From India's largest newsroom, I'm Arun George and this is the
Times of India podcast. Nearly two months before Diwali,
the Delhi government announced that it would retain a ban on
fireworks in the city for this year as well.
BJP MP Manoj Tiwari promptly went to the Supreme Court
seeking that the ban be lifted, only to have his petition
dismissed. To top it off, he was chastised
by the Supreme Court, the. Supreme Court said do something
for people and if there is a ban, there is.
A ban if you want. To bust crackers go to a.
State where there is. No ban.
The debate over a ban on fireworks is now an annual one
in parts of India when the religious sentiments of 1
Community are weighed against the health concerns of the
entire region. We're bringing back this episode
we'd done a while back in which we looked at the issue of
firework bans and they fall out. Deepavali itself means a row of
lights. It is a festival of lights.
It's not the festival of fireworks.
Fireworks itself came to India at a much later stage, you know,
through trade from China and other places.
And and a lot of the critics of the ban of firecrackers often
say that you're looking at, you're banning firecrackers, but
you're not banning these other things that cause air pollution.
But that's not really true. India actually spends billions
of dollars in trying to make. Transport fuel cleaner to to
install solar panels and all of that.
So, and those are things we cannot do without.
You know, we cannot do without moving around.
We cannot do without turning on the, you know, switch and having
electricity. But you can avoid firecrackers
because they're not an integral part of the economy.
That was our little pre Diwali fireworks.
We hope you enjoyed it and that that would be the extent of your
engagement with them. Deceptively enjoyable, the
fatakas and the full juries have a deadly aftermath, especially
in North India which anyway battles extreme air pollution.
In today's podcast, we discuss how fireworks came to India.
Is it possible to get greener, more environment friendly
option? And what are the lacks of
people, mostly poor, who are associated with the
manufacturing of fireworks? With more and more states
banning fireworks, what becomes of these people?
Firecrackers manufacturing in India dates back to the
beginning of 20th century. So one of the main reasons I
think Shivakashi and this region called the Virudhu Nagar
district now. Might have been a pioneer
because it doesn't have much rain.
It's an aerate as you know, it's a rain shadow region.
So the dry conditions favored it started with matchbox making.
So you know, the World War or the Second World War, 1939.
That was the time when, till then, you know, the British were
kind of importing fireworks for whatever celebrations
festivities they had. Basically, I think from the UK,
or maybe you're from Germany. But after the World War this
import stopped, so indigenous fireworks got a boost.
And Shivakashi, probably because Madras was already with the
British and Shivakashi was not too far away.
That's that could be the probable reason, and given the
climatic condition, Shivakashi was a good candidate.
For this so from right from 1940s, we have had these
companies which got into 5 words speaking Some of the some of
them who have been making matchboxes shifted to 5 words
because it was more lucrative. So I think that's the history
and ever since there was no looking back till probably a
couple of decades ago, Shivakashi has been the leader.
It remains the leader when it comes to this industry.
You just heard my colleague Arun Ram, resident Editor of Times of
India, Chennai, and now my other colleague Jaya Menon, who is
political editor of Ty Chennai and who is frequently reported
from the town of Shirkashi, gives us a lay of the land there
and why tragedy haunts the by lanes that create the
instruments of our celebration. If you actually go into the
areas where the factories are located.
You will find that you know the entrances are like any other,
you know, establishment. It is when you get inside, you
find that you know it's like a vast space because there are
certain stipulations by the authority as to how the sheds
should be located, how many people should be working in a
shed. So you find that, you know
there's it's very well kept, very clean.
These are the very organized licensed factories.
Now when you go into Sivakasi and you know outside Sivakasi
rather where these villages where the cottage industries
thrive. In fact, I am told that at least
50% of the industry is, you know.
Contributed by the cottage industries, that is where the
you know, the villages the families work towards, you know
are given assignments by the factories.
Not really legal, not licensed, but the you know they get a
better deal out of. They may not pay as much as they
would have to if, you know, workers are sitting in sheds and
working so. Cottage industry is a big
business and a lot of accidents happen there too.
In fact, when they finish their consignments, they keep it
inside the house. So they sleep along with these
sacks of senior body. They call it, you know, the
small crackers. There are 1070 licensed
fireworks manufacturers in Sivakasi, but many more
unregulated cottage industries, several of them operating from
people's homes. Even though the National Green
Tribunal has laid down safety norms, adherence to them is poor
and deadly accidents in norm, says Jaya Menon.
Every year, at least a minimum of 10 to 15 people die in such
accidents. I'm giving a very minimal kind
of a figure. I'm trying to be a little, you
know, not exaggerate. Now there are also strict norms
as to how you store these. You know the kind of sheds that
are to be used, the kind of, you know, ventilation and where it
should be located. So those kind of norms are also
there. None of them are followed.
Sivakashi and the district it falls under, Virudhanagar, are
in the rain shadow region and therefore arid.
With little by way of agriculture, poverty is rife and
the fireworks industry. Checked it about 6000 to 10,000
crore is the mainstay for families, the business employees
and unusually large number of women and children, Jaya Menon
tells Arun George. During the pandemic, what
happened was the mothers took the children along to the a lot
of women work. In fact, they say 45% of the
workers are women. So when the women go to work,
they took the children along. And of course it worked well
both ways. It was a win win situation for
the employers and for the women, because the employers gave lower
wages for the children. And for the women it was
additional income. And these children were not, I
mean, attending online classes, obviously, because they didn't
have the wherewithal, not neither the gadgets nor the
connectivity to have, you know, for them to participate in
online classes. So these children were taken
along by the mothers and they were actually found working with
the women. Now they were there are raids, I
mean there are frequent raids and all that, but always, you
know, there are, there's deals are struck on the ground, bribes
are paid and even the, I mean the employers, if it's cottage
industry, the villagers pay bribes to the inspectors and the
work goes on. What is happening the rest of
the year? And like, say, where are the men
working in that sense? That's an interesting thing
because as soon as the Diwali gets over, work begins for the
next Diwali. So all through it is not just
Diwali. There are a lot of temple
festivals like Vinay, the Vinayga, Chaturthi in
Maharashtra, for instance. They are huge customers.
They're big customers for Sivakasi.
So through the year you have temple festivals happening
across the country, so there is never a lull in business.
So for Diwa, after Diwali finishes, the work starts for
the next Diwali. For the temples, festivals that
come, all through the other festivals that come, So it's a
continuous process. There's never a lull.
With the NGT ordered green crackers, a ban on fireworks by
states like Delhi, Orissa, West Bengal.
Plus the pandemic of the last two years, it is all clobbered
the fireworks industry, says Balaji TK.
He's part of the family that runs Sri Balaji Fireworks and is
also the legal advisor to the Indian Fireworks Manufacturers
Association. From the 2015, we are facing the
court case pressure from all the sectors.
Because of the court case, we have lost huge amount of orders.
Protection, capacity, marketing and everything.
And it has become a big issue for the people who have taken
the credits from the bank they couldn't repaid.
Many banks have liquidated the assets of many manufacturers.
The one point in that the Supreme Court case is another
big issue that has to be solved. 2nd is the state going again
with the band? Recently, the government of
Rajasthan, which had banned firecrackers, modified its order
to allow for green crackers, a concept mooted by the Supreme
Court. But what exactly are green
crackers? How do they work and are they
effective in reducing air pollution?
Chennai TOIRE Arun Ram Vaysin. I think it's an oxymoron, the
green cracker only that even Neri and other scientific
institutions have agreed have. Even the manufacturers are in
agreement that no cracker can be completely green.
It's like calling like a healthy drink of 6 packs of whiskey.
The government and agencies like Neri have decided, have put a
cap on the use of certain chemicals.
And the when when firecrackers are burst, the emissions, so
emissions have to be 30% less is what the last decision was.
The court is still hearing this case.
It's going back and forth, but there is a general agreement
that a green cracker has should have an emission of 30% less
than the ordinary normal cracker.
When it comes to decibel levels, the decibel levels have been as
high as one 5160, even around 200.
Now it should not cross 125 decibels.
So these are the broad criteria of a green cracker.
You know firecracker is is a is a concentrate of every
imaginable pollutant as we know the the biggest pollutants being
barium and you know the emissions are sulfur dioxide,
carbon monoxide, You think of any bad thing in the air, a
firecracker has it. So there is no dispute over.
The environment, friendliness so to say, of any firecracker when
you had a crisis in the national capital, fireworks also probably
became a point of discussion. And wherever we could cut on
pollution, regular pollution, we could not cut much.
Though there was a shift from diesel engines to petrol and we
are still struggling with electronic automobile.
But I think firecrackers was an easier target that way and
rightly so. So that that problem was the
beginning of a legal tasking or a movement against biker
Packers. But I think parallelly there was
solved also a people's movement especially driven by children
across the country. You know if you look at schools
having campaigns against bike Packers, this whole fad, if I
may also to go between without even understanding it, but in a
in a in a good way it has resulted in a higher awareness.
Balaji TK says that adapting to green crackers is challenging
and expensive. It requires new formulation, but
he adds that the industry is trying.
We're completely going for eco friendly crackers.
The main question raised by the environmentalists and
firecrackers is pollution. So to the point we can say the
firecrackers in the not in the top 20 list of polluting
industries. In the country and we are
celebrating on one day and that's a unite uniting factor.
We celebrate on Diwali. It unites all the religion
people and we celebrate on newer.
It unites all the religion fact people.
So it's it's even though it's challenging, it's not in the top
20 list. We have to consider the
religious factors associated with the happiness.
We cannot completely accept the environments and the band of
fireworks and these things and all it's some religious factors.
Even the car is polluting more. The PM 2.5 and PM10 particles
entered by the car is much more than anything.
If you look at the sources of air pollution in any given year.
Or any given season for that matter.
You will see that the largest sources of outdoor air
pollution, ambient air pollution are Rd. vehicles, industries,
power generation, dust you know, from construction sides and
roads and so on. Additionally, there are, you
know, other factors such as open base burning or diesel generator
sets, or in the case of Northern India, there's stubble burning
as well, right? But if you look at, you know,
air pollution on the specific days where.
Firecrackers are used on those days and the days surrounding
it, the days following it. Firecrackers are definitely one
of the biggest and most dangerous sources of air
pollution or causes of health elements in that period of time.
So at those very high level of concentration, air pollution
from firecrackers is way more dangerous than any other source
of air pollution on those specific days.
Last year, my parents got COVID. Just around Diwali, it was, you
know, a coincidence that happened at that point of time,
and my dad's oxygen levels in particular started dipping.
Luckily, there was a firecracker ban, so there were very few
firecrackers actually went off. But I was imagining if that
time, if it was as bad as it had been in the previous years,
where, you know, the smoke just kind of gets stuck in the air
and there's no way for it to leave and there's no way for you
to escape it either. What would have happened if if
you know it was that bad last year?
That Siddharth Singh, author of The Great Smog of India, a
definitive account of India's troubles with air pollution.
He tells Arun George how abandoned fireworks can help
clean up Indian skies. Firstly, bans on sales cannot be
effective the way that they're being done currently, right?
These bans are often announced just a few days before Diwali,
or a few days before the any given day when you're going to
be using it. And that causes obviously
financial harm to manufacturers as well as sellers, retailers,
they become very hard to implement something when the
goods that, you know, the stock of firecrackers is already in
the marketplace. So it's very easy for it to leak
out from there and find its way into people's homes.
You know, secondly, if they're banned in one location, for
example one city, but not in the neighborhood, neighboring cities
or neighboring states, then of course you know there's no
restriction for people to travel and and you will find
firecrackers being used from beyond that.
I think a far more effective approach would be to combine a
more. I guess national, regional ban
with alternatives so that people still feel involved on those
particular days. You know there are in other
parts of the world, for example, you have community fireworks,
right? So instead of everyone buying
and you know, therefore lighting fire crackers, perhaps at a
social level, at at the level of neighborhoods or villages or
even cities, they can be specific locations where people
can congregate. And you know they can be certain
types of firecrackers used that are perhaps less damaging.
Secondly, you know in in China and other parts of the world
they have now started using drones.
So, so imagine a night sky of drone displays where there are,
you know, grand and majestic sites to be seen.
I I assume that such kind of alternatives would keep people
engaged and and therefore providing an alternative along
with the ban would be something that would be far more
effective. Bad air quality impacts all of
us. It impacts, you know, even the,
in fact it impacts the person who's lighting the firecracker
more than anyone else. So I'm sure they would be
understanding only if we were to have a dialogue as opposed to,
you know, to to extremely unplanned and disruptive changes
at the last minute. But the transition to a
firecracker free country is not coming anytime soon and it is
fraught with environment to the one side.
And livelihood of hundreds and thousands of people on the
other, says Arundram. Political parties have to take a
populist, if not a populist, A sympathetic attitude towards
firecracker makers. So if you see Tamil Nadu Chief
Minister MK Stalin, an appeal to those States and Chief ministers
who had banned even Green trackers.
And Rajasthan was the first one to obliged so.
This is this is the political aspect of it so.
But the problem remains that for many decades we have not been
updating our fireworks industry to be less polluting, or rather
more technology oriented. To give you a classic example,
slightly strained from the main topic, it is also about the
accidents if you look at it. The number of accidents, if you
look at it, has gone up after probably 2000.
This is the reason I feel is because that was a time when
Indian fire crack makers, fire firework makers, especially
shabnashi tried to shift from their conventional traditional
methods to adopt A kind of Chinese fireworks.
No, Chinese are the masters of viral techniques.
So. That was also the time when
there was a shift from more sound to more color.
But the problem was they brought in a new sulphur based new
barium based bearing is the the best of colors chemicals.
But our industry most of it was. Most of it was a cottage
industry did not know how to deal with it.
You know we had this own way of grinding certain chemicals which
led to accidents. So this is.
This is a hallmark of Shivakashi, that how when the
demand went up with the profits went up with the number of
people depended on this industry went up.
We did not catch up with technology and make things safer
and less polluting and now I think there is no point of
return and we'll have to probably completely shift and
rehabilitate this population to a new industry or something
else. We'll have to think probably
out-of-the-box because agriculture in the conventional
way is not possible in such a great shadow region in the
coming days. In the coming decades I'm sure
that fireworks would altogether disappear.
As we have seen in some of the Far East countries and even
China, there are fireworks happening without even one
explosion. That is a virtual fireworks.
It would light up your sky, it would give you the effect of the
light, sound, everything without smoke, without emissions.
So when everything is going virtually, why should we invest
more on something which is endangering lives?
Today's episode was produced by Jayaraj Singh, Sunai Marathi and
Anuja Singh. For a daily spotlight on people,
ideas and stories that matter, subscribe to us.
We are available on TOI, Spotify, Apple, Google Podcasts
and all other platforms of your choice.
For any news tips, e-mail us at TOI Podcast at Timesinternet in.