Did SpaceX break environmental regulations at its Starbase
facility? Now, this question arose after
recent reports indicated that both Texas and federal officials
found SpaceX to be in violation of wastewater discharge rules.
Now, this issue centers around Spacex's Starbase launch site in
Boca Chicas, Texas. Now, SpaceX responded by stating
that regulatory bodies, including the Texas Commission
on Environmental Quality, the TCEQ, and the Environmental
Protection Agency, the EPA, had permitted them to continue
operations while working towards obtaining necessary permits.
However, as of the latest reports, these agencies had not
confirmed such an agreement. Spacex's Star Base facility,
located about a mile from the Gulf of Mexico, has been in
operation since 2014. The site was specifically chosen
and developed to facilitate the testing and launch of Starship.
Now, the site is about 20 miles from the nearest city,
Brownsville, TX, and it's the former site of a small beach
community called Boca Chica. Now, SpaceX has bought most of
the property near the facilities at Boca Chica, so they will
continue to expand on what they already have there.
Now SpaceX secured approval from the Federal Aviation
Administration, the FAA in 2013 or 2023 to conduct regular
launches from the site and the approval was contingent on the
company adhering to various environmental standards.
Now among these standards and these regulations that intended
to minimize the environmental impact around the Starship
launch facility. Now the need for stringent
environmental controls became apparent after the first Test
flight of Starship in April of 2023.
Now the launch resulted in substantial damage to the
launchpad and after the damage was cleaned up and the pad was
rebuilt, SpaceX installed the deluge system with the sprinkler
system to mitigate the force exerted by the Rockets powerful
Raptor. And now this system releases an
estimated massive amount of 422,000 gallons of water per
flight, a portion of which is vaporized instantly, and the
remainder is what has drawn scrutiny from environmental
regulators. Now, according to a report first
published by CNBC, the TCEQ found the SpaceX had been
discharging industrial wastewater from this deluge
system into Texas waterways without proper authorization.
Specifically, the TCe QS July 30th report accused SpaceX of
violating state environmental laws by failing to secure a
Texas Pollutant Discharge Elimination System permit.
Now, the report identified 4 unauthorized discharges since
March 2023, an allegation that if substantiated, could have
serious implications for SpaceX operations going forward at
Starbase. Now SpaceX in his defense, has
maintained his position that the water used in his deluge system
is clean, potable water and then it has worked closely with the
TCEQ throughout the construction and testing phases of the system
to ensure compliance with environmental regulations.
Now, the company has also stated that it submitted an application
for an individual wastewater discharge permit to the TCEQ on
July 1st, 2024. This permit, once granted, would
formally authorize the discharge of wastewater from the deluge
system under specific conditions set by the agency.
Now, the system has attracted criticism from environmental
groups and local activists, who argue that SpaceX should not be
allowed to continue its operations until all
environmental concerns are fully addressed.
Now, Mary Angela Branch, who's a member of the nonprofit
organization Save RGV, has been particularly vocal and she said
the Spacex's activity should be halted immediately given the
reported violations. She also said that her
organization have been involved in legal actions aimed at
protecting these sensitive environmental ecosystems
surrounding Boca Chica since SpaceX started their activities
there. Now, the controversy over
Spacex's wastewater discharge practices has also affected the
FA as plans to hold public hearings on the company's
request to increase frequency of launches and landings at
Starbase. These hearings, which were
scheduled to begin August 5th, were abruptly postponed by the
FAA. In a statement, the FAA cited
the need for additional information from SpaceX before
rescheduling the meetings. The hearings were intended to
gather public input on a draft environmental assessment related
to Spacex's expansion plans at Starbase.
Now, the postponement of the public hearings has sparked
further concerns among local stakeholders, particularly in
the Rio Grande Valley, where Spacex's operations have had
significant huge environmental and social impacts.
A coalition of environmental and civil rights groups, along with
the tribe, the Comacruto Tribe of Texas.
I'm sorry if I butchered that. It's a letter to the FAA
Administrator, Michael Whitaker, expressing their dissatisfaction
with the current public participation process.
Letter criticized the FAA for failing to adequately inform the
local Hispanic community about the hearings and for proposing a
format that would prevent the public from hearing each other's
concerns. The coalition argued that
proposed one-on-one format where residents would provide comments
privately to an FAA stenographer would limit community engagement
and hinder a comprehensive understanding of the concerns.
That's those concerns are surrounding SpaceX and their
operations at Starbase, and they requested that the FAA hold open
public meetings where attendees could hear and discuss the
viewpoints of the peers, thus fostering a more inclusive and
transparent dialogue on the issue.
SpaceX has sought to address these concerns by reiterating
its commitment to the environment down there.
They want to be environmental stewards and they want to comply
with regulatory requirements. And in a statement released on
social media on X Actually, company outlined the steps it
has taken to ensure its operations in Starbase do not
harm the environment. SpaceX said that its deluge
system, which is similar to those used on other launch sites
across the United States such as NASA launch sites, is designed
to protect both the launch site and the surrounding area by
absorbing the heat and vibration generated during the rocket
launches. That's the biggest rocket ever
built, by the way. SpaceX also pointed out that the
water used in the deluge system is not exposed to any industrial
processes before or during operation, and that most of the
water is vaporized by the rocket engines immediately during
liftoff and the fur. To mitigate these environmental
risks, SpaceX collects and hauls off water used in pre launch
power washing of the launchpad. Additionally, SpaceX has
implemented a retention pod system to capture any excess
water, which is then removed from the site to prevent
contamination of local groundwater.
So they're doing their part here.
And despite these assurances, though, the TCEQ findings
suggest that there are ongoing concerns about the potential
environmental impact of Spacex's operations.
The agency's report noted that during an investigation in late
July 2024, SpaceX was found to have discharged industrial
wastewater without the required permitting.
The report indicated that this discharge could potentially
introduce pollutants into Texas waterways.
Although SpaceX has of course contexted these findings,
particularly the claim that wastewater contained unsafe
levels of mercury. We don't want mercury in any of
the water. SpaceX has countered the
allegations by highlighting the results of the independent
laboratory tests, which it says have consistently shown
negligible traces of contaminants in the water, the
soil, and the air around the launchpad.
Now the company acknowledged that while a small amount of
water does escape the pad area during launches, the quantity is
minimal, equivalent to just 0.004 inches of rainfall over
the surrounding area. And SpaceX maintains that this
is insignificant compared to the regions average rainfall at the
annual rainfall of 27 inches. Now the ongoing dispute between
SpaceX and environmental regulators is a huge deal for
SpaceX. The company faces a a huge
challenge. Could they possibly halt the
operations at Starbase to get these regulations under control?
Is SpaceX doing the right thing or will they have to be
investigated again? Will there be another complex
environmental review for Starbase before even the next
launch? Will they launch from Starbase
again within the next month or so?
We're not 100% sure. So the future of Starbase and
Spacex's broader ambitions to get people to the Moon and to
Mars, they're in question right now.
Now, the outcome of this investigation and the
environmental assessment process will be critical in shaping how
SpaceX does operations down to Starbase.
The company's ability to secure the necessary permits and
address regulatory concerns will determine also whether it can
proceed with its planned expansion of launch activities.
And at the same time, the voices of local communities,
environmental groups will continue to play an important
role in this. Now, SpaceX does plan to launch
rockets from another tower at Starbase.
They have tower one that they've continuously launched on and
they also are building tower two right now and they're going to
launch and land rockets at both tower one and at tower two.
So anything that happens with his environment stuff has to do
with tower one and also tower two.
So let me know what you think down in the comments.
It's a really tough situation for SpaceX here because they
want to build rockets that can send people to the moon and to
Mars, but they also want to do the right thing for the
environment. And they think they're doing the
right thing right now. They think they are.
But the data shows, some of the data shows, and it's been
refuted numerous times since any of these reports came out.
It's gone back and forth, but what is SpaceX going to do?
That's what we're really worried about here are are they going to
be able to make the necessary changes to appease the people in
the region and also the regulatory bodies?
Let me know what you think in the comments.
That's about it for today, guys. Take care of yourselves and each
other. Make sure to hit the subscribe
button too, and the like button. And if you're really cool, make
a comment with a rocket emoji down below.
That'd be really cool, thanks again.
Take care of yourselves and each other and I will see you in the
next one.