Welcome back to the Elon Musk Podcast.
This is a show where we discuss the critical crossroads, the
shape SpaceX, Tesla X. The Boring Company and
Neuralink. And I'm your host, Will Walden.
Tesla has settled another case involving a fatal crash linked
to alleged vehicle design defects, marking the second such
settlement this year. The case, filed in 2019,
pertains to a 2016 incident where a test the vehicle
reportedly accelerated uncontrollably in Indianapolis,
colliding with a tree and then caught fire.
This settlement follows a similar resolution in April
regarding a fatal crash involving Tesla's Autopilot
technology. Now, the lawsuit alleged that
the 2015 Model S involved in the Indianapolis crash had a
tendency to catch fire and a defective door latch system that
trapped the passenger inside. Now, the accident resulted in
the deaths of both driver Casey Speckman, who was intoxicated,
and the passenger Kevin McCarthy.
Now, McCarthy's family claimed the defects prevented him from
escaping from the burning vehicle.
Now, Tesla has consistently denied any fault, attributing
the crash to misuse or improper maintenance of the vehicle.
And in its response, Tesla maintained that its cars meet
all relevant safety standards. This case's settlement indicates
the shift from CEO Elon Musk's previous stance against settling
what he termed unjust cases. Now, the recent settlements
contrast with Musk's 2022 declaration on Twitter, where he
vowed never to settle an unjust case even if it might result in
a loss. And in April, Tesla settled
another high profile lawsuit involving an Apple engineer who
died when his Model X crashed while allegedly using Autopilot.
Now, these settlements suggested that Tesla may be more willing
to resolve such cases out of court.
Now, Tesla's legal battles extend beyond these two cases.
The company faces numerous lawsuits across the country
related to alleged defects causing serious or fatal
accidents. At least eight pending lawsuits
are scheduled for trial next year, many involving claims that
crashes occurred while the driver relied on Tesla's
Autopilot technology. Federal regulators are also
scrutinizing Tesla. The National Hwy.
Traffic Safety Administration, or the NHTSA, is investigating
whether Tesla's Autopilot system misleads drivers into believing
it has more capabilities than it does.
This regulatory attention adds pressure to test those legal
challenges right now. And in the Indianapolis crash,
the plaintiffs argued this Speckman lost control of the
Model S when it suddenly accelerated while she tried to
avoid an oncoming vehicle. The car crashed into a tree and
then a parking structure, bursting into flames.
The witnesses reportedly saw McCarthy attempting to escape
but being unable due to the vehicle's design defects.
Now, Tesla has faced multiple complaints regarding fires
allegedly linked to its batteries.
Experts know that electric vehicle batteries can burn more
intensely and for longer durations than internal
combustion engines. This has raised concerns about
the safety of Tesla's battery design and in the lawsuit,
McCarthy's family detailed how he could not escape due to the
post crash fire and the defective door latch system.
Tesla, however, encountered that their vehicles are
state-of-the-art and comply with all safety regulations denying
any defect in the door latch system now.
Separately, Speckman's family filed a lawsuit against Tesla in
2019. After Tesla's attempt to dismiss
the case was denied in February 2023, a settlement was reached
two months later. The specifics of the settlement
remain confidential now. The settlement with McCarthy's
family was announced just days before the trial was set to
begin. Court records describe it as
conditional, but no further details have been provided.
Neither Tesla nor the McCarthy family's lawyers have commented
on the settlement, and in previous cases involving Tesla's
Autopilot, the company has had mixed results, and two
California trials juries concluded that driver error, not
the technology, was to blame for the accidents.
These outcome support must claim the Tesla vehicles are among the
safest on the road, and the case involving the Apple engineer,
who died in 2018 when his Model X crashed into a highway
barrier, was particularly contentious.
The engineer's family argued that Tesla's Autopilot system
was faulty. The confidential settlement
recent April avoided a potentially lengthy and costly
trial for Tesla. Now, despite the legal
challenges, Tesla continues to defend its vehicle safety.
The company points to its rigorous safety standards and
compliance with government regulations.
However, the increasing number of lawsuits and settlements
suggest a growing concern over Tesla's vehicle design and
safety features. The settlements and ongoing
lawsuits could have implications for Tesla's public image and
financial performance. And investors and customers
alike are watching how the company navigates these legal
challenges right now. And Tesla's ability to maintain
its reputation as a leading innovator in the EV market may
hinge on the outcomes of these cases.
Now, while Tesla faces more lawsuits in the future designing
and doing the Autopilot tech, the company's legal strategy
will be under scrutiny as well. The decisions to settle recent
cases indicate a possible shift in approach, potentially aiming
to minimize public trials and adverse publicity.
Regulatory scrutiny, particularly the NHTSA, could
lead to further changes in how Tesla designs and markets its
vehicles. Any findings from ongoing
investigations might result in recalls or modifications to
existing safety features impacting Tesla's operations
now. The outcomes of these cases will
likely influence future litigation involving Tesla.
If more plaintiffs succeed in their claims, Tesla could face
increased legal costs and pressure to enhance its vehicle
safety standards. Conversely, favorable rulings
for Tesla could reinforce its stance on the safety and the
reliability of its vehicles. Hey, thank.
You so much for listening today. I really do appreciate your
support. If you could take a second and
hit the subscribe or the follow button on whatever podcast
platform that you're listening on right now, I greatly
appreciate it. It helps out the show
tremendously and you'll never miss an episode.
And each. Episode is about 10 minutes or
less to get you caught up quickly.
And please, if you want to support the show even more, go
to patreon.com/stage Zero and please take care of yourselves
and each other and I'll see you tomorrow.