00:03:19,120
with the detail of the scenarios
themselves. 

67
00:03:19,120 --> 00:03:20,960
And so forgive me, Tom and 
Jessica, but I'm going to spend 

68
00:03:20,960 --> 00:03:23,440
the first half of the program 
with Pierre Marie because he's 

69
00:03:23,440 --> 00:03:26,000
the sort of the key architect, 
if you like, of the scenarios 

70
00:03:26,000 --> 00:03:28,280
work. 
So Pierre Marie, how did you go 

71
00:03:28,280 --> 00:03:31,240
about selecting themes for the 
scenarios? 

72
00:03:31,240 --> 00:03:33,920
Because I can imagine that there
are other topics, for example, 

73
00:03:33,920 --> 00:03:36,640
nature first or woodland 
integration that might have 

74
00:03:36,640 --> 00:03:39,080
thrown up similarly interesting 
challenges and trade-offs. 

75
00:03:39,280 --> 00:03:42,480
So how and why did you choose 
those themes that you landed on?

76
00:03:42,600 --> 00:03:45,040
I guess the, the point is that 
the, the project, the past five 

77
00:03:45,040 --> 00:03:49,120
project intending from the very 
beginning to not be only, you 

78
00:03:49,120 --> 00:03:52,280
know, researchers thinking and 
discussing between themselves, 

79
00:03:52,280 --> 00:03:55,520
but rather a project that really
engage with stakeholders on the 

80
00:03:55,520 --> 00:03:57,640
ground, farmers processes, 
etcetera. 

81
00:03:57,720 --> 00:04:02,680
So I mean, the project started 
in 2022 with practice helps, 

82
00:04:02,680 --> 00:04:05,760
workshops and multi active 
platform conversations where we 

83
00:04:05,760 --> 00:04:08,880
basically asked people that we 
are joining, OK, what, what's 

84
00:04:08,880 --> 00:04:12,120
your vision for the life 
successor in Europe? 

85
00:04:12,120 --> 00:04:14,800
What would be desirable, what 
would be feasible, what would be

86
00:04:14,800 --> 00:04:17,920
plausible? 
And so we ended up by the autumn

87
00:04:17,920 --> 00:04:23,120
2022 with like 4 broad IDs where
people were saying, hey, I can 

88
00:04:23,120 --> 00:04:25,760
see one future where efficiency 
would be leading. 

89
00:04:25,840 --> 00:04:28,200
I can see one future where 
evaluated would be leading. 

90
00:04:28,280 --> 00:04:30,240
I can see a future combining the
two. 

91
00:04:30,320 --> 00:04:32,680
And I can see a future where 
agroecology would be leading. 

92
00:04:32,680 --> 00:04:35,360
And I can see a last future 
where the animal would be the 

93
00:04:35,360 --> 00:04:38,400
backbone of, you know, the 
future of the life successor. 

94
00:04:38,400 --> 00:04:42,480
So we had those kind of five 
very broad, even not storyline, 

95
00:04:42,480 --> 00:04:46,360
but, you know, broad IDs of what
could be or what should be a 

96
00:04:46,360 --> 00:04:48,800
driver for the future of the 
life successor. 

97
00:04:49,000 --> 00:04:52,040
And we started from there. 
And then we had a number of 

98
00:04:52,040 --> 00:04:56,080
interactions online and then in 
person within the project with 

99
00:04:56,080 --> 00:04:59,640
stakeholders from all across the
EU to sort of sort of like 

100
00:04:59,640 --> 00:05:03,040
gradually refine that by trying 
to kind of, you know, fleshly 

101
00:05:03,040 --> 00:05:06,560
with the bond and put a little 
bit more around those ideas. 

102
00:05:06,640 --> 00:05:09,680
And of course, while doing that,
you know, we changed them a 

103
00:05:09,680 --> 00:05:12,760
little bit gradually. 
So to get a Long story short, it

104
00:05:12,760 --> 00:05:16,160
took us a year and a half from 
that point where we had the 5 

105
00:05:16,280 --> 00:05:19,880
broad visions to get to more 
details, what we call 

106
00:05:19,880 --> 00:05:22,400
storylines. 
So basically broad stories, 

107
00:05:22,400 --> 00:05:25,840
pretty much production focused, 
not talking too much about the 

108
00:05:25,840 --> 00:05:29,560
demon side and, and really get 
to the five stories where as I 

109
00:05:29,560 --> 00:05:33,680
said, the focus is really on 
like how we would be producing 

110
00:05:33,920 --> 00:05:37,360
and rearing and transforming 
animals without paying too much 

111
00:05:37,360 --> 00:05:40,120
attention on the demon side 
because we wanted to basically 

112
00:05:40,240 --> 00:05:44,200
use the demon side as let's say 
a sensitivity analysis, OK, What

113
00:05:44,200 --> 00:05:47,400
kind of demand would be 
compatible with those kind of 

114
00:05:47,400 --> 00:05:51,080
evolution in let's say the 
supply side, the animal side, so

115
00:05:51,080 --> 00:05:52,560
to speak. 
We'll go on to talking about 

116
00:05:52,560 --> 00:05:55,000
those scenarios specifically in 
just a moment, but I'm, I'm 

117
00:05:55,000 --> 00:05:57,120
really interested because you 
sort of explain the process, 

118
00:05:57,160 --> 00:06:00,000
therefore, you know, how the 
scenarios were landed on, you 

119
00:06:00,000 --> 00:06:02,600
know, why it was that those 
things were decided. 

120
00:06:02,680 --> 00:06:06,280
But of course this was, you 
know, 3-4, almost five years ago

121
00:06:06,280 --> 00:06:08,680
now, certainly five years ago 
that you started working on 

122
00:06:08,680 --> 00:06:10,840
these. 
And, and I wonder how much 

123
00:06:10,840 --> 00:06:13,680
things have changed, how much 
the world has changed around you

124
00:06:13,680 --> 00:06:15,000
over the course of that five 
years. 

125
00:06:15,000 --> 00:06:18,040
Because there's a danger, you 
know, for you in France of sort 

126
00:06:18,040 --> 00:06:21,520
of thinking of a sort of France 
first perspective for me in the 

127
00:06:21,520 --> 00:06:24,760
UK, you know, I can think about 
UK policy, but over the last 

128
00:06:24,760 --> 00:06:29,040
five years in the UK, things 
like nature integration, things 

129
00:06:29,040 --> 00:06:32,280
like agroforestry, they've sort 
of grown up and become really 

130
00:06:32,280 --> 00:06:34,680
important parts of the 
conversation where actually four

131
00:06:34,680 --> 00:06:36,560
or five years ago I don't think 
they would have been. 

132
00:06:36,560 --> 00:06:39,560
I think we'd probably have come 
to similar conclusions to the 

133
00:06:39,560 --> 00:06:41,280
ones that you came to at the 
time. 

134
00:06:41,280 --> 00:06:43,160
Then. 
Do you think that across Europe 

135
00:06:43,400 --> 00:06:46,680
things have moved or changed at 
all, and that you might have 

136
00:06:46,680 --> 00:06:49,480
chosen slightly different 
scenarios if you were picking 

137
00:06:49,480 --> 00:06:52,000
them today, or do you think 
they'd largely be the same? 

138
00:06:52,000 --> 00:06:55,000
I think the, the idea of a, 
let's say nature driven scenario

139
00:06:55,000 --> 00:06:58,720
is pretty much part of the 
agricultural scenario, the feed 

140
00:06:58,720 --> 00:07:00,760
no food scenario, which is 
pretty much about building 

141
00:07:00,760 --> 00:07:04,880
nature within landscapes with 
animals and and other things. 

142
00:07:04,960 --> 00:07:08,720
So you're right, we could have 
put more the focus on trees and 

143
00:07:08,720 --> 00:07:11,280
agroforestry and all that. 
That was an option that was 

144
00:07:11,280 --> 00:07:14,200
discussed actually. 
But we thought, OK, it still 

145
00:07:14,200 --> 00:07:16,080
needs to be animal centered so 
to speak. 

146
00:07:16,120 --> 00:07:18,600
So the agrophorestry part was 
like a little bit on the side of

147
00:07:18,600 --> 00:07:22,200
that. 
I think if we were to redo the 

148
00:07:22,200 --> 00:07:26,520
scenario exercise now, I guess 
one of the theme that would 

149
00:07:26,520 --> 00:07:30,120
emerge much more strongly that 
it did in the past is this 

150
00:07:30,120 --> 00:07:33,520
competitiveness question. 
And that would we would really 

151
00:07:33,520 --> 00:07:37,360
see the tension between OK, 
sustainability objectives, you 

152
00:07:37,360 --> 00:07:39,680
know, broader societal 
objectives and this 

153
00:07:39,680 --> 00:07:42,600
competitiveness objective. 
You said UK first, France first,

154
00:07:42,600 --> 00:07:44,040
whatever. 
I mean at the moment that the 

155
00:07:44,040 --> 00:07:47,440
Commission is EU 1st and how do 
we make sure that what is 

156
00:07:47,440 --> 00:07:50,840
produced in the EU, you know, 
can compete on global markets 

157
00:07:50,840 --> 00:07:52,880
and can resist imports from the 
rest of the world. 

158
00:07:53,000 --> 00:07:57,120
So that would probably be one of
the, you know, strong ID that 

159
00:07:57,120 --> 00:07:59,520
would emerge from, you know, 
another kind of focus group or 

160
00:07:59,520 --> 00:08:00,680
whatever. 
Yeah, no, it's really 

161
00:08:00,680 --> 00:08:03,120
interesting, but it's it's just 
interesting to sort of hear how 

162
00:08:03,120 --> 00:08:05,760
society changes because of 
course, you know, it does and 

163
00:08:05,760 --> 00:08:07,640
and different things become 
priorities. 

164
00:08:07,640 --> 00:08:09,840
So yeah, thank you for that. 
So let's talk through each of 

165
00:08:09,840 --> 00:08:12,200
the scenarios individually and 
let's begin perhaps with the 

166
00:08:12,200 --> 00:08:14,760
most radical, the most 
provocative and that's the the 

167
00:08:14,760 --> 00:08:17,640
stock Free Europe scenario. 
Talk me through that. 

168
00:08:17,640 --> 00:08:21,320
What is it and why was this 
particular scenario needed and 

169
00:08:21,320 --> 00:08:24,000
what were the key trade-offs 
that the process unearthed? 

170
00:08:24,080 --> 00:08:26,520
I mean, the stock free scenario,
the European stock free scenario

171
00:08:26,520 --> 00:08:28,680
is rather storyline at this 
stage. 

172
00:08:28,680 --> 00:08:30,120
Yeah. 
I mean, the distinction between 

173
00:08:30,120 --> 00:08:32,400
the storyline and scenario is 
that the storyline is basically 

174
00:08:32,640 --> 00:08:35,919
a set of IDs that are, you know,
more or less nicely articulated.

175
00:08:36,159 --> 00:08:39,679
The scenario is when you start 
computing those IDs, so putting 

176
00:08:39,679 --> 00:08:42,840
some quantitative parameters 
behind the IDs to put them in 

177
00:08:42,840 --> 00:08:45,960
the model and then say, OK, what
would the life success in Europe

178
00:08:45,960 --> 00:08:49,720
look like really if we were to. 
But the storyline can give birth

179
00:08:49,720 --> 00:08:52,160
to two or three scenarios 
because there are many ways you 

180
00:08:52,160 --> 00:08:54,640
can translate, you know, 
narratives into quantitative 

181
00:08:54,640 --> 00:08:55,840
parameters. 
The model, right. 

182
00:08:55,880 --> 00:09:00,760
So the stock free storyline 
emerged as OK, we are missing 

183
00:09:00,760 --> 00:09:02,640
something. 
We are missing sort of a 

184
00:09:02,640 --> 00:09:07,520
counterfactual that would tell 
us basically what are we missing

185
00:09:07,800 --> 00:09:10,360
if at some point we lose all the
animals we have. 

186
00:09:10,560 --> 00:09:14,760
So I guess the idea was not to 
say this is miserable, but 

187
00:09:14,760 --> 00:09:18,240
rather this is something we need
to have in the scope to really 

188
00:09:18,240 --> 00:09:22,640
see what animals are bringing to
landscapes, nature, society, 

189
00:09:22,640 --> 00:09:26,240
economy, etcetera, etcetera. 
But I should add that that was 

190
00:09:26,240 --> 00:09:29,600
highly debated. 
I mean, like many colleagues, 

191
00:09:29,840 --> 00:09:33,720
many stakeholders were like, 
what the hell, I don't even want

192
00:09:33,720 --> 00:09:35,680
this. 
I don't want want to see this 

193
00:09:35,680 --> 00:09:38,240
because it will give IDs to 
other people. 

194
00:09:38,240 --> 00:09:41,040
But we were like, wow, that's 
very interesting because we are 

195
00:09:41,080 --> 00:09:46,000
all, we were quite kind of all 
very sure that this scenario 

196
00:09:46,000 --> 00:09:49,440
would yield results that make it
not very desirable. 

197
00:09:49,440 --> 00:09:52,200
So we are quite confident that 
it was a nice thing to do, 

198
00:09:52,560 --> 00:09:56,000
rather, not to say we don't need
livestock, but rather hey look, 

199
00:09:56,000 --> 00:09:58,600
we really need animals. 
And you say, you know, that 

200
00:09:58,600 --> 00:10:00,840
there was sort of pushback 
within the team, and I can 

201
00:10:00,840 --> 00:10:02,840
imagine that there was. 
But at the same time, you know, 

202
00:10:02,840 --> 00:10:05,680
this is something that NGOs are 
pushing for, certainly, you 

203
00:10:05,680 --> 00:10:08,600
know, not all NGO, but certainly
some campaigning organisations 

204
00:10:08,600 --> 00:10:11,160
are pushing for and some 
commentators within that. 

205
00:10:11,160 --> 00:10:15,080
So it's important, as you say, 
to think, think through the 

206
00:10:15,080 --> 00:10:17,880
benefits of livestock and what 
would be absent if if they 

207
00:10:17,880 --> 00:10:20,480
weren't there. 
And I know that this was an 

208
00:10:20,480 --> 00:10:22,680
extreme scenario. 
It was a counterfactual as you 

209
00:10:22,680 --> 00:10:26,360
say, and you've talked about not
focusing too much on the demand 

210
00:10:26,360 --> 00:10:27,840
side. 
But I wonder whether you 

211
00:10:27,840 --> 00:10:31,560
consider the acceptability of 
this from a a European business 

212
00:10:31,560 --> 00:10:36,360
and citizen perspective, how 
society might reject or arrive 

213
00:10:36,360 --> 00:10:41,160
at a stock free food system. 
Well, I think that I wouldn't 

214
00:10:41,160 --> 00:10:45,520
even dare to raise that question
in a political conversation. 

215
00:10:45,520 --> 00:10:49,040
I mean, like we've been working 
at Ely with many of the 

216
00:10:49,040 --> 00:10:51,760
colleagues at feeble part of the
pathway project, you know, to 

217
00:10:52,040 --> 00:10:55,600
discuss in a sort of like 
peaceful manner about, you know,

218
00:10:55,600 --> 00:10:58,600
how to get people eating a 
little bit less animal source 

219
00:10:58,600 --> 00:11:01,560
foods, you know, for global 
justice reasons, for another 

220
00:11:01,560 --> 00:11:04,840
reasons, whatever reasons. 
And I mean, I've been, you know,

221
00:11:04,840 --> 00:11:07,480
in many hearings in the open 
parliaments, in the Irish 

222
00:11:07,480 --> 00:11:09,760
parliament, in the French 
Parliament, as soon as you start

223
00:11:09,760 --> 00:11:13,560
saying, hey, look, guys, there 
would be some value in in trying

224
00:11:13,560 --> 00:11:16,880
to get people, you know, gently,
not forcing them, but to go 

225
00:11:16,880 --> 00:11:18,520
towards less and better at my 
source food. 

226
00:11:18,600 --> 00:11:21,000
You know, the level of pushback 
you get is like that high. 

227
00:11:21,080 --> 00:11:25,280
So discussing in in in terms of 
setting about a stock free 

228
00:11:25,280 --> 00:11:29,120
Europe is for me probably 
something unthinkable. 

229
00:11:29,560 --> 00:11:32,440
Yeah, yeah, absolutely. 
And, and I guess you know, 

230
00:11:32,440 --> 00:11:35,120
within that I was sort of 
thinking, I mean, precisely as 

231
00:11:35,120 --> 00:11:37,480
you were saying that there is, 
there's so much pushback that 

232
00:11:37,480 --> 00:11:39,840
actually the only way of getting
there would be through 

233
00:11:39,840 --> 00:11:43,160
incredible political 
polarisation and, and, you know,

234
00:11:43,160 --> 00:11:46,200
quite significant state control 
over the food system, which 

235
00:11:46,200 --> 00:11:48,880
would not be popular with with 
very many people. 

236
00:11:49,200 --> 00:11:52,280
So the efficiency first scenario
is probably the scenario that's 

237
00:11:52,280 --> 00:11:54,600
most diametrically opposed to 
the stock for a Europe 

238
00:11:54,600 --> 00:11:57,840
storyline. 
So this is focused on maximizing

239
00:11:57,840 --> 00:12:00,920
feed efficiency to produce as 
much animal protein as possible.

240
00:12:01,120 --> 00:12:02,840
Can you tell me a bit more about
that scenario? 

241
00:12:03,000 --> 00:12:05,200
Yeah. 
Well, I guess as I said, there 

242
00:12:05,200 --> 00:12:07,080
are many ways in which you can 
model efficiency. 

243
00:12:07,080 --> 00:12:09,640
First, depending on what 
assumptions you put on the 

244
00:12:09,640 --> 00:12:14,360
demand side and whether you 
consider that scenario through, 

245
00:12:14,400 --> 00:12:16,240
let's say your market 
equilibrium model. 

246
00:12:16,480 --> 00:12:19,760
So basically where supply and 
demand are dynamically linked 

247
00:12:19,880 --> 00:12:23,360
through markets or whether you 
model that storyline with a 

248
00:12:23,360 --> 00:12:26,640
biomass balance scenario where 
you basically you are the 

249
00:12:26,640 --> 00:12:29,680
special planner and you decide, 
you know how much you produce 

250
00:12:29,680 --> 00:12:34,120
and how when you do model an 
efficiency for scenario via a 

251
00:12:34,120 --> 00:12:36,840
market based model, you know 
what you get at the end of the 

252
00:12:36,840 --> 00:12:39,920
day is exactly what you said. 
Basically you maximize put in 

253
00:12:39,920 --> 00:12:43,080
prediction because basically 
efficiency gains most of the 

254
00:12:43,080 --> 00:12:45,720
time comes with productivity 
gains. 

255
00:12:45,840 --> 00:12:48,480
So basically you are able to 
produce, you know quite 

256
00:12:48,480 --> 00:12:49,960
significant and increase the 
prediction. 

257
00:12:50,400 --> 00:12:53,560
And in a market based model you 
basically increase the 

258
00:12:53,560 --> 00:12:56,400
prediction, you decrease the 
prices, you increase the 

259
00:12:56,400 --> 00:12:58,600
consumption and you increase 
exports, right. 

260
00:12:58,600 --> 00:13:02,200
So that's what happens in an 
efficiency first scenario model 

261
00:13:02,200 --> 00:13:05,400
through a market based model, 
which means that basically you 

262
00:13:05,400 --> 00:13:08,360
have a very well known rebound 
effect where basically your 

263
00:13:08,360 --> 00:13:11,840
efficiency gains are lost 
because you have an increase in 

264
00:13:11,840 --> 00:13:15,800
total production. 
If then you model the efficiency

265
00:13:15,800 --> 00:13:18,560
for scenario with the biomass 
balance model where you decide 

266
00:13:18,600 --> 00:13:22,440
how much you produce, you can 
easily go to a sort of like land

267
00:13:22,440 --> 00:13:26,160
sparing scenario where basically
you have massive efficiency 

268
00:13:26,160 --> 00:13:30,040
gains that if not accompanied by
an increase in the demand, 

269
00:13:30,640 --> 00:13:34,240
translates into, you know, gains
in the land use, gains in 

270
00:13:34,240 --> 00:13:38,640
emissions of whatever greenhouse
gases, gains in manual 

271
00:13:38,640 --> 00:13:40,680
management problems, etcetera, 
etcetera. 

272
00:13:40,800 --> 00:13:44,120
And that is what, you know, many
colleagues like Greens and 

273
00:13:44,120 --> 00:13:47,840
others advocating for land 
spring, you know, philosophy 

274
00:13:48,120 --> 00:13:50,680
have been adverticating for. 
But the reality is that it's not

275
00:13:50,680 --> 00:13:52,960
the world in which we are. 
So that's, you know, that's 

276
00:13:52,960 --> 00:13:54,000
where we get to. 
Yeah. 

277
00:13:54,000 --> 00:13:56,200
And I guess it's sort of 
particularly important when we 

278
00:13:56,200 --> 00:13:58,480
come to some of those futures 
scenarios to kind of compare 

279
00:13:58,520 --> 00:14:01,240
these different scenarios to get
the trade-offs, isn't it? 

280
00:14:01,240 --> 00:14:03,840
Because that's where again, we 
sort of get to grips with the 

281
00:14:03,840 --> 00:14:07,560
whole land sparing, land sharing
discussion and whether in and 

282
00:14:07,560 --> 00:14:10,840
how to deliver the greatest 
level of, of efficiency within 

283
00:14:10,840 --> 00:14:12,640
those systems. 
And, and for me, it's always 

284
00:14:12,640 --> 00:14:15,240
seemed that you've got to have a
combination of things that land 

285
00:14:15,320 --> 00:14:18,200
sparing as such is just 
inherently inefficient because 

286
00:14:18,200 --> 00:14:19,680
you're only using land for one 
thing. 

287
00:14:19,680 --> 00:14:22,600
Whereas if you can layer up a 
whole load of different things 

288
00:14:22,600 --> 00:14:25,960
onto that land, it's delivering 
XY and Z, then that you know, 

289
00:14:25,960 --> 00:14:27,800
surely is, is it's a better 
approach. 

290
00:14:27,800 --> 00:14:30,640
But it seems to me that by and 
large the the efficiency 

291
00:14:30,640 --> 00:14:33,360
approach in addition to sort of 
supporting that land sparing 

292
00:14:33,360 --> 00:14:36,760
approach, that it's essentially 
a description of business as 

293
00:14:36,760 --> 00:14:40,480
usual and sustainable 
intensification, you know, as 

294
00:14:40,480 --> 00:14:42,960
we've understood it over the 
last decade or so. 

295
00:14:42,960 --> 00:14:45,680
Do you think that's fair? 
Yeah, I think it's totally fair.

296
00:14:45,680 --> 00:14:49,400
And I mean, the interactions we 
had with stakeholders in France,

297
00:14:49,400 --> 00:14:51,680
in Europe, in other countries 
are, you know, pretty much 

298
00:14:51,680 --> 00:14:54,760
aligned with that in the sense 
that in most of the sectors, 

299
00:14:54,760 --> 00:14:58,040
because I mean, livestock 
sectors is obviously the meal 

300
00:14:58,040 --> 00:15:00,360
sector is different from the 
beef sector, etcetera, etcetera.

301
00:15:00,520 --> 00:15:03,640
But by large and far, as you 
said, conventional actors were 

302
00:15:03,640 --> 00:15:07,200
really happy to see themselves 
to project themselves into a 

303
00:15:07,400 --> 00:15:10,080
efficiency for scenario because 
that's what they've been doing 

304
00:15:10,080 --> 00:15:12,000
basically for the last decades 
or so. 

305
00:15:12,120 --> 00:15:16,920
And and they see quite easily 
how they could convert those 

306
00:15:16,920 --> 00:15:19,840
efficiency gains into 
competitiveness gains. 

307
00:15:20,120 --> 00:15:22,960
So for them, you know, fair 
enough, let's go for that. 

308
00:15:23,200 --> 00:15:27,080
And last thing, I guess one of 
the big challenge behind the 

309
00:15:27,080 --> 00:15:31,200
efficiency for scenario which 
also makes it very close to 

310
00:15:31,200 --> 00:15:34,960
business as usual scenario is 
that it would not go against 

311
00:15:35,040 --> 00:15:38,160
what we can call the 
commodification process of meat 

312
00:15:38,160 --> 00:15:42,040
and dairy products. 
It would continue to see and you

313
00:15:42,040 --> 00:15:44,760
know, consider all type of 
animal source foods as 

314
00:15:44,760 --> 00:15:48,680
commodities that you need to 
produce by reducing as much as 

315
00:15:48,680 --> 00:15:51,480
you can your production cost. 
Which means amongst other 

316
00:15:51,480 --> 00:15:55,400
things, making sure that you 
have concentrated supply shed 

317
00:15:55,520 --> 00:15:57,000
production systems. 
Well. 

318
00:15:57,360 --> 00:16:00,360
So basically concentrating 
animals in the same place to 

319
00:16:00,360 --> 00:16:03,760
reduce transport, transport 
costs, moving milk to the 

320
00:16:03,760 --> 00:16:08,360
dairies or meat to the houses. 
And that in turn comes with 

321
00:16:08,520 --> 00:16:12,040
massive problems of like 
nitrogen surpluses and animal 

322
00:16:12,040 --> 00:16:13,480
welfare, etcetera, etcetera, 
right? 

323
00:16:13,600 --> 00:16:15,600
And I would imagine that the 
other sort of element around 

324
00:16:15,600 --> 00:16:18,360
that is that if you've got an 
efficiency first system, which 

325
00:16:18,360 --> 00:16:20,680
is relying quite a lot on 
technology to be able to 

326
00:16:20,680 --> 00:16:23,240
deliver, you know, any of the 
environmental games or the 

327
00:16:23,240 --> 00:16:25,680
social games that are associated
with those systems. 

328
00:16:25,680 --> 00:16:28,360
Then there's the potential for 
patented technology and that 

329
00:16:28,360 --> 00:16:30,760
sort of thing, which then 
governments quite like because 

330
00:16:30,760 --> 00:16:34,200
they, they, they can envision 
them being sold on a global 

331
00:16:34,200 --> 00:16:36,720
level and therefore bringing 
money, money into the exchequer 

332
00:16:36,720 --> 00:16:38,760
in different ways as well. 
So there is this sort of 

333
00:16:38,760 --> 00:16:41,560
interesting into linkage, isn't 
there, between that efficiency 

334
00:16:41,560 --> 00:16:44,360
first scenario and the way that 
the government funds. 

335
00:16:44,360 --> 00:16:46,880
Very often it's, it's research 
funding. 

336
00:16:46,920 --> 00:16:49,800
One of the things that I really 
like about the scenarios is that

337
00:16:49,920 --> 00:16:52,400
they're really quite clear and 
they're really, they're simple 

338
00:16:52,400 --> 00:16:53,880
and straightforward to 
understand. 

339
00:16:53,880 --> 00:16:56,200
And very helpfully on the 
Pathways website, you've got 

340
00:16:56,200 --> 00:16:59,880
sort of 1 pages describing these
various different scenarios as 

341
00:16:59,880 --> 00:17:02,040
well. 
And on the efficiency first one 

342
00:17:02,040 --> 00:17:04,880
pager on the key policy 
recommendations, there's a term 

343
00:17:05,040 --> 00:17:07,440
that's in astral ecology 
approach. 

344
00:17:07,560 --> 00:17:09,400
You couldn't just explain that 
for me, could you? 

345
00:17:09,640 --> 00:17:13,400
I guess the idea behind that is 
that, as I was saying, the 

346
00:17:13,400 --> 00:17:17,680
efficiency first would in any 
case rely on concentrated 

347
00:17:17,680 --> 00:17:19,280
livestock from a special point 
of view. 

348
00:17:19,440 --> 00:17:23,599
And so this could only work, so 
to speak, from another point of 

349
00:17:23,599 --> 00:17:27,119
view. 
If you manage to recycle all, 

350
00:17:27,359 --> 00:17:30,160
you know, the byproducts, so to 
speak, of the lifestyle systems,

351
00:17:30,400 --> 00:17:32,840
so manure and how you manage to 
feed, etcetera. 

352
00:17:32,840 --> 00:17:35,280
And so we have good examples of 
the practice hub level. 

353
00:17:35,280 --> 00:17:38,360
So what we call the practice 
hubs are basically those hubs 

354
00:17:38,360 --> 00:17:41,240
where we gathered stakeholders 
from the lifestyle value chains.

355
00:17:41,560 --> 00:17:44,280
And we had a few examples across
the EU, in Denmark, in Britain, 

356
00:17:44,280 --> 00:17:48,160
in France, where, you know, at 
the slaughterhouse level, you 

357
00:17:48,160 --> 00:17:51,120
not only have, you know, animals
being slotted, but you also have

358
00:17:51,120 --> 00:17:54,520
a whole system of recycling the 
manure. 

359
00:17:54,520 --> 00:17:57,960
So basically producers are are 
asked not only to bring the 

360
00:17:57,960 --> 00:18:00,600
animals, but also the manure. 
And this means that they are 

361
00:18:00,600 --> 00:18:03,200
very close from the store, the 
house, and then the manure is 

362
00:18:03,200 --> 00:18:08,160
like dried and transforms into 
whatever kind of organic 

363
00:18:08,280 --> 00:18:10,960
fertilizers. 
And then, you know, sense away 

364
00:18:10,960 --> 00:18:14,360
from the territory to avoid 
those massive natural surpluses 

365
00:18:14,360 --> 00:18:16,840
that we're talking about. 
So you have this whole kind of 

366
00:18:16,840 --> 00:18:20,760
like ecological engineering of 
all the byproducts and all the 

367
00:18:21,080 --> 00:18:24,040
different aspects of the 
physical processes that we try 

368
00:18:24,040 --> 00:18:29,200
that stakeholders try to manage 
to limit all the side effects of

369
00:18:29,200 --> 00:18:31,480
this very high concentration 
livestock systems. 

370
00:18:31,880 --> 00:18:34,080
Yeah, interesting. 
And we've been having that 

371
00:18:34,080 --> 00:18:36,360
discussion actually just 
recently in the UK because of 

372
00:18:36,360 --> 00:18:39,080
course there there's, you know, 
the sort of limits on the amount

373
00:18:39,080 --> 00:18:41,320
of fertilizer that can be 
imported at the moment, in 

374
00:18:41,320 --> 00:18:43,560
particular because of the 
situation around the Strait of 

375
00:18:43,560 --> 00:18:44,960
Hormuz. 
And so they've been 

376
00:18:44,960 --> 00:18:48,440
conversations about whether 
fertilizer itself should be 

377
00:18:48,440 --> 00:18:50,960
subsidised, for example, or 
whether we shouldn't find ways 

378
00:18:51,120 --> 00:18:54,040
around the, you know, the big 
intensive chicken units around 

379
00:18:54,040 --> 00:18:57,680
the River Wye for example, of of
harnessing that manure, making 

380
00:18:57,680 --> 00:18:59,720
sure that it can be sold off. 
And then again, we talk about 

381
00:18:59,720 --> 00:19:02,360
those sort of synergies and 
trade-offs between systems 

382
00:19:02,360 --> 00:19:05,080
because then you've you're sort 
of creating a dependency on 

383
00:19:05,080 --> 00:19:08,920
these, these large chicken units
in order to then fuel a more 

384
00:19:08,920 --> 00:19:11,920
agroecological transition in the
East where livestock don't exist

385
00:19:11,920 --> 00:19:14,720
and where, you know, that 
fertilizer can be replaced by 

386
00:19:14,720 --> 00:19:17,280
more organic fertilizer. 
It's, it's all fascinating 

387
00:19:17,280 --> 00:19:18,960
stuff. 
There are three more pathway 

388
00:19:18,960 --> 00:19:21,320
scenarios and I just want you, 
let's talk through those before 

389
00:19:21,320 --> 00:19:23,640
we start sort of comparing them.
And I wonder if you could talk 

390
00:19:23,640 --> 00:19:26,080
me through the key features and 
learnings from the high animal 

391
00:19:26,080 --> 00:19:29,280
welfare storyline. 
So the high animal welfare 

392
00:19:29,280 --> 00:19:32,560
storyline, as Tom said earlier, 
is really decided that we, we 

393
00:19:32,560 --> 00:19:35,520
put the animal at the forefront 
of the, of the whole sector. 

394
00:19:36,160 --> 00:19:39,720
Meaning that the idea is that 
we, we give, we, we create 

395
00:19:40,600 --> 00:19:43,560
systems at the farm level, at 
the house level, at the Daily 

396
00:19:43,560 --> 00:19:47,960
Devil, where really animals can 
express its behaviors, can have 

397
00:19:47,960 --> 00:19:51,360
more choices, so to speak. 
And that comes with, so to 

398
00:19:51,360 --> 00:19:55,280
speak, radical changes and the 
way animal are rare, you know, 

399
00:19:55,280 --> 00:19:56,840
transported and then 
slaughtered. 

400
00:19:57,000 --> 00:20:01,640
I should say to to to be very 
honest that it has been quite 

401
00:20:01,640 --> 00:20:05,760
difficult to model Percy. 
The high animal welfare scenario

402
00:20:05,760 --> 00:20:09,800
because we basically don't have 
any references to put figures 

403
00:20:09,840 --> 00:20:12,680
behind what those systems would 
look like neither at the farm 

404
00:20:12,680 --> 00:20:15,760
level nor at the slaughterhouses
level nor at the, you know, 

405
00:20:15,760 --> 00:20:18,680
transportation level. 
So it's been something if you 

406
00:20:18,680 --> 00:20:21,720
look at the results for example 
of the market based modelling 

407
00:20:21,920 --> 00:20:25,800
exercise that we did for 
pathways, there is differences 

408
00:20:25,800 --> 00:20:28,440
between animal welfare and the 
business as usual scenario are 

409
00:20:28,440 --> 00:20:32,280
not that you know clear 
precisely because the team you 

410
00:20:32,280 --> 00:20:36,160
know struggles to really see 
okay, where do I implement 

411
00:20:36,160 --> 00:20:39,240
changes in the model, what does 
it mean really et cetera. 

412
00:20:39,440 --> 00:20:42,800
So we did try to do that with 
French stakeholders at a sort of

413
00:20:42,800 --> 00:20:46,880
lower level, so to speak. 
And the reasons we are quite 

414
00:20:47,320 --> 00:20:51,040
challenging because we basically
just to give an example, we did 

415
00:20:51,040 --> 00:20:54,720
decide with the poultry sector 
in France to say, OK, let's 

416
00:20:54,720 --> 00:20:59,320
assume that all half, I think it
was half, half of all the 

417
00:20:59,560 --> 00:21:03,440
chicken raised in France would 
become European chicken 

418
00:21:03,440 --> 00:21:06,640
commitments, you know, 
compliant. 

419
00:21:07,160 --> 00:21:10,560
Yeah, at that level. 
And and then we calculated what 

420
00:21:10,560 --> 00:21:13,600
it would mean because we had the
references in terms of pushing 

421
00:21:13,600 --> 00:21:17,480
cost at the farm level. 
And then we, you know, made some

422
00:21:17,800 --> 00:21:20,000
very rough assumptions at the 
sort of house level. 

423
00:21:20,640 --> 00:21:24,560
And the stakeholders with whom 
we were discussing about that 

424
00:21:24,560 --> 00:21:30,280
scenario said, hey, but we won't
bring any changes into the 

425
00:21:30,280 --> 00:21:33,640
market dynamic because we don't 
believe anything can change. 

426
00:21:33,920 --> 00:21:37,360
And the result was that 
prediction in France would drop 

427
00:21:37,360 --> 00:21:43,520
by largely 3050%, import would 
go up because basically the rest

428
00:21:43,520 --> 00:21:46,240
of the world would continue in 
the way in which they produce. 

429
00:21:46,480 --> 00:21:49,800
And so we would become not 
competitive enough. 

430
00:21:50,200 --> 00:21:52,800
So I think that was quite 
interesting to see that whatever

431
00:21:52,800 --> 00:21:54,760
the scenario and for that 
scenario in particular, because 

432
00:21:54,760 --> 00:21:58,400
it's the most radical probably 
if you don't reflect your 

433
00:21:58,400 --> 00:22:01,760
ambition into whatever trade 
measures or market measures, 

434
00:22:02,200 --> 00:22:04,720
it's really complicated in the 
world in which we live. 

435
00:22:04,920 --> 00:22:07,840
So, so what's the sort of key 
finding, I guess there that this

436
00:22:07,840 --> 00:22:10,160
was something that was intensely
difficult to do at a national 

437
00:22:10,160 --> 00:22:14,000
level because other nations, 
whether those were the European 

438
00:22:14,000 --> 00:22:16,760
nations or, or other nations 
around the world would, would 

439
00:22:16,760 --> 00:22:19,760
sort of step in to fill that 
void because of the demand still

440
00:22:19,760 --> 00:22:21,280
exist, yeah. 
Interesting. 

441
00:22:21,600 --> 00:22:23,800
Exactly. 
Yeah, because I mean, just to, 

442
00:22:23,800 --> 00:22:28,520
to put it very simply, with the 
same, let's say the same size, 

443
00:22:28,520 --> 00:22:33,080
the same farm size in poultry, 
if you go for very high animal 

444
00:22:33,080 --> 00:22:36,120
welfare standards, your level of
prediction just is just cut by 

445
00:22:36,120 --> 00:22:38,600
two or even 3 depending on the 
standards you get. 

446
00:22:38,720 --> 00:22:42,320
So basically your total 
production would go down while 

447
00:22:42,320 --> 00:22:44,760
production costs would go up. 
And so just sort of working on 

448
00:22:44,760 --> 00:22:47,720
the basis for a moment, I 
suppose that that, you know, 

449
00:22:47,720 --> 00:22:51,240
there was a way of having a 
border around around this policy

450
00:22:51,240 --> 00:22:54,440
and that, you know, high animal 
welfare was delivered across 

451
00:22:54,440 --> 00:22:57,280
Europe and there were there 
weren't going to be imports sort

452
00:22:57,280 --> 00:23:00,120
of coming in to fill that void. 
Was there going to be an impact 

453
00:23:00,240 --> 00:23:04,520
on the availability of of 
protein, for example, for poorer

454
00:23:04,520 --> 00:23:06,440
European citizens? 
Was there a sort of an 

455
00:23:06,440 --> 00:23:10,040
expectation that that meat, for 
example, or, you know, certain 

456
00:23:10,040 --> 00:23:13,360
cheeses would become become the 
preserve of of the middle 

457
00:23:13,360 --> 00:23:16,480
classes and and the richer sort 
of elements of the population? 

458
00:23:16,480 --> 00:23:18,640
I. 
Mean that's for sure, assuming 

459
00:23:18,640 --> 00:23:21,560
that, you know, the the markets 
protected and that, you know, 

460
00:23:21,560 --> 00:23:24,360
adopting the students would not 
lead to massive imports. 

461
00:23:24,600 --> 00:23:28,480
Prices would go up, that's 
clear, and availability would go

462
00:23:28,480 --> 00:23:30,920
down and the 2GO together of of 
obviously. 

463
00:23:31,240 --> 00:23:35,320
And I guess we should not, you 
know, underestimate how much 

464
00:23:35,320 --> 00:23:38,760
less animal source food you can 
produce if you really want to 

465
00:23:38,760 --> 00:23:41,280
respect, let's say, animal 
choices. 

466
00:23:41,720 --> 00:23:46,840
So indeed, that raises the 
question of like, well, for whom

467
00:23:47,320 --> 00:23:49,880
meat and dairy products remain 
affordable. 

468
00:23:50,160 --> 00:23:51,880
And there's such a scenario, 
right? 

469
00:23:52,160 --> 00:23:55,400
And is that something that we 
should care about? 

470
00:23:55,520 --> 00:23:58,880
Definitely, yes. 
But I guess it directly points 

471
00:23:58,880 --> 00:24:02,800
to the question of the difficult
question of the needs, right? 

472
00:24:02,800 --> 00:24:07,880
In the sense that basically 
consuming 76 between 65 and 75 

473
00:24:07,880 --> 00:24:11,480
grams of animal proteins a day 
has nothing to do with our 

474
00:24:11,480 --> 00:24:14,400
needs. 
We need probably like 25 to 40 

475
00:24:14,400 --> 00:24:17,080
grams depending on who we are, 
what age we have, etcetera, 

476
00:24:17,080 --> 00:24:20,880
etcetera, which basically means 
that even though it would 

477
00:24:20,880 --> 00:24:25,320
become, you know, more expensive
and we will, we would be less 

478
00:24:25,400 --> 00:24:29,280
able to buy it for most of the 
population, that would not lead 

479
00:24:29,280 --> 00:24:34,160
to any nutritional problems. 
While at the same time, if this 

480
00:24:34,160 --> 00:24:38,280
is accompanied by a drop or at 
least you know, incentives to 

481
00:24:38,280 --> 00:24:42,600
buy more fruits and veg, you 
know, which we really miss in 

482
00:24:42,600 --> 00:24:46,480
our daily diets, that would only
be good for all of us from a 

483
00:24:46,480 --> 00:24:48,640
health perspective. 
So that's a little bit the 

484
00:24:48,640 --> 00:24:50,280
challenge. 
And we did some calculation on 

485
00:24:50,280 --> 00:24:53,680
that at the French level again. 
And what we showed was that to 

486
00:24:53,680 --> 00:24:57,040
you, you could think about a 
world where all the households 

487
00:24:57,040 --> 00:25:01,360
from the poorest to the richest 
would eat 20 to 30% less animal 

488
00:25:01,360 --> 00:25:07,320
source foods, eating 50% more 
fruits and veg, while assuming, 

489
00:25:07,520 --> 00:25:11,080
you know, 20% increase in unit 
prices of the product. 

490
00:25:11,120 --> 00:25:14,520
And you would still be able to 
afford your, you know, food 

491
00:25:14,520 --> 00:25:17,800
basket with the smallest same 
price with no increase in 

492
00:25:17,800 --> 00:25:20,880
prices. 
So that that shows that it's not

493
00:25:20,880 --> 00:25:23,560
only about prices, but it's all 
about also about, you know, 

494
00:25:23,800 --> 00:25:27,400
choice households habits and 
purchasing willingness. 

495
00:25:27,400 --> 00:25:29,360
Whatever. 
Yeah, That's really fascinating.

496
00:25:29,360 --> 00:25:31,240
And it's a conversation that 
we've had on the podcast at 

497
00:25:31,240 --> 00:25:33,160
various different points over 
the last few years. 

498
00:25:33,160 --> 00:25:35,600
And it's really interesting to 
hear the way that you framed it 

499
00:25:35,600 --> 00:25:39,080
there, that even if food prices 
go up, the cost of a food basket

500
00:25:39,080 --> 00:25:41,720
can remain the same depending on
the different dietary choices 

501
00:25:41,720 --> 00:25:43,520
that people are making within 
that now. 

502
00:25:43,760 --> 00:25:46,040
And Tom and Jessica, thanks for 
so much for being patient. 

503
00:25:46,040 --> 00:25:48,520
And I know that, you know, we're
spending a lot of time with PM 

504
00:25:48,520 --> 00:25:50,480
Marie here, but I think, you 
know, going through these 

505
00:25:50,480 --> 00:25:52,960
scenarios before we sort of 
discuss them together is really,

506
00:25:53,160 --> 00:25:56,280
really interesting in the first 
instance and important as well. 

507
00:25:56,400 --> 00:25:58,600
So there's two to go. 
And the scenario that focuses 

508
00:25:58,600 --> 00:26:01,920
perhaps most strongly on 
biodiversity and agroecology is 

509
00:26:01,920 --> 00:26:05,920
the feed no food scenario where 
livestock are primarily grazed 

510
00:26:05,920 --> 00:26:10,160
on grass and fed on waste 
products if they're monogastrix.

511
00:26:10,520 --> 00:26:14,120
The aim is to optimize food 
production for human consumption

512
00:26:14,120 --> 00:26:16,880
rather than growing food 
specifically to feed livestock. 

513
00:26:17,120 --> 00:26:19,800
Could you just talk me through 
the storyline, the primary 

514
00:26:19,800 --> 00:26:22,480
features, why it's important, 
what the key trade-offs are? 

515
00:26:22,720 --> 00:26:25,800
So indeed, as you said, to feed 
no food scenario is probably the

516
00:26:25,800 --> 00:26:29,000
most agrological scenario that 
we developed. 

517
00:26:29,160 --> 00:26:33,240
And I I think we didn't call it 
like that because we wouldn't we

518
00:26:33,240 --> 00:26:36,520
really wanted it to be. 
As I said again, animals focused

519
00:26:36,520 --> 00:26:39,080
animal sentence. 
Also from the from the title 

520
00:26:39,080 --> 00:26:41,920
point of view, As for animal 
welfare, we should not 

521
00:26:41,920 --> 00:26:47,480
underestimate the effects of 
feeding animals with no food 

522
00:26:47,480 --> 00:26:50,440
competitive food stuff. 
It has dramatic consequence on 

523
00:26:50,440 --> 00:26:54,000
how much that you can produce 
and it has a 2 fold effect. 

524
00:26:54,000 --> 00:26:56,800
Basically the first effect is 
that you know how much 

525
00:26:57,000 --> 00:26:59,840
byproducts and non food 
competitive feed stuff is 

526
00:26:59,840 --> 00:27:02,960
available means that you cannot 
feed as many animals as we do 

527
00:27:02,960 --> 00:27:04,680
today. 
So you have less animals. 

528
00:27:04,840 --> 00:27:07,560
But the other thing is that 
let's be very clear as well. 

529
00:27:07,720 --> 00:27:11,120
The quality of the feed from a 
productivity point of view is 

530
00:27:11,120 --> 00:27:13,880
lower. 
So the the animal productivity 

531
00:27:13,880 --> 00:27:16,280
so to speak. 
So the amount of meat, milk or 

532
00:27:16,280 --> 00:27:19,480
eggs that is produced pair 
anymore is lower. 

533
00:27:19,680 --> 00:27:22,600
So you have this twofold effect 
and I mean depending on how you 

534
00:27:22,600 --> 00:27:24,760
model it, what assumptions you 
make, etcetera. 

535
00:27:25,080 --> 00:27:28,600
But you get to a world where or 
to a European life successor 

536
00:27:28,600 --> 00:27:34,400
where pension is decreased has 
decreased by between 30 and 50%,

537
00:27:34,480 --> 00:27:36,120
right. 
That's the, that's the hard 

538
00:27:36,360 --> 00:27:40,200
truth, so to speak, or the hard 
calculations we we got to in 

539
00:27:40,200 --> 00:27:43,160
such a scenario, which is, you 
know, similar to a high demand 

540
00:27:43,160 --> 00:27:45,840
welfare scenario. 
When you say that, I'm just sort

541
00:27:45,840 --> 00:27:48,440
of wondering around, even though
there's a reduction and the 

542
00:27:48,520 --> 00:27:51,120
perhaps the amount of meat and 
dairy that's coming from those 

543
00:27:51,120 --> 00:27:52,880
animals. 
I'm wondering whether you looked

544
00:27:52,880 --> 00:27:54,560
at nutritional levels? 
Because I think one of the 

545
00:27:54,560 --> 00:27:56,960
things that I hear a lot from 
regenerative farmers is that 

546
00:27:57,160 --> 00:28:00,800
they think that the nutritional 
contents, the value of the food 

547
00:28:00,800 --> 00:28:02,960
that's being produced is much 
greater than it would be. 

548
00:28:02,960 --> 00:28:05,280
And therefore you potentially 
need less of it to get the 

549
00:28:05,280 --> 00:28:08,120
nutritional value. 
Yeah, well, I guess overall you 

550
00:28:08,480 --> 00:28:11,880
definitely don't need to eat as 
much animal protein as we eat 

551
00:28:11,880 --> 00:28:13,600
today. 
So, you know, whatever the 

552
00:28:13,600 --> 00:28:16,960
quality of that animals false 
food, you know, eating less of 

553
00:28:16,960 --> 00:28:19,800
those is, is not modeling itself
for anyone. 

554
00:28:20,280 --> 00:28:23,880
Again, 70g compared to the 30 to
50 grams we need a day. 

555
00:28:23,880 --> 00:28:27,640
So you can cut by half. 
So without any problems there. 

556
00:28:28,000 --> 00:28:31,880
And I guess yeah, that that's 
true that from the dairy and 

557
00:28:31,880 --> 00:28:35,680
beef point of view, it's been 
shown that grass fed animals 

558
00:28:35,960 --> 00:28:39,280
produce meat and dairy products 
that are of higher neutral 

559
00:28:39,280 --> 00:28:41,920
quality on fatty acids, 
composition, etcetera. 

560
00:28:41,920 --> 00:28:44,080
That's true. 
And that's that's great. 

561
00:28:44,240 --> 00:28:47,720
But, but, but I think it, it 
could be an argument, but we, we

562
00:28:47,720 --> 00:28:50,040
should put that in a broader 
context of like, well, the fact 

563
00:28:50,040 --> 00:28:52,360
that we don't need as much 
animal product as we eat today. 

564
00:28:52,560 --> 00:28:54,120
Yeah. 
And I remember the work that you

565
00:28:54,120 --> 00:28:57,200
did a few years ago, which, you 
know, was around the whole sort 

566
00:28:57,200 --> 00:29:00,360
of agroecology question as well.
I think it was can agroecology 

567
00:29:00,360 --> 00:29:02,600
Feed Europe was the essential 
question that you were 

568
00:29:02,600 --> 00:29:04,360
addressing. 
And you later transposed that to

569
00:29:04,360 --> 00:29:06,560
the UK as well with the Food 
Farming and Countryside 

570
00:29:06,560 --> 00:29:08,920
Commission. 
And my memory is that the answer

571
00:29:09,040 --> 00:29:12,760
was basically, yes, agroecology 
can feed Europe, no problem 

572
00:29:12,760 --> 00:29:14,640
there. 
But as we've just been 

573
00:29:14,640 --> 00:29:16,600
discussing, diets would have to 
change. 

574
00:29:16,920 --> 00:29:19,160
And I'm just wondering, you 
know, not just about diets, but 

575
00:29:19,160 --> 00:29:21,880
how value chains would shift 
within the feed no food 

576
00:29:21,880 --> 00:29:24,640
scenario. 
So we, we also did some further 

577
00:29:24,640 --> 00:29:28,680
calculations about that and I, I
guess it speaks again to this 

578
00:29:28,680 --> 00:29:30,600
question of animal 
concentration, special 

579
00:29:30,600 --> 00:29:32,200
concentration that I mentioned 
earlier. 

580
00:29:32,560 --> 00:29:35,600
If you go for a feed no food 
scenario, you basically would 

581
00:29:35,600 --> 00:29:38,520
have animals, you know, 
scattered all over the Europe 

582
00:29:38,520 --> 00:29:41,440
instead of being concentrated 
here and there in Brittany, the 

583
00:29:41,440 --> 00:29:42,920
Mark, Netherlands, etc. 
And islands. 

584
00:29:43,080 --> 00:29:47,320
Which basically means that the 
very structure of logistic 

585
00:29:47,320 --> 00:29:50,840
chains, value chains would have 
to change and the facilities as 

586
00:29:50,840 --> 00:29:53,400
well. 
There is other houses, I mean as

587
00:29:53,400 --> 00:29:57,320
they are today has basically 
nothing to do so to speak with 

588
00:29:57,320 --> 00:29:59,240
the reality of a feed no food 
scenario. 

589
00:29:59,320 --> 00:30:03,520
There are way too large way to 
automatize for the kind of 

590
00:30:03,760 --> 00:30:05,720
production system we would have 
in the future. 

591
00:30:06,120 --> 00:30:10,080
So in that sense we did with my 
colleague Michael Esquerbo, we, 

592
00:30:10,080 --> 00:30:15,200
we did try to figure out what it
would mean if France would go 

593
00:30:15,200 --> 00:30:17,240
towards a fully feed no food 
scenario. 

594
00:30:17,560 --> 00:30:20,800
And the result is that it would 
basically lead most of the 

595
00:30:20,800 --> 00:30:23,800
largest slaughterhouses and 
dairies to, you know, quit the 

596
00:30:23,800 --> 00:30:28,600
market because transport costs 
are basically too important and 

597
00:30:28,880 --> 00:30:31,640
are more important than the 
economies of scale you can make 

598
00:30:31,840 --> 00:30:37,040
by staying big while being 
remotely located with the DDD 

599
00:30:37,040 --> 00:30:38,720
demos. 
And that would also lead to 

600
00:30:38,720 --> 00:30:43,880
smaller units to be recreated 
closer to the animals in the 

601
00:30:43,880 --> 00:30:46,640
massive central island, 
wherever, wherever you look at 

602
00:30:46,640 --> 00:30:48,480
that. 
So we, we had a specially 

603
00:30:48,480 --> 00:30:52,320
explicit model that that was, 
you know, that enabled us to, to

604
00:30:52,320 --> 00:30:55,640
really characterize that. 
But overall that that's again, 

605
00:30:55,640 --> 00:30:58,960
some sort of a, you know, 
difficult thing to handle. 

606
00:30:59,320 --> 00:31:02,640
It's also that the number of 
jobs and the overall value 

607
00:31:02,640 --> 00:31:05,600
generated by the the sexual 
would go down quite 

608
00:31:05,600 --> 00:31:09,800
significantly by 30 to 50%. 
And again, so that's, that's not

609
00:31:09,800 --> 00:31:12,960
an easy story to tell to the 
world and to policy makers and 

610
00:31:12,960 --> 00:31:15,200
stakeholders. 
So that's something that we 

611
00:31:15,200 --> 00:31:18,280
usually don't want to consider 
that much because we say, hey, 

612
00:31:18,400 --> 00:31:21,240
it's less and better. 
Wow, it's less and better, yes, 

613
00:31:21,240 --> 00:31:24,240
from an algorithm point of view,
but from a mechanic point of 

614
00:31:24,240 --> 00:31:26,920
view it might be less and less. 
That's interesting because I 

615
00:31:26,920 --> 00:31:30,160
think the way that I've always 
sort of thought about it and, 

616
00:31:30,200 --> 00:31:32,840
and you know, perhaps your 
numbers there are, are telling a

617
00:31:32,840 --> 00:31:35,880
different story is that if you 
know, for example, thinking 

618
00:31:35,880 --> 00:31:39,400
about the UK, if the murder did 
feel abattoir, which is, you 

619
00:31:39,400 --> 00:31:42,640
know, pretty enormous, we're to 
close and we were to see a, a 

620
00:31:42,640 --> 00:31:45,800
resurgence of small 
infrastructure, a small 

621
00:31:45,800 --> 00:31:48,880
abattoirs, then you're actually 
creating more jobs as a result 

622
00:31:48,880 --> 00:31:50,160
of that. 
They're being displaced and 

623
00:31:50,160 --> 00:31:52,880
they're being moved around. 
And so I, I guess it's arguable,

624
00:31:52,880 --> 00:31:55,320
isn't it, depending on, 
depending on exactly what that 

625
00:31:55,320 --> 00:31:57,840
solution is and what the, the 
infrastructure response is. 

626
00:31:57,840 --> 00:31:59,880
And I guess that brings us, 
doesn't it to the rural 

627
00:31:59,880 --> 00:32:04,360
renaissance scenario, which is, 
which is looking at the the way 

628
00:32:04,360 --> 00:32:08,080
in which livestock can 
contribute to a a renewed rural 

629
00:32:08,080 --> 00:32:11,000
economy, to a strong rural 
economy, which which frankly, 

630
00:32:11,320 --> 00:32:14,240
you know, doesn't exist in that 
many places I don't think around

631
00:32:14,240 --> 00:32:16,360
Europe at the moment. 
So what's the purpose of this 

632
00:32:16,360 --> 00:32:18,240
storyline? 
Again, the key elements. 

633
00:32:18,440 --> 00:32:20,800
What were the main challenges 
that you identified here? 

634
00:32:21,000 --> 00:32:23,600
Let let me come back to the 
point you made just before very 

635
00:32:23,600 --> 00:32:25,640
quickly. 
I, I think the question you're, 

636
00:32:25,640 --> 00:32:28,720
you're raising with like whether
relocating about war would be 

637
00:32:28,720 --> 00:32:31,680
good or not, whatever it has to 
do with what we can call the 

638
00:32:31,680 --> 00:32:33,560
labour intensity of the 
processing. 

639
00:32:33,840 --> 00:32:37,200
And what is true is that in the 
dairy sector, depending on in 

640
00:32:37,200 --> 00:32:40,640
what which pipes you send the 
day the the the milk, you 

641
00:32:40,640 --> 00:32:43,560
basically have very contrasted 
labor intensity. 

642
00:32:43,840 --> 00:32:47,760
So you can have a decoupling 
between volumes and value in 

643
00:32:47,760 --> 00:32:49,320
jobs. 
In the dairy sector that is 

644
00:32:49,320 --> 00:32:51,440
true. 
You can have like 20% less milk 

645
00:32:51,560 --> 00:32:54,560
and the same amount of value and
jobs created right in the mid 

646
00:32:54,560 --> 00:32:57,320
sector when you have an animal, 
you stutter it and you get into 

647
00:32:57,320 --> 00:33:00,160
pieces full stop. 
So it doesn't matter that much 

648
00:33:00,160 --> 00:33:03,640
if you have a bigger trois or 
small 1, you have like nearly 

649
00:33:03,640 --> 00:33:06,920
like 5 to 10% difference in 
labor intensity, not more. 

650
00:33:07,080 --> 00:33:10,160
Which means that if you decrease
the volumes, you decrease the 

651
00:33:10,160 --> 00:33:13,040
values and the number of jobs 
even, you know, not that much 

652
00:33:13,040 --> 00:33:15,800
because you know, you, you have 
this slight difference in labor 

653
00:33:15,800 --> 00:33:18,680
intensity. 
That being said, it relates very

654
00:33:18,680 --> 00:33:20,560
much to the reward renaissance 
scenario. 

655
00:33:20,560 --> 00:33:24,160
That is why, you know, I, I, I 
was keen to, to make the point 

656
00:33:24,160 --> 00:33:28,120
because the reward Renaissance 
scenario again was not that easy

657
00:33:28,120 --> 00:33:31,120
to model because there are many 
ways in which you can translate 

658
00:33:31,120 --> 00:33:34,720
the story into quantitative 
parameters and into a scenario 

659
00:33:34,720 --> 00:33:37,400
depending on like again, what 
model you use and, and what all 

660
00:33:37,400 --> 00:33:38,840
the stakeholders are on the 
table, right. 

661
00:33:39,280 --> 00:33:42,760
So the way in which we did that 
in in the French exercise, which

662
00:33:42,760 --> 00:33:45,680
was a bit different from what 
was done at the at the EU level 

663
00:33:45,680 --> 00:33:50,000
with the market based model, was
that we we assume that if we 

664
00:33:50,000 --> 00:33:54,960
want the livestock sector to 
play this central role in rural 

665
00:33:54,960 --> 00:33:59,160
economies, it probably needs to 
be very different from one place

666
00:33:59,240 --> 00:34:01,520
to another place. 
There are places where you would

667
00:34:01,520 --> 00:34:05,360
still have, let's say, commodity
focused production systems from 

668
00:34:05,360 --> 00:34:07,200
the farm to the other tour to 
the Davis. 

669
00:34:07,480 --> 00:34:10,040
And there are some places where 
basically the only way in which 

670
00:34:10,040 --> 00:34:13,920
the life successor can thrive is
to have high value added is to 

671
00:34:13,920 --> 00:34:16,440
produce high value added 
products, you know, towards 

672
00:34:16,440 --> 00:34:19,040
niche markets and stuff. 
So basically in the way in which

673
00:34:19,040 --> 00:34:22,760
we have modelled it, the rural 
Renaissance scenario is a bit of

674
00:34:22,760 --> 00:34:25,719
a mix between feed, no food and 
efficiency. 

675
00:34:25,719 --> 00:34:31,080
First, in the sense that where 
you have capacities, skills and 

676
00:34:31,080 --> 00:34:34,800
potential to do, let's say 
commodities, you do them and you

677
00:34:34,800 --> 00:34:37,239
improve them the way in which 
you produce them, etc. 

678
00:34:37,719 --> 00:34:40,560
And where you have, you know, 
capacities to do this kind of 

679
00:34:40,560 --> 00:34:44,440
like high value product, you do 
them, but you increase how much 

680
00:34:44,440 --> 00:34:47,920
you do and, and, and you improve
the the overall quality of that.

681
00:34:48,120 --> 00:34:50,760
This in a context where, I mean,
we should be very clear about 

682
00:34:50,760 --> 00:34:52,400
that. 
Even though the European Union 

683
00:34:52,400 --> 00:34:54,639
puts the emphasis strongly on 
the fact that we have an 

684
00:34:54,639 --> 00:34:56,320
excellent livestock sector, 
blah, blah, blah. 

685
00:34:56,320 --> 00:35:00,600
Our ability in many countries 
and in French in particular, to 

686
00:35:00,600 --> 00:35:04,360
really sell our products to the 
rest of the world under the 

687
00:35:04,360 --> 00:35:07,520
banner of excellence has 
weakened over the last few years

688
00:35:07,720 --> 00:35:09,560
because, you know, the rest of 
the world does not necessarily 

689
00:35:09,680 --> 00:35:11,920
continue to want that. 
They have their own way of 

690
00:35:11,920 --> 00:35:13,000
producing this and that and 
that. 

691
00:35:13,240 --> 00:35:15,440
So the only ones that are really
able to do that at the moment in

692
00:35:15,440 --> 00:35:18,480
Europe are the Italians, you 
know. 

693
00:35:18,800 --> 00:35:22,600
So, so just to say that real 
Renaissance assumes that there 

694
00:35:22,600 --> 00:35:26,800
is also demand for both types of
products, the communities and 

695
00:35:26,800 --> 00:35:30,080
let's say the high quality 
projects from whatever point of 

696
00:35:30,080 --> 00:35:31,560
view. 
And that's not necessarily the 

697
00:35:31,560 --> 00:35:33,640
case today. 
So the real Renaissance scenario

698
00:35:33,640 --> 00:35:37,760
is also one scenario that relies
on a certain, in a certain 

699
00:35:37,760 --> 00:35:41,560
sense, on an evolution of the 
demand, both the domestic demand

700
00:35:41,560 --> 00:35:44,360
at the EU plus UK level, but 
also of the world demand, 

701
00:35:44,360 --> 00:35:46,960
because there would be a need 
for the rest of the world to be 

702
00:35:46,960 --> 00:35:48,640
interested in those kind of 
projects. 

703
00:35:48,720 --> 00:35:50,800
The way that you're describing 
that, it's slightly different, I

704
00:35:50,800 --> 00:35:53,200
think to the way that I'd 
imagined it because I'd, I'd 

705
00:35:53,200 --> 00:35:55,600
sort of imagined it being much 
more closely linked to I, I 

706
00:35:55,600 --> 00:35:58,240
suppose to that sort of 
agroecological feed, no food. 

707
00:35:58,240 --> 00:36:01,200
But the, but you're talking 
about it being a combination of,

708
00:36:01,400 --> 00:36:03,600
of both that and the efficiency 
first. 

709
00:36:03,600 --> 00:36:07,120
And, and in that way, it feels 
like it's a, it's, it's kind of 

710
00:36:07,120 --> 00:36:10,160
a bridge towards the feed, no 
food, a bridge towards the 

711
00:36:10,160 --> 00:36:12,760
agroecological model where, you 
know, we've got to get there. 

712
00:36:12,760 --> 00:36:14,760
We already have the 
infrastructure set up in the way

713
00:36:14,760 --> 00:36:17,880
that it is. 
So how do we move from, from one

714
00:36:17,880 --> 00:36:19,600
to the other? 
And, and that would be one way 

715
00:36:19,600 --> 00:36:21,960
of doing it. 
And of course, towards the end 

716
00:36:21,960 --> 00:36:24,240
of your answer there, you were 
sort of coming towards those, 

717
00:36:24,680 --> 00:36:27,160
those, those sort of financial 
model elements. 

718
00:36:27,160 --> 00:36:31,440
And I'm guessing that for this 
storyline to work to manifest 

719
00:36:31,440 --> 00:36:33,840
itself, we'd need to see a 
significant shift in where the 

720
00:36:33,840 --> 00:36:36,520
profit goes, wouldn't we? 
The the idea of profit moving 

721
00:36:36,680 --> 00:36:40,320
away at least a little from 
retail shareholders, for 

722
00:36:40,320 --> 00:36:43,600
example, and back towards the 
farm gate, there's sort of, you 

723
00:36:43,600 --> 00:36:46,040
know, profit moving back down 
the value chain. 

724
00:36:46,080 --> 00:36:49,960
Are there any downsides to that?
Well, I guess the question is, 

725
00:36:49,960 --> 00:36:55,600
is how much do we understand 
about the value distribution 

726
00:36:55,600 --> 00:36:58,000
across value chains. 
I mean, there is there is this 

727
00:36:58,000 --> 00:37:02,480
idea that farmers are the ones 
that are the least, so to speak,

728
00:37:03,120 --> 00:37:05,760
you know, remunerated for, for 
what they produce while 

729
00:37:05,760 --> 00:37:08,520
downstream the chains you have 
big shareholders, you know, 

730
00:37:08,520 --> 00:37:10,240
making a lot of profits, et 
cetera, et cetera. 

731
00:37:10,400 --> 00:37:12,960
We've made some stupid 
calculations just to kind of 

732
00:37:12,960 --> 00:37:15,920
like try to objectify that a 
little bit and looking at a big 

733
00:37:15,920 --> 00:37:19,800
dairy company that I would not 
name here that is making a lot 

734
00:37:19,800 --> 00:37:23,480
of profits, right. 
And we did divided the overall 

735
00:37:23,480 --> 00:37:26,680
profit made by the company by 
the number of farmers that are 

736
00:37:26,680 --> 00:37:29,440
supplying the company. 
And at the end of the day, even 

737
00:37:29,440 --> 00:37:33,160
though all the profits were 
redistributed to farmers, it 

738
00:37:33,160 --> 00:37:36,560
would mean roughly €1000 more 
per year. 

739
00:37:37,240 --> 00:37:39,680
You're not going to do the 
transition with thousand €1000 

740
00:37:39,680 --> 00:37:42,480
more on your farm a year, right?
You need more than that. 

741
00:37:42,840 --> 00:37:45,320
So I think we should be very 
clear about the fact that there 

742
00:37:45,320 --> 00:37:47,600
are two different problems. 
There is one problem, which is 

743
00:37:47,600 --> 00:37:51,360
that of, let's put it like that,
social justice, how equitable is

744
00:37:51,360 --> 00:37:53,120
our food system? 
And we need to address that 

745
00:37:53,120 --> 00:37:55,720
problem. 
But we should not believe that 

746
00:37:56,000 --> 00:37:58,880
once that problem will be 
addressed, all the rest will be 

747
00:37:58,880 --> 00:38:00,480
solved. 
I think those are two different 

748
00:38:00,480 --> 00:38:02,320
problems. 
My understanding is that at the 

749
00:38:02,320 --> 00:38:05,480
moment, what is putting pressure
on farmers and volition actors 

750
00:38:05,480 --> 00:38:10,080
alike has probably a bit to do 
with an equal Power Distribution

751
00:38:10,080 --> 00:38:11,680
across the chain. 
Fair enough. 

752
00:38:12,080 --> 00:38:15,280
But also with the fact that as 
we've been discussing, all those

753
00:38:15,280 --> 00:38:17,760
products, meat and dairy 
products are basically 

754
00:38:17,760 --> 00:38:21,840
commodities for 90% of the 
market, meaning that at at some 

755
00:38:21,840 --> 00:38:25,400
point you need to align with 
world market prices. 

756
00:38:25,640 --> 00:38:29,000
When you know that the Thai 
producers, the Brazilian 

757
00:38:29,000 --> 00:38:32,960
producers, they are able to 
produce 1 kilogram of poultry 

758
00:38:33,240 --> 00:38:37,800
with like 30 to 40% lower 
approaching cost, you can easily

759
00:38:37,800 --> 00:38:41,880
understand how difficult it is 
for all the Virginian actors 

760
00:38:41,880 --> 00:38:46,360
from the farmer to Salter houses
to the potatoes to realign with 

761
00:38:46,360 --> 00:38:48,400
that. 
And the reality is that we still

762
00:38:48,400 --> 00:38:52,840
have like 30% trade tariffs on 
poultry in Europe because 

763
00:38:52,840 --> 00:38:55,960
basically if we were to have 
like 0 tariffs, we were a bit, 

764
00:38:55,960 --> 00:38:59,560
we would basically be eating 
Brazilian and Thai poultry. 

765
00:38:59,760 --> 00:39:01,520
And that's, you know, that's the
situation. 

766
00:39:01,640 --> 00:39:04,640
So I think we should, you know, 
there is the market, there is 

767
00:39:04,640 --> 00:39:07,640
the very change question, but 
there is also the, the, let's 

768
00:39:07,640 --> 00:39:11,320
say the market economy question,
which is probably as important 

769
00:39:11,320 --> 00:39:13,640
as the former. 
And, and I think within that, I 

770
00:39:13,640 --> 00:39:15,720
was sort of getting the 
impression as well that, you 

771
00:39:15,720 --> 00:39:19,280
know, it, it's not just about 
farmers and the shareholders 

772
00:39:19,280 --> 00:39:20,920
that there's an awful lot of of 
people in between. 

773
00:39:20,920 --> 00:39:23,520
So if, for example, we were, you
know, shifting to a situation 

774
00:39:23,520 --> 00:39:25,800
where an awful lot of that 
profit was being held on farm 

775
00:39:25,800 --> 00:39:28,680
because the farmers were doing 
their own processing and their 

776
00:39:28,680 --> 00:39:30,960
own marketing and all this sort 
of stuff, then then actually 

777
00:39:30,960 --> 00:39:34,040
there's a whole impact on the 
jobs that are higher up the 

778
00:39:34,040 --> 00:39:36,480
value chain, but below the 
shareholders themselves. 

779
00:39:36,480 --> 00:39:39,200
And so, you know, understanding 
that impact on the economy 

780
00:39:39,200 --> 00:39:42,520
alongside everything else, you 
know, is it would be, you know, 

781
00:39:42,520 --> 00:39:45,360
and is really interesting. 
So we've heard outlines there, 

782
00:39:45,360 --> 00:39:47,080
haven't we? 
For for the five different 

783
00:39:47,080 --> 00:39:49,920
scenarios, each individually 
interesting in their own right 

784
00:39:49,920 --> 00:39:51,720
of of course, but what do we do 
with them? 

785
00:39:51,720 --> 00:39:53,920
What do we do with them now? 
How do we put them together 

786
00:39:54,040 --> 00:39:56,760
within the Pathways project? 
Yeah, I mean, what we've been 

787
00:39:56,760 --> 00:39:59,200
trying to do. 
And yesterday Tom spoke about 

788
00:39:59,200 --> 00:40:01,160
the, the, the, the government we
had in Brussels. 

789
00:40:01,160 --> 00:40:03,280
I mean, the European Union is 
preparing. 

790
00:40:04,080 --> 00:40:08,880
So-called livestock strategy 
whereby the idea is to give 

791
00:40:09,120 --> 00:40:13,240
visions and guidelines for how 
policy makers at the national 

792
00:40:13,240 --> 00:40:16,760
and EU level should treat the 
livestock sector in terms of 

793
00:40:16,760 --> 00:40:19,400
subsidies, in terms of 
regulations etcetera, etcetera. 

794
00:40:19,440 --> 00:40:22,200
What what we've been trying to 
do with the Pathway project and 

795
00:40:22,200 --> 00:40:24,600
all our organizations involving 
the project has been to really 

796
00:40:25,040 --> 00:40:29,280
help and support policymakers in
designing this livestock 

797
00:40:29,280 --> 00:40:35,080
strategy so as to reflect some 
of our findings at least in how 

798
00:40:35,080 --> 00:40:38,920
subsidies will be, you know 
Petro farmers, what regulations 

799
00:40:39,040 --> 00:40:41,160
should be given the priority 
etcetera, etcetera. 

800
00:40:41,320 --> 00:40:44,200
So that's the one of the thing 
that we have been trying to do 

801
00:40:44,200 --> 00:40:47,040
with Pathways. 
The other thing being that I 

802
00:40:47,040 --> 00:40:50,920
guess I hope at least that with 
pathways we've tried to take, 

803
00:40:51,080 --> 00:40:53,280
you know, I don't like that much
at all, but to take a sort of a 

804
00:40:53,280 --> 00:40:56,120
holistic or systemic view on the
life successor. 

805
00:40:56,280 --> 00:41:00,240
And, and we're trying to really 
get that into further future 

806
00:41:00,240 --> 00:41:02,800
research and trying to get our 
colleagues from other 

807
00:41:02,800 --> 00:41:05,320
universities, from other 
research centers to really take 

808
00:41:05,320 --> 00:41:07,880
step back and stop, you know, 
looking only at OK efficiency 

809
00:41:07,880 --> 00:41:11,760
gains at the animal level, but 
rather, OK, how does this 

810
00:41:11,760 --> 00:41:15,360
efficiency gain fit into a 
broader evolution of the whole 

811
00:41:15,360 --> 00:41:17,080
sector? 
Thanks so much for that. 

812
00:41:17,080 --> 00:41:19,240
I think that's it. 
It's been really interesting 

813
00:41:19,240 --> 00:41:21,720
hearing about the work that 
you've been doing and and that 

814
00:41:21,720 --> 00:41:24,560
conversation that we've been 
having, PM Marie through those 

815
00:41:24,560 --> 00:41:27,320
different scenarios. 
But Tom, just bringing you in, 

816
00:41:27,320 --> 00:41:30,040
as we discussed in a previous 
episode, your interest is in 

817
00:41:30,040 --> 00:41:32,320
biodiversity and monitoring 
biodiversity. 

818
00:41:32,520 --> 00:41:36,040
How do the scenarios help you to
think about the trade-offs 

819
00:41:36,040 --> 00:41:37,720
between food production and 
nature? 

820
00:41:37,840 --> 00:41:41,240
Yes, I think this comes back a 
bit to the land sparing versus 

821
00:41:41,240 --> 00:41:43,720
land sharing debate that you we 
touched on earlier. 

822
00:41:43,880 --> 00:41:47,320
And we can definitely see 
efficiency first as being a good

823
00:41:47,320 --> 00:41:51,200
example of land sparing in that 
agricultural land is focused on 

824
00:41:51,320 --> 00:41:53,640
maximizing efficiency and 
productivity. 

825
00:41:54,040 --> 00:41:59,280
And the other non agricultural 
land, if we maintain the same 

826
00:41:59,280 --> 00:42:02,320
output, we can then spare other 
land for for nature 

827
00:42:02,320 --> 00:42:05,320
conservation. 
Whereas the Feed no food and 

828
00:42:05,320 --> 00:42:09,160
Royal Renaissance really are 
more of an integration of 

829
00:42:09,600 --> 00:42:12,840
biodiversity into farming 
systems and so hence more of a 

830
00:42:12,840 --> 00:42:15,880
land sharing approach. 
So I think you can see these 

831
00:42:15,880 --> 00:42:19,520
different, different ways of 
integrating biodiversity and 

832
00:42:19,800 --> 00:42:22,000
agriculture. 
But of course this is. 

833
00:42:22,400 --> 00:42:25,880
This is taking quite a 
simplified and polarised view to

834
00:42:25,880 --> 00:42:29,720
some degree and it's I don't 
think that it's 11 approach is 

835
00:42:29,720 --> 00:42:33,480
better than the other and then 
sparing and sharing have 

836
00:42:33,680 --> 00:42:37,600
advantages in certain contexts. 
So there's some important 

837
00:42:37,600 --> 00:42:40,480
biodiversity habitats that are 
not really suitable for 

838
00:42:40,480 --> 00:42:42,120
agricultural production like 
wetlands. 

839
00:42:42,560 --> 00:42:45,720
There's others like semi natural
species rich Grafton's which 

840
00:42:45,840 --> 00:42:49,200
very much are reliant on 
livestock, albeit at quite a low

841
00:42:49,680 --> 00:42:52,520
production output. 
Both approaches have advantages 

842
00:42:52,520 --> 00:42:55,840
in certain contexts and so it's 
about finding that right, that 

843
00:42:55,840 --> 00:43:00,040
right balance and the right 
context between man sparing and 

844
00:43:00,040 --> 00:43:01,960
sharing. 
And similarly in the pathway 

845
00:43:01,960 --> 00:43:05,480
scenarios about finding that 
right balance and what works, 

846
00:43:05,680 --> 00:43:07,440
what works well in different 
contexts. 

847
00:43:07,800 --> 00:43:11,680
So again, just reiterating that 
point that there isn't 1A1 size 

848
00:43:11,680 --> 00:43:14,720
fits all solution here, but it's
about finding that right, that 

849
00:43:14,720 --> 00:43:16,320
right blend and the right 
context. 

850
00:43:16,400 --> 00:43:19,240
Yeah, it's interesting. 
And I wonder how one goes about 

851
00:43:19,240 --> 00:43:22,720
using the different scenarios 
and and blending them fairly 

852
00:43:22,720 --> 00:43:25,600
because I'm sort of thinking 
about this from a policy 

853
00:43:25,600 --> 00:43:27,960
perspective. 
And you know, before I was 

854
00:43:28,000 --> 00:43:32,960
working as the editorof8.9.com 
and was primarily, you know, 

855
00:43:32,960 --> 00:43:34,440
sort of working within the 
policy world. 

856
00:43:34,440 --> 00:43:37,480
I can imagine looking at these 
different scenarios and cherry 

857
00:43:37,480 --> 00:43:41,240
picking the bits that seem to 
work best for me and using them 

858
00:43:41,240 --> 00:43:44,920
to to make my arguments. 
So I can sort of see from the 

859
00:43:44,920 --> 00:43:47,240
efficiency first that there are 
certain elements that I ought to

860
00:43:47,240 --> 00:43:50,120
be drawing out and from the the 
feed no food. 

861
00:43:50,120 --> 00:43:52,760
There might be other elements to
draw out in order to help build 

862
00:43:52,760 --> 00:43:54,800
a picture of rule renaissance, 
for example. 

863
00:43:55,280 --> 00:43:58,960
Is that how you expect people to
use this and this and, and how, 

864
00:43:59,160 --> 00:44:01,480
and I guess, I guess the 
question is, really is that an 

865
00:44:01,480 --> 00:44:03,760
appropriate use of the 
scenarios? 

866
00:44:03,760 --> 00:44:06,640
Do you think Tom, or should we 
be looking and and combining 

867
00:44:06,640 --> 00:44:07,720
them, blending them in a 
different way? 

868
00:44:08,120 --> 00:44:09,720
No, I think that that does make 
sense. 

869
00:44:09,720 --> 00:44:13,160
I think there is a need for for 
some regional differences. 

870
00:44:13,160 --> 00:44:16,760
I mean, Europe is a big place 
and there's different cultures 

871
00:44:16,760 --> 00:44:18,720
and contexts and climates within
that. 

872
00:44:18,720 --> 00:44:23,200
So in certain member states in 
the EU and other non EU 

873
00:44:23,200 --> 00:44:26,280
countries, different approaches 
might be better suited to those 

874
00:44:26,280 --> 00:44:28,880
contexts. 
So yeah, I think picking out the

875
00:44:28,880 --> 00:44:31,880
strengths of each scenarios 
works, but also taking account 

876
00:44:31,880 --> 00:44:35,520
of those regional differences in
the local contexts and local 

877
00:44:35,520 --> 00:44:39,040
cultures and and societies. 
Now, Jessica, you're quite new 

878
00:44:39,040 --> 00:44:42,520
to the Pathways projects. 
I wonder, you know, you come to 

879
00:44:42,520 --> 00:44:45,120
the scenarios fairly late in the
day, I guess in the same way 

880
00:44:45,120 --> 00:44:47,000
that I have. 
And I wonder what you find most 

881
00:44:47,000 --> 00:44:50,040
compelling about the scenarios. 
So yeah, as you said, I I just 

882
00:44:50,040 --> 00:44:52,760
joined the project, so I'm still
discovering a lot of things in 

883
00:44:52,760 --> 00:44:55,320
the in the scenarios. 
So far, what I find the most 

884
00:44:55,320 --> 00:44:58,200
interesting about the scenarios 
is that they are built on the 

885
00:44:58,200 --> 00:45:02,480
three core concepts of pathways 
and they are both complementary 

886
00:45:02,480 --> 00:45:05,200
and transdisciplinary, which is 
both things that I have done in 

887
00:45:05,200 --> 00:45:07,640
the past. 
So you have the sustainability 

888
00:45:07,640 --> 00:45:11,520
trade-offs, which will be one of
my focus, the leverage points 

889
00:45:11,520 --> 00:45:14,960
with the reconnect, rethink and 
restructure and then the one 

890
00:45:14,960 --> 00:45:17,280
welfare. 
And I think what's powerful here

891
00:45:17,280 --> 00:45:21,240
is that it goes beyond all of 
the classic triple bottom line 

892
00:45:21,240 --> 00:45:23,640
sustainability, you know, 
approach. 

893
00:45:24,120 --> 00:45:27,360
So we capture the complexity of 
the livestock systems and we 

894
00:45:27,360 --> 00:45:31,120
include positive and negative 
consequences that can be direct 

895
00:45:31,120 --> 00:45:35,200
or indirect. 
So as we just said, none of the 

896
00:45:35,200 --> 00:45:38,320
scenario is ideal or realistic, 
let's say. 

897
00:45:38,880 --> 00:45:42,920
But they give some trends and 
they give some tools to what we 

898
00:45:42,920 --> 00:45:47,360
may face in the future because 
as just Tom said as well, we 

899
00:45:47,360 --> 00:45:51,640
have various places, various 
policies, and I guess we will 

900
00:45:51,640 --> 00:45:54,920
use those as tools to respond to
some challenges that may be 

901
00:45:54,920 --> 00:45:58,720
faced in the future. 
And from the personal note, 

902
00:45:58,720 --> 00:46:01,880
let's say I'm very glad to work 
on the animal welfare parts 

903
00:46:02,480 --> 00:46:05,560
because I think here it's 
treated as a unique dimension, 

904
00:46:05,560 --> 00:46:09,360
distinct dimension of 
sustainability and not gathered 

905
00:46:09,360 --> 00:46:12,360
in across environmental and 
social. 

906
00:46:12,680 --> 00:46:14,520
Sometimes it's kind of in the 
background. 

907
00:46:14,520 --> 00:46:16,760
And this time it's like really 
one of the focus. 

908
00:46:16,800 --> 00:46:20,080
So as Pierre Mahi said, we do 
not know what we're going to 

909
00:46:20,080 --> 00:46:22,080
face. 
We don't have realistic data of 

910
00:46:22,080 --> 00:46:25,000
managing differently the animal 
welfare across livestock. 

911
00:46:25,000 --> 00:46:29,800
But this is a really good stone 
like on this future architecture

912
00:46:29,800 --> 00:46:32,960
of what will be the food 
systems, because we we questions

913
00:46:32,960 --> 00:46:36,200
how we can do without the 
animals or differently with the 

914
00:46:36,200 --> 00:46:38,000
animals. 
And I think it's a very 

915
00:46:38,000 --> 00:46:41,440
important question that we start
really questioning and answering

916
00:46:41,440 --> 00:46:43,480
with that project. 
So yeah, I just joined the 

917
00:46:43,480 --> 00:46:47,680
project, but already struck by 
the depth of the analytical work

918
00:46:47,680 --> 00:46:50,280
that has been done. 
And yeah, it's quite remarkable.

919
00:46:50,440 --> 00:46:51,960
Yeah. 
And and also it probably 

920
00:46:51,960 --> 00:46:55,120
enhanced greatly by you know 
working with the pharma groups 

921
00:46:55,320 --> 00:46:58,200
around Europe as well. 
So there is the agricultural 

922
00:46:58,200 --> 00:47:00,560
underpinning and then the 
architecture over, over and 

923
00:47:00,560 --> 00:47:02,600
above that from an intellectual 
standpoint. 

924
00:47:02,840 --> 00:47:06,520
Now one of your study interests 
is around land use impacts a 

925
00:47:06,520 --> 00:47:08,880
long the life cycle of food 
products. 

926
00:47:08,880 --> 00:47:11,240
Do you think the scenarios can 
help you to better understand 

927
00:47:11,240 --> 00:47:12,440
impacts there? 
Yeah. 

928
00:47:12,440 --> 00:47:15,800
So land use has been one of my 
focus in my previous research. 

929
00:47:16,280 --> 00:47:20,280
It's a very valuable tool to 
capture a lot of different 

930
00:47:20,280 --> 00:47:23,360
indicators along the life cycle 
and for food products. 

931
00:47:23,840 --> 00:47:28,000
But here we can have a complete 
complementary approach as well 

932
00:47:28,040 --> 00:47:32,400
with other types of like geosol 
for example that have been used.

933
00:47:32,480 --> 00:47:35,040
So I think thanks to the 
scenarios, we'll have a better 

934
00:47:35,040 --> 00:47:38,720
understanding what could be the 
land use impact and try to 

935
00:47:38,720 --> 00:47:43,200
assess land use consequences in 
the future according to what 

936
00:47:43,200 --> 00:47:47,440
sort of policy or maybe just 
decisions if it's at farm levels

937
00:47:47,440 --> 00:47:49,920
or business level. 
I think it will be really 

938
00:47:49,920 --> 00:47:55,640
interesting to compile it with 
the Geosol analysis and try to 

939
00:47:55,640 --> 00:47:59,920
to see both type of consequences
that can have not only from the 

940
00:48:00,000 --> 00:48:03,800
sustainable environmental 
impact, but also having the 

941
00:48:03,800 --> 00:48:07,000
nitrogen flows and something a 
bit more biological, let's say 

942
00:48:07,000 --> 00:48:09,840
the nutrient cycle. 
Combining those two 

943
00:48:09,840 --> 00:48:12,680
methodologies, I think will be 
very valuable to understand the 

944
00:48:12,680 --> 00:48:15,560
land use and the consequences of
the farming systems we will 

945
00:48:15,560 --> 00:48:17,320
develop. 
So yeah, definitely. 

946
00:48:17,440 --> 00:48:20,840
Now, Tom, I wonder whether you 
could tell me a bit about how 

947
00:48:21,280 --> 00:48:24,240
the pathways data modelling 
work, not just your own, but 

948
00:48:24,440 --> 00:48:26,160
broadly interacts with the 
scenarios. 

949
00:48:26,160 --> 00:48:28,280
Because we've talked about the 
way in which, you know, I've 

950
00:48:28,280 --> 00:48:30,880
just mentioned there the pharma 
practice hubs, you know, key 

951
00:48:30,880 --> 00:48:34,640
part of the pathways work. 
We've got the scenarios work, 

952
00:48:34,840 --> 00:48:37,080
the data modelling that we 
talked about in a previous 

953
00:48:37,080 --> 00:48:38,920
episode. 
So how does the data modelling 

954
00:48:38,920 --> 00:48:40,680
fit within all of this other 
stuff? 

955
00:48:40,840 --> 00:48:43,280
So yeah, I guess there's there's
two kind of ways to think about 

956
00:48:43,280 --> 00:48:45,000
the scenarios. 
We can think about them in a 

957
00:48:45,240 --> 00:48:48,640
more qualitative way by talking 
about them with stakeholders. 

958
00:48:48,640 --> 00:48:51,120
And there's a lot of value in 
that because there's a lot of 

959
00:48:51,120 --> 00:48:54,320
things that are quite difficult 
to model, like cultures and 

960
00:48:54,440 --> 00:48:57,200
societies and power dynamics. 
But there's some things that we 

961
00:48:57,200 --> 00:49:00,280
can model that are based on hard
numbers, things like greenhouse 

962
00:49:00,280 --> 00:49:03,520
gas emissions, GDP, protein 
production. 

963
00:49:03,720 --> 00:49:06,680
So these are things that we can 
we can model, and those models 

964
00:49:06,680 --> 00:49:09,360
are perfect, but we can come up 
with good estimates. 

965
00:49:09,800 --> 00:49:12,720
And so we've used various 
modelling approaches to compare 

966
00:49:12,880 --> 00:49:15,520
the five scenarios we've been 
talking about, and we've used a 

967
00:49:15,520 --> 00:49:19,360
variety of different models to 
provide different perspectives. 

968
00:49:19,360 --> 00:49:21,920
So different models will do 
different things, look at the 

969
00:49:21,920 --> 00:49:25,840
system in different ways and at 
different scales from the farm 

970
00:49:25,840 --> 00:49:28,000
scale to more continental 
scales. 

971
00:49:28,080 --> 00:49:31,760
And then in pathways we've we've
then brought these together at a

972
00:49:31,760 --> 00:49:36,400
high level to try to deliver 
some key messages about what the

973
00:49:36,400 --> 00:49:39,560
strengths and trade-offs of each
scenario are. 

974
00:49:39,680 --> 00:49:42,520
So in terms of the models, we've
done a life cycle assessment 

975
00:49:42,600 --> 00:49:43,840
that you've just been talking 
about. 

976
00:49:44,760 --> 00:49:46,960
So that includes both 
environmental and social 

977
00:49:46,960 --> 00:49:49,280
impacts. 
We've used an economic model 

978
00:49:49,280 --> 00:49:52,600
which works at a global scale. 
So it looks at things like trade

979
00:49:52,720 --> 00:49:57,640
and how how the system level 
economics changes and also a 

980
00:49:57,640 --> 00:50:00,520
more spatial and nitrogen 
balance and food production 

981
00:50:00,520 --> 00:50:03,120
models. 
That's the GSO model that 

982
00:50:03,120 --> 00:50:05,600
Jessica just mentioned. 
So these all look at the 

983
00:50:05,600 --> 00:50:08,360
scenarios in different ways, 
different outcomes, and to give 

984
00:50:08,360 --> 00:50:11,880
you a high level overview of 
what the models found. 

985
00:50:12,480 --> 00:50:14,800
And this is very high level 
because of course, once you get 

986
00:50:14,800 --> 00:50:17,240
into the nitty gritty, there's 
also lots of nuances. 

987
00:50:17,240 --> 00:50:19,440
There's differences between 
livestock species and 

988
00:50:19,600 --> 00:50:21,040
differences between regions and 
things. 

989
00:50:21,040 --> 00:50:25,080
But being very general at a very
high level, we found that the 

990
00:50:25,080 --> 00:50:29,480
food, no food was very strong 
for environmental impacts in 

991
00:50:29,480 --> 00:50:32,000
terms of lowering environmental 
impacts of production, 

992
00:50:32,040 --> 00:50:35,280
particularly in terms of when we
measure it by the unit of land 

993
00:50:35,280 --> 00:50:38,720
area, as you might expect, it 
wasn't so great generally for 

994
00:50:38,720 --> 00:50:41,560
the economic impacts and for and
for production. 

995
00:50:41,640 --> 00:50:45,400
The high animal welfare scenario
was quite strong for social 

996
00:50:45,400 --> 00:50:49,760
impacts and economically it was 
reasonably strong, but it does 

997
00:50:49,760 --> 00:50:52,680
come with relatively high 
environmental impacts per 

998
00:50:52,680 --> 00:50:55,880
production unit just because 
it's, it's the animal was front 

999
00:50:55,880 --> 00:50:58,520
and centre of the production 
system. 

1000
00:50:58,840 --> 00:51:00,360
So it's not not the most 
efficient. 

1001
00:51:00,480 --> 00:51:03,720
Then the rural renaissance was 
quite strong for economics, 

1002
00:51:03,720 --> 00:51:06,200
particularly as you might 
expect, the rural economy like 

1003
00:51:06,520 --> 00:51:09,760
wages in the agricultural 
sector, it was relatively 

1004
00:51:09,760 --> 00:51:12,160
productive, not the best for 
environmental impacts. 

1005
00:51:12,160 --> 00:51:15,640
It was relatively middle when we
compared the scenarios to each 

1006
00:51:15,640 --> 00:51:17,400
other. 
And then efficiency first, as 

1007
00:51:17,400 --> 00:51:20,360
you might expect was best for 
production as strong 

1008
00:51:20,360 --> 00:51:24,200
economically with low 
environmental impacts per 

1009
00:51:24,200 --> 00:51:26,240
production unit. 
But when we look at 

1010
00:51:26,240 --> 00:51:29,640
environmental impacts per land 
area, so if we keep the same 

1011
00:51:29,640 --> 00:51:32,960
area of land for livestock 
production and convert it all to

1012
00:51:32,960 --> 00:51:35,240
efficiency first, we're 
producing a lot more that we're 

1013
00:51:35,240 --> 00:51:38,160
having a lot more environmental 
impact as you might expect. 

1014
00:51:38,240 --> 00:51:41,680
And then the stockless was this 
quite extreme scenario where it 

1015
00:51:41,680 --> 00:51:45,640
had strong environmental 
improvements in terms of 

1016
00:51:45,640 --> 00:51:48,000
reducing greenhouse gas 
emissions when we remove 

1017
00:51:48,000 --> 00:51:51,520
livestock, of course, but it was
fairly disastrous in terms of 

1018
00:51:52,040 --> 00:51:54,040
economic impacts. 
So I think that gives you a bit 

1019
00:51:54,040 --> 00:51:57,160
of a flavour that all of the 
scenarios have certain 

1020
00:51:57,160 --> 00:52:00,160
strengths, but they all come 
with with certain trade-offs as 

1021
00:52:00,160 --> 00:52:02,560
well. 
Yeah, I'm interested in the way 

1022
00:52:02,560 --> 00:52:06,240
in which the different elements 
of the projects mesh together. 

1023
00:52:06,240 --> 00:52:09,000
Because there's a sort of a 
chicken and egg situation here 

1024
00:52:09,000 --> 00:52:12,160
where there's a degree to which 
the use of the modelling depends

1025
00:52:12,160 --> 00:52:13,720
on the scenarios being 
developed. 

1026
00:52:13,720 --> 00:52:16,200
And and perhaps there's, you 
know, a degree to which the the 

1027
00:52:16,200 --> 00:52:18,760
reverse is true as well. 
But if we take, for example, the

1028
00:52:18,760 --> 00:52:21,920
modelling work or the metrics 
work that Jenny Inverson was 

1029
00:52:21,920 --> 00:52:25,240
talking about on a previous 
podcast around farm animal 

1030
00:52:25,240 --> 00:52:28,760
welfare, there is it the case 
that that the kind of metrics 

1031
00:52:28,760 --> 00:52:30,960
that she was arriving at. 
And if you remember, she'd 

1032
00:52:30,960 --> 00:52:34,520
taken, you know, thousands of 
animal welfare metrics and 

1033
00:52:34,520 --> 00:52:38,800
boiled them down to, you know, 
around 20 iceberg metrics for 

1034
00:52:38,800 --> 00:52:41,640
different, different farm animal
species that were telling us a 

1035
00:52:41,640 --> 00:52:44,200
range of different aspects, 
whether those were social or 

1036
00:52:44,200 --> 00:52:47,280
environmental, including the 
welfare aspects. 

1037
00:52:47,520 --> 00:52:51,000
Were you taking those and then 
applying them to the different 

1038
00:52:51,000 --> 00:52:55,440
scenarios in a sort of specific 
and studied way or or was it, 

1039
00:52:55,680 --> 00:52:57,360
you know, sort of less precise 
than that? 

1040
00:52:57,480 --> 00:53:00,480
That was a challenge in that 
each scenario had to be had to 

1041
00:53:00,480 --> 00:53:02,600
be quantified in terms of 
numbers. 

1042
00:53:02,600 --> 00:53:05,440
And you know, all models have 
assumptions or models require 

1043
00:53:05,440 --> 00:53:08,000
inputs. 
So you know, we have this a text

1044
00:53:08,200 --> 00:53:11,240
qualitative description of a 
scenario and then we have to 

1045
00:53:11,240 --> 00:53:14,880
convert that into some kind of 
numeric form which we can use as

1046
00:53:14,920 --> 00:53:17,640
as model inputs. 
So yeah, that was a bit of an 

1047
00:53:17,640 --> 00:53:21,360
iterative process and it was we 
had modelling workshops to 

1048
00:53:21,360 --> 00:53:25,360
decide on on how to do that. 
But yeah, there are of course 

1049
00:53:25,440 --> 00:53:28,440
some options that come with that
in all the models, so there is 

1050
00:53:28,440 --> 00:53:30,760
detail there. 
Yeah, Now I'm a big fan. 

1051
00:53:30,840 --> 00:53:33,760
I, I was a very big fan of the 
rural Renaissance scenario 

1052
00:53:33,840 --> 00:53:36,200
before the conversation now and 
I sort of understood that it's 

1053
00:53:36,200 --> 00:53:37,920
slightly more of the efficiency 
first element. 

1054
00:53:37,920 --> 00:53:40,280
I particularly liked it when I 
thought it was primarily Agri 

1055
00:53:40,280 --> 00:53:42,720
ecological. 
But but Even so, it feels as 

1056
00:53:42,720 --> 00:53:46,040
though those last three 
storylines that we talked 

1057
00:53:46,040 --> 00:53:48,800
through, the rural Renaissance, 
the feed, no food and the high 

1058
00:53:48,800 --> 00:53:51,880
animal welfare, they're actually
quite complementary to each 

1059
00:53:51,880 --> 00:53:53,440
other. 
Yeah, I think, I think they are 

1060
00:53:53,440 --> 00:53:55,600
to a degree. 
And I think a lot of people, 

1061
00:53:55,680 --> 00:53:59,080
people do see the Royal 
Renaissance as quite an idyllic 

1062
00:53:59,080 --> 00:54:01,000
scenario. 
So you're not alone there. 

1063
00:54:01,120 --> 00:54:03,520
And I think, yeah, there are 
complementarities and taking 

1064
00:54:03,520 --> 00:54:06,160
animal welfare, for example, I 
think that's very compatible 

1065
00:54:06,160 --> 00:54:08,920
with the female food and Royal 
Renaissance scenarios. 

1066
00:54:09,000 --> 00:54:12,240
And to some extent, I think our 
modelling results back that up. 

1067
00:54:12,720 --> 00:54:16,320
And if we take efficiency first 
as the other scenario, I think 

1068
00:54:16,320 --> 00:54:19,320
that is quite different in that 
when we modelled that scenario, 

1069
00:54:19,320 --> 00:54:23,560
that was the only scenario that 
improve self-sufficiency in food

1070
00:54:23,680 --> 00:54:26,960
in the EU in 20-50. 
And that's comparing the 

1071
00:54:26,960 --> 00:54:30,080
scenarios to a business, a 
projected business as usual in 

1072
00:54:30,080 --> 00:54:32,080
20-50. 
But I think there are also some 

1073
00:54:32,360 --> 00:54:34,360
key differences between those 
scenarios. 

1074
00:54:34,360 --> 00:54:37,720
And perhaps the starkest 
difference is in the feed new 

1075
00:54:37,720 --> 00:54:41,040
food where we see the the pork 
and poultry sectors declining 

1076
00:54:41,040 --> 00:54:43,680
very strongly. 
There's quite a big difference. 

1077
00:54:43,680 --> 00:54:46,560
Whereas of course, pork and 
poultry are much more compatible

1078
00:54:46,560 --> 00:54:49,960
with rural Renaissance and high 
animal welfare, albeit at lower 

1079
00:54:50,200 --> 00:54:53,400
densities, as PM was saying. 
And I think there's also, when 

1080
00:54:53,400 --> 00:54:56,080
we think about the transitions 
towards these scenarios, then 

1081
00:54:56,280 --> 00:54:58,880
efficiencies first probably 
stands out as slightly different

1082
00:54:58,880 --> 00:55:01,720
to the others in terms of being,
as you were saying earlier, 

1083
00:55:02,160 --> 00:55:05,120
probably the closest to the 
business as usual in terms of 

1084
00:55:05,120 --> 00:55:08,280
where the sector is heading with
agritech developments and 

1085
00:55:08,280 --> 00:55:12,080
specialization and scale. 
Whereas the other 3, Royal 

1086
00:55:12,080 --> 00:55:15,160
Renaissance, speedy food and 
high animal welfare do present 

1087
00:55:15,160 --> 00:55:18,600
some some more difficult 
barriers in terms of always 

1088
00:55:18,680 --> 00:55:21,320
going against some of the the 
current trends of the food 

1089
00:55:21,320 --> 00:55:22,880
system. 
And that's not to say that we 

1090
00:55:22,880 --> 00:55:25,200
should forget about them because
they're too difficult, because I

1091
00:55:25,200 --> 00:55:27,840
think they have their real 
advantages in in certain 

1092
00:55:27,840 --> 00:55:30,640
contexts and they do have a role
to play, but perhaps more 

1093
00:55:30,640 --> 00:55:32,920
difficult to scale up. 
Now, PM Marie, we're coming 

1094
00:55:32,920 --> 00:55:35,160
towards the end of the program, 
but I wonder whether you can 

1095
00:55:35,160 --> 00:55:38,080
maybe reflect on the scenarios 
work that you've been involved 

1096
00:55:38,080 --> 00:55:41,200
in over the last five years and 
the Pathways project more 

1097
00:55:41,200 --> 00:55:43,360
broadly. 
And I wonder how you hope that 

1098
00:55:43,360 --> 00:55:47,320
the work is going to be used in 
the wider world by campaigners 

1099
00:55:47,320 --> 00:55:50,920
or by the media, ultimately by 
policy makers themselves. 

1100
00:55:51,040 --> 00:55:52,960
I guess there are there are 
three points of of third 

1101
00:55:52,960 --> 00:55:57,440
different nature that I'm hoping
will be used and reflected upon 

1102
00:55:57,440 --> 00:56:00,760
by by various stakeholders. 
One thing is that we've shown 

1103
00:56:00,760 --> 00:56:04,000
with pathways or at least we've 
tried to demonstrate that you 

1104
00:56:04,000 --> 00:56:08,720
need good enough approaches from
a methodical point of view to 

1105
00:56:08,720 --> 00:56:11,400
really identify the trade-offs 
associated to different 

1106
00:56:11,400 --> 00:56:13,600
trajectories of change for 
sector. 

1107
00:56:13,600 --> 00:56:16,600
Because it's only on that basis 
that you can discuss with a 

1108
00:56:16,600 --> 00:56:19,560
variety of stakeholders about 
OK, where are potential 

1109
00:56:19,560 --> 00:56:22,600
synergies, where are trade-offs?
And if they are trade-offs, if 

1110
00:56:22,600 --> 00:56:24,960
they are losers, how can we 
compensate theirs etcetera, 

1111
00:56:24,960 --> 00:56:26,560
etcetera. 
Because at the moment those 

1112
00:56:26,560 --> 00:56:29,000
conversations are basically 
occurring on the basis of 

1113
00:56:29,160 --> 00:56:32,080
virtually nothing because you 
have only partial analysis of 

1114
00:56:32,080 --> 00:56:33,440
the transformation to the 
sector. 

1115
00:56:33,520 --> 00:56:37,480
And so it's it's just who is 
going to shout the louder, who's

1116
00:56:37,480 --> 00:56:40,440
going to win the fight, you know
in a way which is not the the 

1117
00:56:40,440 --> 00:56:44,000
nicest way to design policies. 
So that's the one thing. 

1118
00:56:44,080 --> 00:56:47,000
The second thing which is 
similar in nature to my first 

1119
00:56:47,000 --> 00:56:52,280
point is that even even though 
we did provide researchers in 

1120
00:56:52,280 --> 00:56:55,440
policy because with like EU wide
molding and results. 

1121
00:56:55,480 --> 00:56:58,880
What we essentially say is that 
as Tom was saying a number of 

1122
00:56:58,880 --> 00:57:01,800
times, there is no 
one-size-fits-all logic or 

1123
00:57:01,800 --> 00:57:05,400
answer. 
And it has to be brought down so

1124
00:57:05,400 --> 00:57:08,320
to speak to the territorial 
level where it makes sense where

1125
00:57:08,320 --> 00:57:12,440
our livestock system can really 
develop and you know express its

1126
00:57:12,440 --> 00:57:14,480
strengths on weaknesses. 
So what we are saying 

1127
00:57:14,480 --> 00:57:17,040
essentially with pathways and 
what we are hoping people to do 

1128
00:57:17,040 --> 00:57:21,080
is that not trade-offs and 
synergies at the meta level, the

1129
00:57:21,080 --> 00:57:24,240
EU level, the national level, 
but rather bring that down to, 

1130
00:57:24,400 --> 00:57:27,680
you know, broad territories and,
and you know, try to discuss, to

1131
00:57:27,680 --> 00:57:30,200
have constructive conversations 
on where do we want to go. 

1132
00:57:30,600 --> 00:57:33,320
And the third thing, which is 
kind of a different nature, is 

1133
00:57:33,320 --> 00:57:37,440
that I hope that with the work 
that has been done with the 

1134
00:57:37,440 --> 00:57:41,440
biomass balance modelling, we 
can demonstrate that, you know, 

1135
00:57:41,440 --> 00:57:45,800
the circularity dimension of the
livestock sector is a backbone 

1136
00:57:45,800 --> 00:57:49,360
of any kind of more, let's say, 
sustainable for desirable 

1137
00:57:49,960 --> 00:57:53,560
livestock sector. 
And if circularity is to be 

1138
00:57:53,680 --> 00:57:57,200
valued, so to speak, it has 
massive implications for all the

1139
00:57:57,200 --> 00:57:59,800
transformations of the future 
transformations of the sector. 

1140
00:57:59,840 --> 00:58:02,880
And that needs to be reflected 
somewhere, even though again, 

1141
00:58:02,880 --> 00:58:05,480
this will need to be tailored to
each specific territories. 

1142
00:58:05,720 --> 00:58:09,440
But I hope that we've proven 
that circular, that this 

1143
00:58:09,440 --> 00:58:12,680
circularity dimension is a 
critical pillar for future life 

1144
00:58:12,680 --> 00:58:14,040
success. 
Systems fantastic. 

1145
00:58:14,040 --> 00:58:15,920
That's, that's really 
fascinating. 

1146
00:58:15,920 --> 00:58:19,320
And Jessica, just a couple of 
questions to you to bring us to 

1147
00:58:19,320 --> 00:58:21,160
the end. 
I know that agricultural 

1148
00:58:21,160 --> 00:58:23,360
economics are also something 
that are important. 

1149
00:58:23,560 --> 00:58:26,880
In terms of your own research 
and based on the scenarios you 

1150
00:58:26,880 --> 00:58:29,440
know and the and your 
understanding of them, where do 

1151
00:58:29,440 --> 00:58:33,360
you think the most exciting 
economic opportunities exist in 

1152
00:58:33,360 --> 00:58:35,880
the future of food systems 
within Europe? 

1153
00:58:36,040 --> 00:58:41,480
So in past, I will be looking at
how to like magnet and market 

1154
00:58:41,480 --> 00:58:46,600
equilibrium model can capture 
how farm, farm level changes 

1155
00:58:46,600 --> 00:58:51,000
ripple out to add into prices, 
trade flows, adjustments where 

1156
00:58:51,000 --> 00:58:53,200
the most exciting opportunities 
lie. 

1157
00:58:53,280 --> 00:58:56,840
I think we need to be careful 
about this time frame because 

1158
00:58:56,840 --> 00:58:59,560
all these scenarios can generate
markets and business 

1159
00:58:59,560 --> 00:59:03,400
opportunities in the short term.
For example, the real question 

1160
00:59:03,400 --> 00:59:06,360
will be if it will last in the 
long term and that's 

1161
00:59:06,360 --> 00:59:09,440
fundamentally a question about 
the sustainability of the 

1162
00:59:09,440 --> 00:59:13,000
economic model we choose. 
So my view is that the most 

1163
00:59:13,000 --> 00:59:16,320
durable economic opportunities 
will be those on the long term, 

1164
00:59:16,400 --> 00:59:19,920
environmentally and socially 
sustainable, including the 

1165
00:59:19,920 --> 00:59:22,600
animal welfare. 
So we need to look at the trade 

1166
00:59:22,600 --> 00:59:25,720
off to know if it's going to be 
economically interesting in the 

1167
00:59:25,720 --> 00:59:28,200
long term. 
Also, the public policy has a 

1168
00:59:28,200 --> 00:59:32,000
crucial role to play here, 
helping societies to make the 

1169
00:59:32,000 --> 00:59:35,320
decisions that are good for 
people, for the planet, for the 

1170
00:59:35,320 --> 00:59:38,760
animals, and creating the 
condition economically, like the

1171
00:59:38,760 --> 00:59:42,640
economic opportunities that can 
generally be resilient over 

1172
00:59:42,640 --> 00:59:45,680
time. 
So I mean now I cannot answer 

1173
00:59:45,680 --> 00:59:47,360
that question. 
Fair enough. 

1174
00:59:47,760 --> 00:59:51,040
And just finally, you're going 
to be gathering and analysing 

1175
00:59:51,040 --> 00:59:54,040
feedback from the pathways 
partners over the course of the 

1176
00:59:54,040 --> 00:59:56,560
next few months. 
How is that going to contribute 

1177
00:59:56,560 --> 00:59:58,480
to the final elements of the 
project? 

1178
00:59:58,560 --> 01:00:03,040
So yeah, my role is like really 
bringing at the final stage of 

1179
01:00:03,040 --> 01:00:07,240
that project and I will be 
synthesizing the outputs from 

1180
01:00:07,240 --> 01:00:10,000
the different model based 
assessments that we have already

1181
01:00:10,000 --> 01:00:12,280
mentioned. 
Like the LCA, the Geo Soul. 

1182
01:00:12,720 --> 01:00:15,320
So a big part of that will be 
working directly with our 

1183
01:00:15,320 --> 01:00:17,400
partners. 
So we just mentioned it's like a

1184
01:00:17,520 --> 01:00:21,560
lot of stakeholders are involved
and we try to gather the 

1185
01:00:21,560 --> 01:00:24,960
workshop, the interviews and 
validate and refine the findings

1186
01:00:24,960 --> 01:00:27,280
with people who are actually 
working in the sector. 

1187
01:00:27,280 --> 01:00:30,880
So the farmers, the supply chain
actors, the policy makers, the 

1188
01:00:30,880 --> 01:00:32,760
NGOs. 
So this Co production of 

1189
01:00:32,760 --> 01:00:37,440
knowledge is now needs to be 
refined and polished and try to 

1190
01:00:38,080 --> 01:00:41,840
let's say clean a bit all of the
findings we have and put that 

1191
01:00:41,840 --> 01:00:44,840
together in a consistent way. 
So the goal is ultimately to 

1192
01:00:44,840 --> 01:00:48,400
produce something that is a 
clear analysis that identify the

1193
01:00:48,400 --> 01:00:52,120
most promising transition that 
pathways for sustainable 

1194
01:00:52,120 --> 01:00:56,400
livestock in Europe and set out 
a forward-looking research 

1195
01:00:56,400 --> 01:01:00,240
agenda that identifies where the
gaps and opportunities still 

1196
01:01:00,240 --> 01:01:02,320
lie. 
So I will look at the future of 

1197
01:01:02,320 --> 01:01:04,440
pathways. 
What do we do after pathways as 

1198
01:01:04,440 --> 01:01:06,040
well? 
So yeah, I'm one of the last 

1199
01:01:06,040 --> 01:01:08,480
species of the pathway puzzle. 
Fantastic. 

1200
01:01:08,480 --> 01:01:10,480
Look, That's it. 
That's all we've got time for. 

1201
01:01:10,680 --> 01:01:14,160
I'd like to thank my guests, Dr.
Jessica Bosso, Doctor Tom 

1202
01:01:14,160 --> 01:01:16,560
Staton, and Dr. Pierre Marie 
O'bear. 

1203
01:01:16,760 --> 01:01:19,520
If you've not yet heard our 
previous Pathways programs and 

1204
01:01:19,520 --> 01:01:22,000
you can find them by scroll 
calling back in your podcast 

1205
01:01:22,000 --> 01:01:23,480
feed. 
And if you've enjoyed listening,

1206
01:01:23,480 --> 01:01:25,000
please come back and listen to 
more. 

1207
01:01:25,000 --> 01:01:28,200
Tell your friends like us, 
review us and share our links. 

1208
01:01:28,400 --> 01:01:32,040
You can sign up for our free 
weekly newsletter@8.9.com. 

1209
01:01:32,240 --> 01:01:34,080
That's the number 8, the word 
point. 

1210
01:01:34,080 --> 01:01:37,320
The #9.com. 
Farmgate is Europe's highest 

1211
01:01:37,320 --> 01:01:40,960
ranking food security podcast. 
And we're partof8.9.com, the 

1212
01:01:40,960 --> 01:01:44,120
land use news channel, which is 
supported by First Milk, Pelican

1213
01:01:44,120 --> 01:01:47,240
AG, the Nature Friendly Farming 
Network, Friars Moore Livestock 

1214
01:01:47,240 --> 01:01:50,640
Health, the Royal Agricultural 
University Agrolo and Indian 

1215
01:01:50,720 --> 01:01:53,000
individual donors. 
And I've been thin loca stain. 

1216
01:01:53,240 --> 01:01:54,000
Bye for now.
