Hey everybody. Welcome back to the Elon Musk
Podcast. This is a show where we discuss
the critical crossroads, the Shape, SpaceX, Tesla X, The
Boring Company, and Neuralink. I'm your host, Will Walden.
Tesla has embarked on a legal fight to reinstate Elon Musk's
pay package valued at about $56 billion.
This is despite the company's shareholders reapproving the
package for a second time. There's a stark divide between
the visionary leadership that Musk embodies and the practical
realities of running a car manufacturing business now.
The repercussions of this decision may significantly
impact Tesla's future, given Musk's business strategies in
the past. Now, Tesla has long juggled 2
competing identities. On one hand, it operates as a
car manufacturer facing the tough realities of producing and
selling complex EVs, and on the other, it function as a dream
factory driven by Musk's grandiose visions and market
magic. This dual nature has
historically worked to Tesla's advantage, with Musk's charisma
and storytelling often over shattering operational
challenges. So this landscape is shifting
though. Tesla score business is
struggling right now, and Musk's hype is pushing the boundaries
of fantasy, leading to reputational damage and also
legal entanglements. Despite these issues, Tesla
shareholders have thrown their support behind Musk's visionary
identity, choosing to risk the company's future on his
ambitious dreamweaving. Starting in 2013, Musk crafted a
new kind of social financial phenomenon blending high tech
hype with online virality. His ability to inspire
confidence in Tesla's future dominance and ambitious
technical goals has been his primary value to the company.
Other than his technical abilities now more than his
managerial or engineering skills as well.
What began is exaggerations of achievable goals like solar
powered superchargers has escalating to taking pre
payments for self driving capabilities that remain
unfulfilled. Now, I want you to know I am a
big supporter of Tesla, but you can't overlook these things.
Musk's grand visions, including robotaxis and humanoid robots,
have distance Tesla from reality for a lot of people.
These ideas are now central to Tesla's new values.
Despite being under a federal fraud investigation and numerous
civil lawsuits, this hype began to diverge from Musk from
reality around the same time his power over Tesla's governance
solidified. A pivotal moment was in 2018
when Musk demanded Tesla's board to vouch for his indiacrity
following SC CS fraud charges over his quote funding secured
tweet. Now, that year, the board
approved his $56 billion compensation package focused
more on market capitalization than operational performance,
studying the stage for ongoing fantastical narratives.
For much of the past five years, Tesla's operational challenges
were mitigated by favorable market conditions.
The model wise release coincided with peak EV hype and supply
chain constraints, allowing Tesla to charge premium prices.
However, as supply constraints eased and competition increased,
Tesla's sales and profits have began to weigh and waver.
With Tesla Score business no longer showing endless growth,
Musk's leadership style faces increasing criticism.
His purchase of Twitter and subsequent involvement in
culture wars has further distracted him from Tesla,
according to some people. And it's also damaging its
inclusive brand and market appeal, according to those
people. I want to reiterate, I don't
feel this way now. Instead of expanding Tesla's
market with affordable vehicles, Musk invested in the divisive
cyber truck. The vehicle, designed more as
kind of a meme than a serious contender in the truck market,
reflects Musk's penchant for creating viral yet impractical
products. Heading to Tesla's woes, Musk
and SpaceX both face lawsuits from former employees alleging a
toxic workplace culture and Musk's inappropriate behavior.
These issues, coupled with his publicized romantic
entanglements, paint a troubling picture of leadership.
Tesla's recent reincorporation in Texas, which was approved by
shareholders, is about more than saving $255,000 annually in
state fees. It's Musk's attempt to distance
Tesla from Delaware's stringent shareholder protections after
losing a case over his pay package.
According to people that don't like Elon Musk, this move is
seen by some as a gamble on Musk's critical role in the
company. Now, Texas, which has been
attracting businesses with lower taxes and a new business court
system, offers a potentially more favorable legal environment
for Tesla. However, the uncertainty of new
courts and potentially influential judges raises
concerns about predictability in legal outcomes.
Tesla's not the first company to move away from Delaware, though.
Companies like Microsoft and TripAdvisor have also set more
favorable legal environments. This trend reflects broader
concerns about Delaware's stringent corporate governance
standards. And while the legal differences
between Delaware and Texas are kind of minor, they can impact
corporate decisions. For instance, mergers may
require higher shareholder approval in Texas, and it's
harder for shareholders to inspect company books there.
These nuances can influence corporate strategies and also
governance. Now, Delaware's extensive legal
precedents provide A level of predictability that Texas lacks.
This predictability is valuable for corporate boards and
attorneys in assessing legal risks and outcomes, something
Texas courts will need time to develop.
And Tesla justifies its move to Texas by highlighting its
innovative spirit in the minor financial benefits.
The company argues that embracing new approaches aligns
with its culture and history of taking bold steps now, despite
this relocation, legal battles over Musk's pay package are
likely to continue in Delaware courts.
This ongoing litigation underscores the complexities and
risks of corporate governance under Elon Musk's leadership.
And as Tesla navigates these challenges, the future hinges on
Musk's ability to balance his very ambitious, visionary ways
with practical business realities.
The company's success will depend on addressing operational
hurdles while maintaining the innovative edge that is defined
as brand now. Tesla's journey under Musk's
leadership remains a high stakes balance act between visionary
innovation and operational execution.
The legal battles and corporate decisions unfolding now will
shape the company's trajectory in the years to come.
Hey, thank you so much for listening today.
I really do appreciate your support.
If you could take a second and hit the subscribe or the follow
button on whatever podcast platform that you're listening
on right now, I greatly appreciate it.
It helps out the show tremendously and you'll never
miss an episode. And each episode is about 10
minutes or less to get you caught up quickly.
And please, if you want to support the show even more, go
to patreon.com/stage Zero. And please take care of
yourselves and each other, and I'll see you tomorrow.