1
00:00:00,200 --> 00:00:03,240
Coming up next on Words and 
Numbers, Jimmy Kimmel. 

2
00:00:03,560 --> 00:00:06,440
The balance of power and 
congressional numbers. 

3
00:00:06,800 --> 00:00:10,880
United States passports. 
And Clark Neely joins us to talk

4
00:00:10,880 --> 00:00:14,080
about privileges and immunities.
Hi, I'm James. 

5
00:00:14,080 --> 00:00:16,040
And I'm Anthony and. 
This is words and numbers. 

6
00:00:21,480 --> 00:00:24,320
Our comments on words and 
numbers reflect our own thinking

7
00:00:24,320 --> 00:00:27,120
and are of no reflection of our 
employers. 

8
00:00:27,560 --> 00:00:30,640
But my comments, unlike 
Anthony's, should be 

9
00:00:30,640 --> 00:00:34,920
everybody's. 
So, Aunt, what's new and 

10
00:00:34,920 --> 00:00:36,440
exciting in your world this 
week? 

11
00:00:37,160 --> 00:00:41,520
Two things came across my desk 
within an hour of each other, 

12
00:00:42,040 --> 00:00:45,560
apparently different but 
interestingly linked. 

13
00:00:46,200 --> 00:00:50,280
The first one was Americans 
approval rating of Congress. 

14
00:00:50,280 --> 00:00:53,480
This is from Gallup, just came 
out. 

15
00:00:53,920 --> 00:00:56,720
Have they gotten over that 20% 
hurdle yet? 

16
00:00:57,240 --> 00:01:05,800
Oh, James, sweet child, no. 
Well, they try and. 

17
00:01:05,800 --> 00:01:10,640
Try and try the The fraction of 
Americans who approve of 

18
00:01:10,640 --> 00:01:12,800
Congress is 10. 
Percent. 

19
00:01:13,480 --> 00:01:17,280
That makes that 32% approval 
rating Donald Trump has look 

20
00:01:17,280 --> 00:01:21,480
astronomical. 
He's literally three times a 

21
00:01:21,480 --> 00:01:23,440
number of Americans, right? 
Three times. 

22
00:01:24,560 --> 00:01:27,200
But what's interesting here, I'm
looking at at Gallup's numbers 

23
00:01:27,200 --> 00:01:33,440
and they go back to looks like 
1974 and it looks like Congress 

24
00:01:33,440 --> 00:01:36,760
had a lower approval rating only
once. 

25
00:01:36,760 --> 00:01:42,920
That was in November of 2013 at 
9%. 9 Good God. 

26
00:01:43,360 --> 00:01:46,320
Of course, Congress, Congress, 
no doubt I can hear them saying 

27
00:01:46,320 --> 00:01:49,160
hold my beard, just come back 
next month and we'll see what 

28
00:01:49,160 --> 00:01:51,520
they can do. 
But that's, that's one of the 

29
00:01:51,520 --> 00:01:54,640
two articles that came across. 
And it's it's kind of not, it's 

30
00:01:54,640 --> 00:01:58,880
not surprising that Americans 
hold Congress in contempt like 

31
00:01:58,880 --> 00:02:00,280
this. 
I was a little bit surprised at 

32
00:02:00,280 --> 00:02:02,280
the extent to which, but 
nonetheless. 

33
00:02:02,600 --> 00:02:04,320
Contempt. 
Here's Congress actually has 2 

34
00:02:04,320 --> 00:02:08,759
completely different meanings. 
Here's the other article. 

35
00:02:08,759 --> 00:02:12,520
The other article is 
highlighting that Prince 

36
00:02:12,520 --> 00:02:15,360
Charles, of course, is here in 
Washington this week. 

37
00:02:15,360 --> 00:02:16,680
King. 
Charles. 

38
00:02:16,840 --> 00:02:18,600
Oh, I'm sorry, King Charles. 
Yeah. 

39
00:02:19,200 --> 00:02:23,320
In Washington this week, he 
addressed Congress. 

40
00:02:23,880 --> 00:02:29,120
And in his address to Congress, 
he's pointing to EU KS own 

41
00:02:29,120 --> 00:02:35,960
Declaration of Rights from the 
1690s and the Magna Carta, both 

42
00:02:35,960 --> 00:02:39,440
of which were documents that 
that expressed ideas that the 

43
00:02:39,440 --> 00:02:43,080
founders drew on when they wrote
our founding documents. 

44
00:02:43,520 --> 00:02:49,440
And the interesting thing was 
King Charles underlined the need

45
00:02:49,720 --> 00:02:54,400
for the checks and balances 
amongst the various branches of 

46
00:02:54,400 --> 00:02:58,920
government, which of course 
people took as a slap at Donald 

47
00:02:58,920 --> 00:03:01,600
Trump. 
Oh, that's a slap at Congress. 

48
00:03:01,920 --> 00:03:05,960
It's a slap at Congress exactly 
because the the problem, Of 

49
00:03:05,960 --> 00:03:09,120
course we don't have functioning
checks and balances now. 

50
00:03:09,120 --> 00:03:13,080
It's not because Donald Trump is
doing more than he should, which

51
00:03:13,080 --> 00:03:15,560
I don't disagree, he is doing 
more than he should. 

52
00:03:15,720 --> 00:03:20,680
Donald Trump is doing Donald 
Trump is doing exactly what the 

53
00:03:20,680 --> 00:03:23,680
framers of the American 
Constitution predicted 

54
00:03:23,680 --> 00:03:26,360
presidents would do. 
He is. 

55
00:03:26,760 --> 00:03:30,000
That's not to, that's not to 
defend what he's doing, but it 

56
00:03:30,000 --> 00:03:34,080
is to say that we anticipate, we
the founders anticipated this 

57
00:03:34,520 --> 00:03:38,920
and built in checks and 
balances, 1/3 of which is 

58
00:03:38,920 --> 00:03:40,640
failing. 
Here's Congress. 

59
00:03:40,640 --> 00:03:45,000
Congress stood up and applauded 
when control said, yo, you 

60
00:03:45,000 --> 00:03:48,040
should have checks and balances.
Well, they can find their hands 

61
00:03:48,040 --> 00:03:50,320
to applaud. 
Why can't they find their hands 

62
00:03:50,320 --> 00:03:54,960
to to censure, or to impeach or 
to do whatever, simply pass a 

63
00:03:54,960 --> 00:03:57,680
law? 
That is that. 

64
00:03:58,000 --> 00:04:01,840
Constrains the executive branch.
I want Danny to get his bleeping

65
00:04:01,840 --> 00:04:06,360
finger ready because it would 
have been hilarious if King 

66
00:04:06,360 --> 00:04:11,360
Charles had said and you, dopey 
mother, you're the problem. 

67
00:04:11,760 --> 00:04:17,680
Yes, yes, that would exactly. 
Alas, it was not to be. 

68
00:04:18,800 --> 00:04:20,600
But. 
But let's talk about something 

69
00:04:20,600 --> 00:04:21,920
that might end. 
Up. 

70
00:04:22,200 --> 00:04:29,080
Being a just outcome, Jimmy 
Kimmel again, running his mouth 

71
00:04:29,360 --> 00:04:33,000
at a time when he really 
shouldn't be right at every now 

72
00:04:33,000 --> 00:04:35,800
and again he says something 
boneheadedly stupid. 

73
00:04:36,080 --> 00:04:39,120
And I don't think Jimmy is the 
sharpest knife in the drawer. 

74
00:04:39,440 --> 00:04:43,440
But, you know, be that as it 
may, he's got quite the pulpit. 

75
00:04:43,960 --> 00:04:48,800
Every night he's on ABC 
hammering away and he referred 

76
00:04:48,800 --> 00:04:52,040
to Melania Trump. 
And as we record this, I think 

77
00:04:52,040 --> 00:04:56,600
we're what, 3-4 days out from 
the assassination attempt of 

78
00:04:56,600 --> 00:05:00,360
Donald Trump. 
He referred to Melania Trump as 

79
00:05:01,160 --> 00:05:07,720
an expectant wiggle 00. 
And, you know, Jimmy ran afoul 

80
00:05:08,040 --> 00:05:11,240
of the the Trump crowd 
previously. 

81
00:05:11,240 --> 00:05:13,120
And I thought they had a point 
then. 

82
00:05:13,920 --> 00:05:19,960
I know they have a point now. 
This was too much, too soon, too

83
00:05:19,960 --> 00:05:24,840
far, and I do hereby predict 
Jimmy Kimmel will be fired for 

84
00:05:24,840 --> 00:05:28,000
it and we will never have to 
look at him on late night TV 

85
00:05:28,000 --> 00:05:30,160
again. 
Well, that's the kind of thing 

86
00:05:30,160 --> 00:05:33,240
that that attracts the attention
of the Secret Service. 

87
00:05:33,240 --> 00:05:36,760
They start doing checks what it 
is you actually mean by what 

88
00:05:36,760 --> 00:05:39,840
you're saying. 
The Secret Service is not his 

89
00:05:39,840 --> 00:05:43,120
concern. 
The advertisers and the network 

90
00:05:43,120 --> 00:05:47,040
executives are his concern. 
Sweep Sweep is coming up and 

91
00:05:47,040 --> 00:05:49,520
they got a real problem now and 
they're going to they're going 

92
00:05:49,520 --> 00:05:53,080
to dump him as fast as they 
would dump a red hot coal. 

93
00:05:53,640 --> 00:05:57,120
If if he's still here when we 
record next week, I'll be 

94
00:05:57,120 --> 00:05:59,760
shocked. 
But given that we're recording 

95
00:05:59,760 --> 00:06:03,360
next week's episode in 5 
minutes, I won't have anything 

96
00:06:03,360 --> 00:06:06,920
to say about this next week. 
Which of course, aunt, brings us

97
00:06:06,920 --> 00:06:10,000
to the foolishness of the week. 
Do you have a passport? 

98
00:06:11,160 --> 00:06:14,720
I do just got my renewed. 
You have to have a passport 

99
00:06:14,720 --> 00:06:17,320
because you like to go for long 
idiotic walks in Spain. 

100
00:06:17,760 --> 00:06:20,840
That's right. 
And when you open your passport,

101
00:06:20,840 --> 00:06:23,600
what do you see? 
Picture of me? 

102
00:06:24,080 --> 00:06:25,600
Yeah. 
Yeah, it's not what I'm talking 

103
00:06:25,600 --> 00:06:26,840
about, you narcissist. 
I. 

104
00:06:29,240 --> 00:06:32,280
Don't know shining papers. 
Stuff typically the Statue of 

105
00:06:32,280 --> 00:06:33,800
Liberty, right? 
Things like this. 

106
00:06:34,080 --> 00:06:35,800
Oh, the stuff in the background,
yeah. 

107
00:06:35,840 --> 00:06:39,640
Yeah, now, aunt, you're, you're 
going to be able to get a 

108
00:06:39,640 --> 00:06:43,800
passport for the 250th 
anniversary of the United States

109
00:06:43,800 --> 00:06:45,840
of America. 
Don't kill me. 

110
00:06:46,480 --> 00:06:47,800
Oh, no. 
No, please. 

111
00:06:47,800 --> 00:06:50,120
No, Please no. 
With Donald Trump's. 

112
00:06:50,160 --> 00:06:54,440
Picture on it and you called me 
a. 

113
00:06:54,440 --> 00:06:59,320
Narcissist There can be more 
than one narcissist in the 

114
00:06:59,320 --> 00:07:02,800
world. 
There are lesser and greater 

115
00:07:02,800 --> 00:07:08,360
degrees of narcissism. 
The passports will only be 

116
00:07:08,360 --> 00:07:11,480
available at the Washington 
Passport Agency. 

117
00:07:12,080 --> 00:07:15,800
I wasn't aware there were other 
passport agencies, but OK. 

118
00:07:16,120 --> 00:07:19,640
And any American citizen, quote,
UN quote, who applies for a 

119
00:07:19,640 --> 00:07:23,960
passport when the rollout 
happens will be entitled to one 

120
00:07:23,960 --> 00:07:30,200
of the special Donald Trump 
250th anniversary passports. 

121
00:07:30,480 --> 00:07:34,680
You know, I, I kind of want to 
get one, not because I want it 

122
00:07:34,920 --> 00:07:39,240
for itself, but I can imagine 20
years from now that's going to 

123
00:07:39,240 --> 00:07:43,360
be a collector's item. 
It could be, but given the use 

124
00:07:43,360 --> 00:07:46,800
that a passport serves, you 
would go to a European country 

125
00:07:46,800 --> 00:07:52,600
and flash that and then all the 
back on the plane, you know, 

126
00:07:52,640 --> 00:07:55,400
they bring you into the special 
bad boy room and they make you 

127
00:07:55,400 --> 00:07:58,360
open up all your bags. 
You don't. 

128
00:07:58,360 --> 00:08:01,360
You don't want this, but but 
here we are. 

129
00:08:01,840 --> 00:08:04,800
It's at least a benign 
foolishness of the week. 

130
00:08:04,800 --> 00:08:07,640
And I like the foolishness of 
the week to be rather benign. 

131
00:08:07,880 --> 00:08:10,520
Right. 
In a week in which we watch 

132
00:08:10,520 --> 00:08:13,680
somebody try to kill the 
president, at least this is 

133
00:08:13,680 --> 00:08:16,760
funny. 
Clark Neely joins us again this 

134
00:08:16,760 --> 00:08:18,880
week. 
Clark is senior vice president 

135
00:08:19,040 --> 00:08:21,160
for legal studies at the Cato 
Institute. 

136
00:08:21,760 --> 00:08:23,680
Clark, welcome back to WORDS and
NUMBERS. 

137
00:08:24,600 --> 00:08:27,360
It's great to be back. 
I'm sorry you were. 

138
00:08:27,480 --> 00:08:31,080
Very nice to see you again. 
You were out of town last 

139
00:08:31,080 --> 00:08:32,960
weekend. 
My mother was in town. 

140
00:08:33,320 --> 00:08:38,240
And so I threw a bit of a party 
and had invited you over. 

141
00:08:38,240 --> 00:08:39,919
And of course, I told her that 
you're around town. 

142
00:08:39,919 --> 00:08:42,960
You couldn't make it. 
And she was, she was quite 

143
00:08:43,360 --> 00:08:46,680
disturbed. 
She was looking forward to 

144
00:08:46,680 --> 00:08:48,480
seeing you. 
There's like the high point. 

145
00:08:48,480 --> 00:08:50,440
You didn't care about me, but 
you wanted to see you. 

146
00:08:50,440 --> 00:08:53,160
She did get to see Phil Magnus. 
That was OK. 

147
00:08:53,160 --> 00:08:56,920
But she misses Clark Neely. 
So your mother and I have this 

148
00:08:56,920 --> 00:09:00,080
in common. 
I'm really thrilled to see Clark

149
00:09:00,080 --> 00:09:02,440
and I, you know, whatever with 
you. 

150
00:09:03,280 --> 00:09:06,840
I, I, I hesitate to say 
something like this to you 

151
00:09:06,840 --> 00:09:11,280
because we've had conversations 
before, but what's going on? 

152
00:09:12,120 --> 00:09:13,720
You know, it's funny, I don't 
want to sound like a 1 trick 

153
00:09:13,720 --> 00:09:16,360
pony, so I'm going to, I'm going
to ask you like, do you mean 

154
00:09:16,360 --> 00:09:19,040
like in the world with 
institutional law? 

155
00:09:19,560 --> 00:09:23,440
Well, me Kanwa is your thing and
you know I've got one in the 

156
00:09:23,440 --> 00:09:27,160
chamber if you'd like me to, to 
fire it, but. 

157
00:09:28,120 --> 00:09:32,400
You know, I would say the 
president's relentless efforts 

158
00:09:32,440 --> 00:09:37,440
to persecute and prosecute his 
perceived political enemies 

159
00:09:37,440 --> 00:09:39,280
continues. 
We've just seen the second 

160
00:09:39,280 --> 00:09:42,440
indictment of James comedy. 
This one's even more 

161
00:09:42,440 --> 00:09:45,120
preposterous than the first one,
if that's even possible. 

162
00:09:45,760 --> 00:09:51,400
Let's be fair, Clark. 
He did write 8647 in Seashells 

163
00:09:51,680 --> 00:09:55,200
in the Sand. 
I mean, who wouldn't take that 

164
00:09:55,480 --> 00:09:57,920
as a legitimate threat on the 
life of the president? 

165
00:09:58,440 --> 00:10:01,080
Well, obviously a grand jury in 
the Eastern District of North 

166
00:10:01,080 --> 00:10:03,520
Carolina found that to be an 
incredibly reckless and and 

167
00:10:03,520 --> 00:10:07,640
sinister act. 
I think that helps us, helps 

168
00:10:07,640 --> 00:10:12,000
remind us that a competent 
prosecutor can in fact indict a 

169
00:10:12,000 --> 00:10:14,920
ham sandwich. 
And these days of course, could 

170
00:10:14,920 --> 00:10:17,600
get the same ham sandwich to 
plead guilty to being a Turkey 

171
00:10:17,600 --> 00:10:20,400
sub. 
That's preferably right. 

172
00:10:20,720 --> 00:10:21,040
Yeah. 
So. 

173
00:10:21,760 --> 00:10:23,560
That happens in this case 
remains to be seen. 

174
00:10:23,560 --> 00:10:25,840
I think this, I think this 
latest indictment, just for 

175
00:10:25,840 --> 00:10:30,120
those who have not seen it, 
comedy took a picture of or at 

176
00:10:30,120 --> 00:10:34,040
least posted on Twitter, a 
picture of the, the the numbers 

177
00:10:34,040 --> 00:10:40,800
8647 spelled out in seashells on
the beach and said, oh, I just 

178
00:10:40,800 --> 00:10:43,920
saw this out for a walk today. 
86 Of course, for anybody who's 

179
00:10:43,920 --> 00:10:46,200
worked in the restaurant 
industry knows that's a term, 

180
00:10:46,440 --> 00:10:50,800
slang term for it. 
We're out of a particular dish. 

181
00:10:50,800 --> 00:10:52,920
So we can't let anybody else 
order that. 

182
00:10:52,920 --> 00:10:56,240
It's also slang for for throwing
somebody out of a bar. 

183
00:10:56,440 --> 00:10:59,960
And in this case, it's being 
interpreted as a serious 

184
00:11:00,440 --> 00:11:05,640
suggestion to kill the 47th 
president of the United States, 

185
00:11:05,640 --> 00:11:06,800
which is, of course, Donald 
Trump. 

186
00:11:06,800 --> 00:11:09,800
This is, it's hard for me to 
believe I'm saying this, but 

187
00:11:09,800 --> 00:11:14,400
this might just be the most 
preposterous thing, the most 

188
00:11:14,400 --> 00:11:17,800
preposterous and malicious abuse
of power we've seen this 

189
00:11:17,800 --> 00:11:20,400
administration perpetuate to 
date. 

190
00:11:20,880 --> 00:11:23,560
And this, this indictment is 
going to be laughed out of 

191
00:11:23,560 --> 00:11:25,960
court. 
And it might even be so bad that

192
00:11:25,960 --> 00:11:28,360
it could be one of the the 
vanishingly rare cases that 

193
00:11:28,360 --> 00:11:33,800
actually gives rise to a a 
viable claim for attorneys fees 

194
00:11:33,800 --> 00:11:36,760
on the part of the exonerated 
defendant. 

195
00:11:36,760 --> 00:11:39,600
There is a provision in federal 
law that permits that to happen.

196
00:11:39,960 --> 00:11:43,640
Courts almost never allow it, 
both because it's a stringent 

197
00:11:43,640 --> 00:11:45,640
standard and because a 
disproportionate number of 

198
00:11:45,640 --> 00:11:47,480
judges are former prosecutors 
themselves. 

199
00:11:47,480 --> 00:11:49,160
And that's a kind of a 
professional courtesy. 

200
00:11:49,560 --> 00:11:51,280
But this one I think actually 
might do it. 

201
00:11:51,960 --> 00:11:57,840
But wait, there's more, because 
comedy then took down the post 

202
00:11:58,080 --> 00:12:03,120
almost immediately and 
apologized on Instagram almost 

203
00:12:03,120 --> 00:12:05,720
immediately. 
Well, there's your men's Rea, 

204
00:12:05,720 --> 00:12:06,960
James. 
He knew what he was doing. 

205
00:12:07,120 --> 00:12:09,160
Wrong. 
That's exactly what they're 

206
00:12:09,160 --> 00:12:11,320
going to say. 
That's exactly what they're 

207
00:12:11,320 --> 00:12:14,960
going to say. 
Does does the 86 necessarily get

208
00:12:14,960 --> 00:12:19,480
interpreted as as kill the 
president as opposed to impeach 

209
00:12:19,480 --> 00:12:23,000
and remove? 
It it's, I mean, it's an 

210
00:12:23,000 --> 00:12:25,360
entirely subjective, I don't 
know if you've heard, but some 

211
00:12:25,360 --> 00:12:30,320
language can be subjective. 
And I don't know exactly, you 

212
00:12:30,320 --> 00:12:33,280
know, sort of we might have to 
bring in an expert to see if 

213
00:12:33,280 --> 00:12:36,040
seashells are capable of of 
encoding inflection. 

214
00:12:36,360 --> 00:12:39,880
Maybe that matters here. 
But the idea that a former 

215
00:12:40,080 --> 00:12:43,160
director of the FBI, you know, 
even frankly, a kind of an 

216
00:12:43,160 --> 00:12:46,440
authoritarian nitwit like James 
Comedy, which I think frankly he

217
00:12:46,440 --> 00:12:49,840
is, I don't have much regard for
him, as you probably can tell. 

218
00:12:50,480 --> 00:12:53,600
But the idea that he would 
publicly call for the 

219
00:12:53,600 --> 00:12:57,960
assassination of a sitting 
president is, is preposterous 

220
00:12:58,320 --> 00:13:02,240
beyond words for a variety of 
reasons. 

221
00:13:02,600 --> 00:13:05,720
But, you know, I think rather 
clearly he just thought that was

222
00:13:05,720 --> 00:13:09,800
sort of a clever, you know, 
almost kind of a, a numerical 

223
00:13:09,800 --> 00:13:13,120
Morse code of, of a sort. 
And but yeah, I think. 

224
00:13:13,240 --> 00:13:16,680
And you're, you know, none of us
can get inside his head. 

225
00:13:16,680 --> 00:13:19,240
But it seems to me that's a much
more plausible interpretation 

226
00:13:19,840 --> 00:13:22,880
basically that what he's really 
trying to convey is it's time 

227
00:13:22,880 --> 00:13:25,400
to, you know, it's time to get 
rid of this, this bumbling 

228
00:13:25,400 --> 00:13:27,560
fascist rube in the, in the 
White House. 

229
00:13:27,560 --> 00:13:30,360
I, I, I said a word that just 
came out of my mouth. 

230
00:13:30,360 --> 00:13:33,200
I, I don't, I hope that doesn't 
set off a whole, you know, 

231
00:13:33,200 --> 00:13:35,680
conflagration. 
I use the F word to describe 

232
00:13:35,680 --> 00:13:37,280
Trump. 
Others have as well. 

233
00:13:37,280 --> 00:13:39,760
I think we're past that point. 
I think you don't have to use 

234
00:13:39,760 --> 00:13:42,120
the word, but I don't think it's
possible anymore to criticize 

235
00:13:42,120 --> 00:13:45,280
people who do. 
And and Clark, I think it's kind

236
00:13:45,280 --> 00:13:49,400
of interesting actually the the 
timing of the announcement of 

237
00:13:49,400 --> 00:13:54,200
the prosecution coming so tight 
to the the attempted 

238
00:13:54,200 --> 00:13:56,440
assassination just a couple of 
days ago. 

239
00:13:57,280 --> 00:14:00,160
Well, yes and no. 
I mean this, this grand jury 

240
00:14:00,160 --> 00:14:02,280
would have to have been 
empanelled and considering 

241
00:14:02,280 --> 00:14:06,800
evidence almost certainly before
the events at the at the the 

242
00:14:06,800 --> 00:14:08,960
dinner. 
But yeah, maybe. 

243
00:14:08,960 --> 00:14:11,520
Well, they, I mean, they, they 
could have waited two weeks. 

244
00:14:12,960 --> 00:14:15,360
Well, I suppose that's right. 
I suppose that's right. 

245
00:14:15,360 --> 00:14:17,600
Whether whether the timing is 
just, you know, entirely 

246
00:14:17,600 --> 00:14:19,440
coincidental or not, I think 
it's something that's not 

247
00:14:19,440 --> 00:14:23,040
transparent to us, but, you 
know, perhaps, perhaps it's more

248
00:14:23,040 --> 00:14:28,600
than a coincidence. 
And given the God, can you even 

249
00:14:28,600 --> 00:14:32,800
call it news conference anymore?
Given the news conference that I

250
00:14:32,800 --> 00:14:36,440
saw this afternoon, they've 
apparently been investigating 

251
00:14:36,440 --> 00:14:39,800
this heinous act for 10:50. 
Months. 

252
00:14:40,880 --> 00:14:42,520
Well, that sounds about right 
for the feds. 

253
00:14:42,920 --> 00:14:47,160
I mean, it's it's one, it's one 
photograph posted briefly and 

254
00:14:47,480 --> 00:14:49,600
taken down from a social media 
site. 

255
00:14:49,600 --> 00:14:52,440
So I suppose nearly a year of 
investigations. 

256
00:14:52,440 --> 00:14:56,440
I mean, you may recall that I 
wrote about a case in my book 

257
00:14:56,440 --> 00:15:00,240
where the Hemingway Home and 
Museum in Key West, FL was 

258
00:15:00,720 --> 00:15:06,040
alleged to have been not 
providing overhead sleeping, 

259
00:15:06,280 --> 00:15:10,800
sleeping compartments for cats. 
They have about two dozen or 

260
00:15:10,800 --> 00:15:14,840
three dozen cats on the premises
of that museum and they did not 

261
00:15:14,840 --> 00:15:17,640
have enclosed and covered 
sleeping areas for the cats. 

262
00:15:17,640 --> 00:15:19,960
And I believe the Department of 
Agriculture took something like 

263
00:15:19,960 --> 00:15:24,120
3 years to investigate that one.
But it involved multiple trips 

264
00:15:24,120 --> 00:15:27,120
by multiple teams of 
investigators to Key West and 

265
00:15:27,120 --> 00:15:30,680
even rented a like an Airbnb 
with a room that overlooked the 

266
00:15:30,680 --> 00:15:33,680
compound so they could document 
what nobody disputed, which is 

267
00:15:33,680 --> 00:15:35,080
that the cats are sleeping 
outside. 

268
00:15:35,080 --> 00:15:37,160
So. 
But you know, this doesn't sound

269
00:15:37,160 --> 00:15:42,520
like a a a an 
uncharacteristically long time 

270
00:15:42,520 --> 00:15:45,560
frame to nail down an undisputed
fact. 

271
00:15:46,960 --> 00:15:50,760
All right, so we've gotten that 
bee out of your bonnet there. 

272
00:15:50,840 --> 00:15:53,400
There was something I wanted to 
bring up. 

273
00:15:53,400 --> 00:15:57,600
And and I don't know if it's a 
broader trend or if my 

274
00:15:57,600 --> 00:16:02,560
algorithms have simply decided 
to spit these things out at me 

275
00:16:02,560 --> 00:16:06,720
and no one else. 
But it it seems to to be the 

276
00:16:06,720 --> 00:16:11,280
case in in my digital experience
that people are pushing back 

277
00:16:11,280 --> 00:16:15,560
awfully hard and courts are 
starting to agree on qualified 

278
00:16:15,560 --> 00:16:19,160
immunity. 
I would say I have that 

279
00:16:19,160 --> 00:16:23,600
impression to an extent. 
I, I don't, I, I think we'd be, 

280
00:16:23,600 --> 00:16:27,480
we want to be very careful about
suggesting that we can or have 

281
00:16:27,480 --> 00:16:29,840
actually quantified this. 
So your impression and my 

282
00:16:29,840 --> 00:16:32,920
impression probably line up in 
some ways. 

283
00:16:32,920 --> 00:16:36,120
I think there is more skepticism
in the last couple of years 

284
00:16:36,120 --> 00:16:40,320
about qualified immunity from 
courts than I've seen in the 

285
00:16:40,320 --> 00:16:42,120
past. 
But that might like be just 

286
00:16:42,120 --> 00:16:45,800
saying, well, hey look the 
needle on this thermometer moved

287
00:16:45,800 --> 00:16:48,200
and I think we actually might be
above absolute 0. 

288
00:16:48,800 --> 00:16:54,440
Yeah, I know, maybe it's just a 
warm summer, but it it's kind of

289
00:16:54,440 --> 00:16:59,240
nice to see local courts saying 
things like, oh, no, no, no, no,

290
00:16:59,240 --> 00:17:01,280
you don't get qualified immunity
for that. 

291
00:17:01,800 --> 00:17:04,440
And you know, who knows where 
this might lead? 

292
00:17:04,440 --> 00:17:07,640
This might this might turn out 
to be something crazy. 

293
00:17:08,480 --> 00:17:11,359
Well, if you'd like to put a 
wager on it, I'd be happy to do 

294
00:17:11,359 --> 00:17:11,839
that. 
Or if. 

295
00:17:12,960 --> 00:17:17,160
No, no, no, no, no. 
I'm not that crazy. 

296
00:17:17,599 --> 00:17:18,079
Come on. 
Yeah. 

297
00:17:18,119 --> 00:17:19,680
Look, I don't want to throw cold
water on it. 

298
00:17:19,680 --> 00:17:24,520
I do think that there's been a 
discernible shift in, in 

299
00:17:24,520 --> 00:17:26,480
judicial attitude towards 
qualified immunity. 

300
00:17:26,480 --> 00:17:31,400
But I, I doubt that it is 
showing up at, you know, in, in,

301
00:17:31,400 --> 00:17:33,440
in more than barely discernible 
terms. 

302
00:17:33,440 --> 00:17:37,680
Let's say it like the Court of 
Appeals level, you know where 

303
00:17:38,080 --> 00:17:39,840
like it. 
Does this indicate an actual 

304
00:17:39,840 --> 00:17:44,120
change in in legal doctrine so 
that you're you're if if you, if

305
00:17:44,120 --> 00:17:47,720
you do have a contested case 
involving an assertion of 

306
00:17:47,720 --> 00:17:51,840
qualified immunity, are your 
odds measurably better of 

307
00:17:51,840 --> 00:17:54,800
winning that in the past couple 
of years than they were, let's 

308
00:17:54,800 --> 00:17:56,280
say in the 10 or 20 years before
that? 

309
00:17:56,680 --> 00:17:58,840
My guess would be a little bit, 
but not much. 

310
00:17:59,480 --> 00:18:03,400
For for people who are new to 
us, can you give a brief 

311
00:18:03,680 --> 00:18:05,520
definition of qualified 
immunity? 

312
00:18:06,320 --> 00:18:08,360
Yeah, you bet. 
So this is a legal defense that 

313
00:18:08,360 --> 00:18:11,920
the Supreme Court invented out 
of whole cloth in the between 

314
00:18:11,920 --> 00:18:15,160
1967 and 1983. 
It kind of evolved a little bit 

315
00:18:15,160 --> 00:18:19,320
between those dates, but where 
it stands now is that if you sue

316
00:18:19,920 --> 00:18:22,600
a government official, 
including, for example, a police

317
00:18:22,600 --> 00:18:26,560
officer under federal civil 
rights law, it's not enough to 

318
00:18:26,560 --> 00:18:28,880
have a meritorious case. 
In other words, it's not enough 

319
00:18:29,120 --> 00:18:32,800
to be able to show that your 
rights were in fact violated by 

320
00:18:32,800 --> 00:18:34,240
the defendant that you have 
sued. 

321
00:18:34,520 --> 00:18:38,560
You also have to demonstrate 
that the the specific 

322
00:18:39,000 --> 00:18:42,880
application of the law in your 
case, that it is clearly 

323
00:18:42,880 --> 00:18:46,720
established that what that 
person did to you violated your 

324
00:18:46,720 --> 00:18:49,280
rights. 
And the only way to do that is 

325
00:18:49,280 --> 00:18:53,800
to identify a pre-existing case 
in your jurisdiction at the 

326
00:18:53,800 --> 00:18:56,920
appellate level where 
essentially the identical same 

327
00:18:56,920 --> 00:18:58,880
thing has happened to somebody 
else. 

328
00:18:58,880 --> 00:19:03,920
And a court has already said, 
yes, that specific thing, you 

329
00:19:03,920 --> 00:19:06,720
know, punching somebody in the 
face while they're wearing 

330
00:19:06,720 --> 00:19:11,080
handcuffs behind their body on a
Tuesday after they had a a meal 

331
00:19:11,080 --> 00:19:14,600
at Wendy's. 
OK, If that exact case is on the

332
00:19:14,600 --> 00:19:17,080
books and all those things have 
happened before, then it's 

333
00:19:17,080 --> 00:19:19,240
clearly established they 
shouldn't have done that to you.

334
00:19:19,520 --> 00:19:22,200
But if it's a Wednesday or if 
you had a meal at Taco Bell 

335
00:19:22,200 --> 00:19:25,040
instead, or the cuffs were 
cuffed in front, then they get 

336
00:19:25,040 --> 00:19:26,080
qualified immunity. 
Why? 

337
00:19:26,080 --> 00:19:28,040
Because it wasn't clearly 
established that they shouldn't 

338
00:19:28,040 --> 00:19:30,320
have done that to you. 
I'm exaggerating a little bit, 

339
00:19:30,320 --> 00:19:34,520
but only a little bit. 
And James, when you see these 

340
00:19:35,280 --> 00:19:39,920
these articles in your feed 
about pushback on immunity, is 

341
00:19:39,920 --> 00:19:42,600
this, this is the qualified 
immunity. 

342
00:19:42,600 --> 00:19:46,440
That's the version that police 
officers get, not the the 

343
00:19:46,840 --> 00:19:49,120
version on steroids that 
prosecutors get. 

344
00:19:49,120 --> 00:19:51,200
Is that right? 
Yeah, I'm only talking about 

345
00:19:51,200 --> 00:19:54,480
police officers and it's almost 
always at a very local 

346
00:19:54,480 --> 00:19:56,880
jurisdiction. 
Yeah. 

347
00:19:56,880 --> 00:20:01,640
So just to be clear, if you try 
to sue a prosecutor who has in 

348
00:20:01,640 --> 00:20:04,480
fact violated your rights, and 
that does happen from time to 

349
00:20:04,480 --> 00:20:08,880
time, you won't even have the 
opportunity to to overcome this 

350
00:20:08,880 --> 00:20:11,520
qualified immunity defense 
because prosecutors have 

351
00:20:11,520 --> 00:20:14,480
something called absolute 
prosecutorial immunity. 

352
00:20:14,760 --> 00:20:18,480
And it simply doesn't matter at 
that point how glaring the 

353
00:20:18,480 --> 00:20:22,600
rights violation was or whether 
there's any relevant case law on

354
00:20:22,600 --> 00:20:25,120
the books. 
Your case will simply be tossed 

355
00:20:25,120 --> 00:20:28,000
out because the person who. 
Violated your rights is a 

356
00:20:28,000 --> 00:20:30,320
prosecutor. 
And the Supreme Court has held 

357
00:20:30,600 --> 00:20:34,240
in its infinite wisdom and again
without a shred of textual basis

358
00:20:34,240 --> 00:20:37,920
in federal law that prosecutors 
must not be sued no matter how 

359
00:20:37,920 --> 00:20:40,560
badly they behave. 
And that is not an exaggeration.

360
00:20:40,560 --> 00:20:43,240
That is simply a faithful 
description and accurate 

361
00:20:43,240 --> 00:20:45,920
description of of what the 
Supreme Court has done in this 

362
00:20:45,920 --> 00:20:47,280
area. 
And it's, it's, it's an 

363
00:20:47,680 --> 00:20:50,240
abomination. 
So let let me push on that for a

364
00:20:50,240 --> 00:20:52,960
minute. 
If let's suppose hypothetically,

365
00:20:52,960 --> 00:20:57,240
a, a prosecutor is prosecuting 
someone for an alleged crime. 

366
00:20:57,760 --> 00:21:03,000
The prosecutor runs across 
evidence that that clearly 

367
00:21:03,000 --> 00:21:08,240
exonerates this person and the 
prosecutor destroys the evidence

368
00:21:09,680 --> 00:21:11,840
that was clearly destroying 
evidence is a crime. 

369
00:21:11,840 --> 00:21:15,800
This would be even, you know, 
worse than that, at least in in 

370
00:21:16,120 --> 00:21:19,280
the gut level, because the 
prosecutor knows that that this 

371
00:21:19,280 --> 00:21:22,440
guy is now innocent, yet he's 
prosecuting him anyway, Destroys

372
00:21:22,440 --> 00:21:25,320
the evidence. 
Does immunity cover him there? 

373
00:21:25,880 --> 00:21:28,560
Absolutely, absolutely. 
Because Ant, you have to 

374
00:21:28,560 --> 00:21:32,400
understand, as bad as what you 
described is, it's not as bad as

375
00:21:32,400 --> 00:21:35,240
a world in which prosecutors 
could be sued for their rights 

376
00:21:35,240 --> 00:21:37,400
violating behavior. 
That's the view of the Supreme 

377
00:21:37,400 --> 00:21:41,120
Court, because if, if, if, if 
prosecutors could be sued 

378
00:21:41,120 --> 00:21:43,960
anytime they violated people's 
rights, nobody would want to be 

379
00:21:43,960 --> 00:21:45,720
a prosecutor. 
That's .1. 

380
00:21:45,720 --> 00:21:47,400
That's actually the Supreme 
Court's rationale. 

381
00:21:47,400 --> 00:21:51,240
And then second, there are all 
these other mechanisms for 

382
00:21:51,240 --> 00:21:54,560
accountability, including 
reporting the prosecutor to the 

383
00:21:54,560 --> 00:21:57,640
State Bar, criminal prosecution 
discipline with inside their 

384
00:21:57,640 --> 00:21:59,400
office. 
And the fact that none of those 

385
00:21:59,400 --> 00:22:01,720
things ever happen is not what's
important. 

386
00:22:01,880 --> 00:22:03,920
The fact that is that they 
exist. 

387
00:22:03,920 --> 00:22:06,240
That's all that matters 
according to the Supreme Court. 

388
00:22:07,040 --> 00:22:10,400
And and this is this is an 
absolutely preposterous 

389
00:22:10,400 --> 00:22:14,160
judicially confected doctrine. 
Again, I hate to be a broken 

390
00:22:14,160 --> 00:22:16,560
record, but perhaps it's no 
surprise that a wildly 

391
00:22:16,560 --> 00:22:19,440
disproportionate number of 
federal judges were prosecutors 

392
00:22:19,440 --> 00:22:23,920
before they become judges. 
And so we see a willingness on 

393
00:22:23,920 --> 00:22:28,920
the the judiciary to simply 
invent A categorical defense for

394
00:22:28,960 --> 00:22:33,080
for their, you know, former 
fellow former colleagues so that

395
00:22:33,080 --> 00:22:36,000
they are not exposed to civil 
rights liability for their 

396
00:22:36,000 --> 00:22:39,320
rights violating conduct. 
Now, there is one sliver. 

397
00:22:39,400 --> 00:22:43,040
There is one sliver of of light 
here where you might be able to 

398
00:22:43,040 --> 00:22:47,080
sue a prosecutor, and that's if 
you can prove that when they 

399
00:22:47,080 --> 00:22:50,320
violated your rights, they 
weren't actually acting as a 

400
00:22:50,320 --> 00:22:52,920
prosecutor. 
So, for example, let's say that 

401
00:22:53,120 --> 00:22:56,200
you're being interviewed by a 
couple of detectives and a 

402
00:22:56,200 --> 00:22:58,880
prosecutor walks into the room 
and just starts beating the hell

403
00:22:58,880 --> 00:23:00,920
out of you with a rubber 
trenching to try to get you to 

404
00:23:00,920 --> 00:23:03,360
confess. 
You would be able to make an 

405
00:23:03,360 --> 00:23:06,840
argument that in that instance 
they were not acting as a 

406
00:23:06,840 --> 00:23:09,120
prosecutor, they were acting as 
an investigator. 

407
00:23:09,440 --> 00:23:12,640
And that was not a fundamentally
prosecutorial act. 

408
00:23:12,640 --> 00:23:15,600
When they when they beat the tar
out of you with a truncheon and 

409
00:23:15,600 --> 00:23:19,120
you might maybe, I mean, they 
would absolutely come back with 

410
00:23:19,120 --> 00:23:21,200
prosecutorial immunity as a 
defense. 

411
00:23:21,200 --> 00:23:23,480
And I would say some judges 
would grant it, but there's at 

412
00:23:23,480 --> 00:23:26,560
least a sliver of a chance that 
you would prevail because they 

413
00:23:26,560 --> 00:23:29,560
were not acting as a prosecutor.
They were acting as a more as an

414
00:23:29,560 --> 00:23:34,040
investigator slash detective and
trying to elicit a a confession 

415
00:23:34,040 --> 00:23:35,400
from you by beating the hell out
of you. 

416
00:23:36,560 --> 00:23:38,400
You're being a bit of a downer 
here, Clerk. 

417
00:23:39,560 --> 00:23:40,880
Hey, listen, man, I got my 
brand. 

418
00:23:41,200 --> 00:23:42,320
I got my brain. 
You want to talk about 

419
00:23:42,320 --> 00:23:44,200
something, talk about something 
fun. 

420
00:23:44,960 --> 00:23:50,240
Well, like, you know, is there 
any good news at, at the AT or 

421
00:23:50,240 --> 00:23:52,200
near the Supreme Court at this 
point? 

422
00:23:53,000 --> 00:23:56,760
Yeah, I mean, I think we could 
talk about the the court's 

423
00:23:56,760 --> 00:24:00,040
ruling in the in the, in the 
tariff case, that was probably, 

424
00:24:00,040 --> 00:24:02,520
you know, Donald Trump's 
biggest, shiniest toy. 

425
00:24:02,520 --> 00:24:05,080
And they'd snatched it right 
away from him and stomped it 

426
00:24:05,080 --> 00:24:07,480
into pieces. 
And they're going to do the same

427
00:24:07,480 --> 00:24:12,480
thing with with the follow up 
efforts to invoke the other 

428
00:24:13,600 --> 00:24:16,760
federal statutes to try to 
resurrect that tariff regime. 

429
00:24:16,760 --> 00:24:18,000
I think that's a pretty big 
deal. 

430
00:24:18,640 --> 00:24:20,080
I do. 
I do too. 

431
00:24:21,400 --> 00:24:24,240
Maybe it would be more fun to 
talk about the birthright 

432
00:24:24,240 --> 00:24:26,360
citizenship case. 
Sure. 

433
00:24:26,920 --> 00:24:31,640
Where do you think that's going?
I think that is going to be 7 

434
00:24:31,640 --> 00:24:37,000
two, striking down or, or 
declaring that the the executive

435
00:24:37,000 --> 00:24:42,520
order that purports to 
essentially invalidate or or 

436
00:24:42,840 --> 00:24:44,920
marginalized the 14th 
Amendment's birthright 

437
00:24:44,920 --> 00:24:50,960
citizenship provision is is 
doesn't have the force of law. 

438
00:24:52,160 --> 00:24:55,880
I mean, first of all, you can't 
trump, I hate to use that word 

439
00:24:55,880 --> 00:24:58,600
in this context, but it's, it's 
the most apt 1. 

440
00:24:58,640 --> 00:25:02,720
You can't, an executive order 
does not trump the Constitution 

441
00:25:03,320 --> 00:25:06,600
and it's, doesn't it, it, it 
can't contravene federal 

442
00:25:06,600 --> 00:25:08,720
statutory law either. 
And there's actually a statute 

443
00:25:08,720 --> 00:25:11,040
on point here too. 
So it, it's, you know, it's a, 

444
00:25:11,160 --> 00:25:13,880
it's, it's a, it's the weakest 
of those three. 

445
00:25:13,880 --> 00:25:16,640
It's, it's weaker than a 
constitutional amendment and 

446
00:25:16,640 --> 00:25:17,960
it's weaker than a federal 
statute. 

447
00:25:17,960 --> 00:25:21,920
And but, you know, I, I did the,
I, I was surprised at the 

448
00:25:23,320 --> 00:25:26,560
receptivity or the apparent 
receptivity of at least a couple

449
00:25:26,560 --> 00:25:28,240
of the justices to this 
argument. 

450
00:25:29,400 --> 00:25:30,880
And for those who don't know 
that the reason there's an 

451
00:25:30,880 --> 00:25:33,200
argument here is that the 14th, 
the language of the 14th 

452
00:25:33,200 --> 00:25:37,640
Amendment says that all persons 
born in the United States and 

453
00:25:37,640 --> 00:25:40,560
subject to the jurisdiction 
thereof are citizens of the 

454
00:25:40,560 --> 00:25:43,040
United States. 
And so there's been this sort of

455
00:25:43,160 --> 00:25:51,320
nouveau scholarship that that 
purports to demonstrate that 

456
00:25:51,320 --> 00:25:53,760
that at the time of the 
ratification of the 14th 

457
00:25:53,760 --> 00:25:56,920
Amendment, subject to the 
jurisdiction thereof would have 

458
00:25:56,920 --> 00:26:00,400
been understood not simply to 
mean, are you subject to the 

459
00:26:00,400 --> 00:26:03,720
legal jurisdiction of of the 
United States, which of course 

460
00:26:03,720 --> 00:26:05,960
we know you are, because if 
you're an illegal immigrant and 

461
00:26:05,960 --> 00:26:08,240
you commit a federal crime, they
are definitely going to 

462
00:26:08,240 --> 00:26:11,880
prosecute you for it. 
And so in that sense, you are 

463
00:26:11,880 --> 00:26:15,560
subject to the jurisdiction of 
of the United States. 

464
00:26:16,920 --> 00:26:22,120
But the question is, does it 
mean more like that, that either

465
00:26:22,120 --> 00:26:26,160
you or your parents had some 
allegiance to another country at

466
00:26:26,160 --> 00:26:28,280
the time you were born? 
And the reason there's there's a

467
00:26:28,280 --> 00:26:31,040
little bit of wiggle room here, 
of course, is because that that 

468
00:26:31,040 --> 00:26:32,640
language must be doing something
right. 

469
00:26:33,000 --> 00:26:36,680
And what, what I'd say the most 
credible arguments are is that 

470
00:26:37,200 --> 00:26:40,360
what that language is doing is 
making clear that the children 

471
00:26:40,360 --> 00:26:43,960
of a foreign diplomats are not 
U.S. citizens simply because 

472
00:26:43,960 --> 00:26:49,120
they were born while the one or 
more parents was serving as as 

473
00:26:49,120 --> 00:26:51,560
a, a diplomat, you know, in an 
embassy, for example. 

474
00:26:51,680 --> 00:26:56,080
Or if there's an invading army 
and, and you know, let's say one

475
00:26:56,080 --> 00:26:59,120
of the female soldiers has a 
baby on US soil while they are 

476
00:26:59,120 --> 00:27:01,760
in the act of invading the 
United States, that child is not

477
00:27:01,760 --> 00:27:04,840
a United States citizen. 
But the argument is that it's 

478
00:27:04,840 --> 00:27:06,760
much more expansive than that. 
Essentially, if you're here 

479
00:27:06,760 --> 00:27:10,840
unlawfully with no intent to 
remain, then you are not subject

480
00:27:10,840 --> 00:27:12,880
to the jurisdiction of the 
United States in the sense of 

481
00:27:12,880 --> 00:27:17,120
the 14th Amendment means and and
you're not a birthright citizen.

482
00:27:17,600 --> 00:27:20,160
Again, I don't think that 
argument got any real traction 

483
00:27:20,160 --> 00:27:23,160
among more than let's say two or
three justices. 

484
00:27:23,160 --> 00:27:25,640
But this somewhat 
disappointingly, I think it's a 

485
00:27:25,640 --> 00:27:28,520
decent chance we'll see that a 
non unanimous ruling in this 

486
00:27:28,520 --> 00:27:29,600
case, which I think it's too 
bad. 

487
00:27:30,800 --> 00:27:33,640
Can you can you speak to and? 
I honestly don't know. 

488
00:27:33,840 --> 00:27:36,240
I don't even have a hint of the 
answer to this question. 

489
00:27:36,240 --> 00:27:43,160
But can you speak of to to 
whether that language also was 

490
00:27:43,160 --> 00:27:46,600
crafted in a way to cover Native
Americans? 

491
00:27:48,040 --> 00:27:50,920
It seems to be, although it's 
funny when, when I believe Chief

492
00:27:50,920 --> 00:27:54,480
Justice Roberts asked the 
solicitor General John Sauer, or

493
00:27:54,480 --> 00:27:56,120
maybe it was Gorsuch. 
I think it was, it would have 

494
00:27:56,120 --> 00:27:58,080
been Gorsuch because he's very 
interested in in Native 

495
00:27:58,080 --> 00:27:59,320
Americans. 
And he asked, well, what you 

496
00:27:59,320 --> 00:28:03,200
know, what significance does 
your theory have for for 

497
00:28:03,200 --> 00:28:04,800
American Indians? 
And so I hadn't really thought 

498
00:28:04,800 --> 00:28:07,720
about that, which is difficult 
to believe. 

499
00:28:08,640 --> 00:28:10,920
Yeah, impossible to believe, one
might say. 

500
00:28:11,480 --> 00:28:13,160
Right. 
So, you know, but clearly there 

501
00:28:13,160 --> 00:28:19,320
was some consideration of the 
fact that at least some Native 

502
00:28:19,320 --> 00:28:23,720
Americans are, are born under 
circumstances where they are 

503
00:28:23,760 --> 00:28:29,880
subject to the jurisdiction of 
the, the, the tribal polity of 

504
00:28:29,880 --> 00:28:31,440
the reservation on which they 
were born. 

505
00:28:32,120 --> 00:28:34,720
And then there are others who 
are born and are subject to the 

506
00:28:34,720 --> 00:28:35,840
jurisdiction of the United 
States. 

507
00:28:35,840 --> 00:28:37,760
And we have to be able to 
distinguish between those two. 

508
00:28:38,640 --> 00:28:43,960
That that seems to me so 
reasonable as to defy 

509
00:28:43,960 --> 00:28:47,640
opposition, and yet I know that 
we're going to get pushed back 

510
00:28:47,640 --> 00:28:49,080
on this. 
Yeah. 

511
00:28:49,120 --> 00:28:51,080
I mean, I look, I mean, I think 
this has become a kind of a 

512
00:28:51,080 --> 00:28:54,000
cultural football. 
And what we've seen is that 

513
00:28:54,000 --> 00:28:57,240
there are plenty of people, 
unfortunately, who can talk 

514
00:28:57,240 --> 00:29:01,840
themselves into just about 
anything as long as it's the 

515
00:29:01,840 --> 00:29:06,200
preferred view at that given 
point in time of Donald Trump. 

516
00:29:06,960 --> 00:29:09,640
I mean, it's, it's kind of 
crazy, Clark and I, I wonder if 

517
00:29:09,840 --> 00:29:12,360
if you got this sort of 
education when you went to law 

518
00:29:12,360 --> 00:29:14,840
school. 
I got it in Graduate School 

519
00:29:15,280 --> 00:29:19,080
where I studied under Ralph 
Rossum of a very well known 

520
00:29:19,080 --> 00:29:22,200
constitutional scholar. 
And he said, and in his 

521
00:29:22,200 --> 00:29:26,440
textbook, it said when the 
constitutional text is clear, 

522
00:29:26,720 --> 00:29:30,600
there's your answer. 
When the text is somewhat 

523
00:29:30,600 --> 00:29:34,200
ambiguous, OK, some 
interpretation might be 

524
00:29:34,200 --> 00:29:37,000
necessary. 
And you go to secondary sources 

525
00:29:37,000 --> 00:29:40,800
and they you can go to the 
debates around the, the 

526
00:29:40,800 --> 00:29:44,680
amendment or the Constitution 
itself and arrive at a sensible 

527
00:29:44,680 --> 00:29:48,000
answer. 
And it's only when these things 

528
00:29:48,000 --> 00:29:51,520
don't apply that political 
answers can even creep in. 

529
00:29:53,080 --> 00:29:55,280
And I don't know that Ralph 
would still say this. 

530
00:29:55,280 --> 00:29:58,760
I hope to God he still would, 
but I'll still say it. 

531
00:30:00,080 --> 00:30:04,400
Yeah, I, I So that's one of 
those statements that's seems 

532
00:30:05,720 --> 00:30:08,040
eminently sensible on its face, 
and perhaps it is. 

533
00:30:08,040 --> 00:30:11,240
But the question of, of what 
exactly is clear in the 

534
00:30:11,240 --> 00:30:14,080
Constitution might be more 
challenging than we suppose. 

535
00:30:14,080 --> 00:30:17,240
I mean, I'll take it what I 
think is an easy example. 

536
00:30:17,240 --> 00:30:20,520
I believe that even if there 
comes a day when we begin 

537
00:30:20,520 --> 00:30:25,040
colonizing other planets, the 
the requirement that the US 

538
00:30:25,040 --> 00:30:29,040
president be 35 years of age 
will not give us very much 

539
00:30:29,040 --> 00:30:30,920
trouble. 
Even if somebody who was born on

540
00:30:30,920 --> 00:30:36,320
Venus and is 35 Venusian years 
old, which I as I understand it 

541
00:30:36,320 --> 00:30:41,440
would be about 21 1/2 Earth 
years, that's not going to 

542
00:30:41,440 --> 00:30:45,640
present insurmountable 
interpretive challenges. 

543
00:30:46,760 --> 00:30:49,800
On the other hand, think about a
provision like the 8th 

544
00:30:49,800 --> 00:30:54,240
Amendment's cruel and unusual 
restriction or limitation on 

545
00:30:54,520 --> 00:30:58,200
prohibition against cruel and 
unusual punishments on the 

546
00:30:58,200 --> 00:30:59,680
space. 
That might seem pretty clear. 

547
00:30:59,680 --> 00:31:02,560
On the other hand, it's, you 
know, there's one question is 

548
00:31:02,560 --> 00:31:07,680
the word and is it I think. 
I think the word and there does 

549
00:31:07,680 --> 00:31:12,640
some heavy lifting. 
It has to be cruel and unusual, 

550
00:31:12,800 --> 00:31:15,040
not cruel or unusual. 
Yeah. 

551
00:31:15,200 --> 00:31:19,880
And but unusual has at least a 
potential flavor of temper, of a

552
00:31:20,200 --> 00:31:24,680
temporal flavor to it, right, In
the sense that does it, what 

553
00:31:24,680 --> 00:31:26,480
point in time do we ask if it's 
unusual? 

554
00:31:26,480 --> 00:31:28,240
Right, Because back at the 
founding they were doing, 

555
00:31:28,240 --> 00:31:31,720
they're still doing things like 
mutilation, branding, cutting 

556
00:31:31,720 --> 00:31:33,280
off, you know, parts of your 
face. 

557
00:31:33,280 --> 00:31:35,000
The nose. 
Yep, Yep. 

558
00:31:35,240 --> 00:31:39,760
And look, I, you know, I 
hesitate to use the changing 

559
00:31:39,760 --> 00:31:43,920
mores of the, of the American 
people argument because you know

560
00:31:43,920 --> 00:31:48,200
where that nonsense leads. 
But certain mores have in fact 

561
00:31:48,200 --> 00:31:50,920
changed. 
And I I think it would be very 

562
00:31:50,920 --> 00:31:56,840
difficult to make a cruel and 
unusual case in the time of the 

563
00:31:56,840 --> 00:31:59,520
founding that would be the exact
same as it is now. 

564
00:32:00,000 --> 00:32:02,600
I think that's right, although 
there's some justices I think 

565
00:32:02,600 --> 00:32:05,160
would push back hard on that, 
believe the, you know, former 

566
00:32:05,160 --> 00:32:08,040
Justice Antonin Scalia took the 
position that the meaning of 

567
00:32:08,040 --> 00:32:09,520
those terms was fixed at the 
time. 

568
00:32:10,240 --> 00:32:14,320
I, I believe that's correct. 
I, I think I would have a hell 

569
00:32:14,320 --> 00:32:16,440
of an argument with Scalia, and 
I think it would be 

570
00:32:16,440 --> 00:32:19,280
extraordinarily difficult 
because he was not a stupid 

571
00:32:19,280 --> 00:32:20,960
person. 
But I'll. 

572
00:32:21,360 --> 00:32:23,680
I'll say this, I'm not sure 
anything that they did back then

573
00:32:23,680 --> 00:32:26,360
was as cruel as executing 
somebody by electric chair. 

574
00:32:26,360 --> 00:32:28,600
I've never seen it myself and I 
never care to see it, but the 

575
00:32:28,600 --> 00:32:30,320
descriptions I read are truly 
horrific. 

576
00:32:31,440 --> 00:32:37,000
But you're, you're talking here 
about words that that may not 

577
00:32:37,280 --> 00:32:39,840
preserve their meaning over 
time. 

578
00:32:40,320 --> 00:32:45,440
And I I get that. 
But this, the phrase that we, 

579
00:32:45,520 --> 00:32:49,520
you led with subject to the 
jurisdiction thereof in 

580
00:32:49,520 --> 00:32:52,160
determining who is and isn't a 
citizen. 

581
00:32:53,160 --> 00:32:56,640
Am I missing something or could 
the founders have just written 

582
00:32:56,640 --> 00:32:59,280
in much more plain English? 
In other words, were there other

583
00:32:59,280 --> 00:33:02,840
words available to them that 
would have communicated what was

584
00:33:02,840 --> 00:33:07,560
in their heads better than this?
Well, we're we're in 1868 by the

585
00:33:07,560 --> 00:33:10,160
time we get to the amendment. 
So let's not pick on the 

586
00:33:10,160 --> 00:33:11,720
founders. 
Sure, sure. 

587
00:33:11,720 --> 00:33:14,880
Sorry, Yeah. 
Well, look, that's not even the 

588
00:33:14,880 --> 00:33:17,000
least clear terminology in the 
14th Amendment. 

589
00:33:17,000 --> 00:33:19,480
You'll, you'll hopefully 
remember that one of the things 

590
00:33:19,480 --> 00:33:22,440
I used to litigate at the 
Institute for Justice was the 

591
00:33:22,480 --> 00:33:24,840
another provision that says that
no state shall make or enforce 

592
00:33:24,840 --> 00:33:27,960
any law that shall infringe the 
privileges or immunities of 

593
00:33:27,960 --> 00:33:31,240
citizens of the United States. 
And the first time the Supreme 

594
00:33:31,240 --> 00:33:35,760
Court looked at that in an 1873 
case called the Slaughterhouse 

595
00:33:35,760 --> 00:33:40,000
case, is they completely botched
it and and interpreted the 

596
00:33:40,000 --> 00:33:43,080
privileges or immunities clause 
in a way that literally no one 

597
00:33:43,080 --> 00:33:45,720
thinks is remotely credible 
today. 

598
00:33:45,720 --> 00:33:47,920
And I would I would characterize
that as one of those decisions 

599
00:33:47,920 --> 00:33:50,480
that was wrong the day it was 
decided. 

600
00:33:50,480 --> 00:33:53,680
So I think James is right here. 
I mean, I two things are true. 

601
00:33:53,680 --> 00:33:56,160
On the one hand, let's not throw
rocks backwards in time. 

602
00:33:56,160 --> 00:33:58,000
On the other hand, yeah, there 
are certainly provisions of the 

603
00:33:58,000 --> 00:34:00,600
14th Amendment that that that 
could have been expressed with 

604
00:34:00,600 --> 00:34:05,840
greater clarity. 
But yeah, I think the 15th as 

605
00:34:05,840 --> 00:34:07,640
well. 
But you know, that's another 

606
00:34:07,640 --> 00:34:11,239
argument for another day. 
The the 14th Amendment has 

607
00:34:11,760 --> 00:34:17,159
caused more constitutional 
mischief than I think any other 

608
00:34:17,159 --> 00:34:20,280
single thing. 
I mean, we only get in court, we

609
00:34:20,280 --> 00:34:23,480
only get in the doctrine of 
incorporation through the 14th. 

610
00:34:24,159 --> 00:34:25,560
So here's the thing. 
I've heard you talk about 

611
00:34:25,560 --> 00:34:27,719
incorporation before. 
So I think I, I, I'm going to, 

612
00:34:27,719 --> 00:34:31,080
I'm going to make AI don't care 
for that terminology and I don't

613
00:34:31,120 --> 00:34:35,320
care for the, the, the, the 
sense of, of the constitution 

614
00:34:35,320 --> 00:34:36,800
that it conveys for those who 
don't. 

615
00:34:36,800 --> 00:34:39,520
Know before before you go here I
I want to hear what you have to 

616
00:34:39,520 --> 00:34:42,080
say. 
But can you define what the 

617
00:34:42,080 --> 00:34:44,800
incorporation means? 
I was just about to do that. 

618
00:34:45,159 --> 00:34:48,639
Thank you. 
So it's, it's a term that that 

619
00:34:48,639 --> 00:34:52,040
describes a, a way of looking at
the 14th Amendment and 

620
00:34:52,040 --> 00:34:55,800
specifically either the due 
process clause or the privileges

621
00:34:55,800 --> 00:34:58,560
or immunities clause, or some 
number of clauses acting 

622
00:34:58,560 --> 00:35:04,800
together as making applicable 
against state governments the 

623
00:35:05,160 --> 00:35:08,200
substantive and procedural 
provisions of the Bill of 

624
00:35:08,200 --> 00:35:12,000
Rights. 
And to to make that into to say 

625
00:35:12,000 --> 00:35:16,120
that in just very simple terms, 
does the Supreme Court up until 

626
00:35:16,120 --> 00:35:20,920
1868 had always interpreted the 
the Bill of Rights, the 1st 

627
00:35:20,920 --> 00:35:23,960
Amendment free expression, 4th 
Amendment protection against 

628
00:35:23,960 --> 00:35:27,240
unreasonable searches and 
seizures, etcetera, as applying 

629
00:35:27,240 --> 00:35:31,120
only to the federal government. 
And that's probably a correct 

630
00:35:31,120 --> 00:35:33,280
interpretation for a variety of 
reasons we don't need to get 

631
00:35:33,280 --> 00:35:36,480
into. 
But what became apparent was 

632
00:35:36,480 --> 00:35:39,600
that their their hope and their 
belief that state governments 

633
00:35:39,600 --> 00:35:43,520
would would prove much less 
tyrannical than the federal 

634
00:35:43,520 --> 00:35:46,640
government was woefully 
mistaken. 

635
00:35:46,640 --> 00:35:50,360
And we know that in part by just
look at some of the efforts that

636
00:35:50,360 --> 00:35:53,440
state governments took to try to
suppress abolitionist sediment 

637
00:35:53,440 --> 00:35:56,920
before the Civil War, including 
outlawing, and I believe at 

638
00:35:56,920 --> 00:35:59,800
least one case, making a capital
offense to send abolitionist 

639
00:35:59,800 --> 00:36:04,200
literature through the mail. 
So the goal of 14th Amendment 

640
00:36:04,440 --> 00:36:09,840
was to fundamentally rejigger 
the allocation of, of, of power 

641
00:36:09,840 --> 00:36:11,840
between the state and federal 
government, at least in one 

642
00:36:11,840 --> 00:36:16,240
important regard, which is to 
prevent states from tyrannizing 

643
00:36:16,520 --> 00:36:18,320
individuals. 
And it wasn't just newly freed 

644
00:36:18,320 --> 00:36:20,040
blacks. 
They could have said just just 

645
00:36:20,040 --> 00:36:20,920
Friedman. 
And they didn't. 

646
00:36:21,440 --> 00:36:23,880
That's right. 
And the problem, of course, is 

647
00:36:23,880 --> 00:36:26,360
that that states, like all 
governments are kind of 

648
00:36:26,360 --> 00:36:30,720
endlessly creative in figuring 
out ways to oppress and 

649
00:36:30,720 --> 00:36:33,320
tyrannize. 
And so just to take a few 

650
00:36:33,320 --> 00:36:36,320
examples, in Southern states 
that were trying to hold newly 

651
00:36:36,320 --> 00:36:39,240
freed blacks in a state of 
constructive servitude, there 

652
00:36:39,240 --> 00:36:43,560
were laws against vagrancy and 
loitering that that were so 

653
00:36:43,560 --> 00:36:46,320
elastic that they would apply to
kind of anybody who's just out 

654
00:36:46,320 --> 00:36:48,360
in public. 
And then you could you could 

655
00:36:48,360 --> 00:36:51,920
prosecute that person and 
convict them and put them on a 

656
00:36:51,920 --> 00:36:54,640
chain gang that was going to 
look exactly like plantation 

657
00:36:54,640 --> 00:36:58,040
work. 
There were laws that prohibited 

658
00:36:58,400 --> 00:37:01,000
black people from being off of 
their employer's property 

659
00:37:01,000 --> 00:37:02,480
without a note from the 
employer. 

660
00:37:02,760 --> 00:37:04,880
It was a deliberate effort to 
prevent them from going in 

661
00:37:04,880 --> 00:37:06,600
search of better economic 
opportunities. 

662
00:37:06,600 --> 00:37:09,240
And I could go on and on. 
But the and then of course, 

663
00:37:09,240 --> 00:37:12,000
there were more blatant laws, 
like just just disarming anybody

664
00:37:12,000 --> 00:37:14,760
who's black, that kind of thing.
So the challenge that the 

665
00:37:14,760 --> 00:37:18,520
framers of the 14th Amendment 
were faced with is this 

666
00:37:18,600 --> 00:37:23,840
endlessly creative ability of of
Southern states in particular to

667
00:37:23,840 --> 00:37:29,120
restrict newly freed blacks and 
their white supporters in ways 

668
00:37:29,120 --> 00:37:32,840
that defied any sort of bullet 
point list so that you can't do 

669
00:37:32,840 --> 00:37:34,800
this and then you can't do that 
and you can't do this other 

670
00:37:34,800 --> 00:37:37,360
thing. 
And so they they necessarily had

671
00:37:37,360 --> 00:37:40,000
to speak and rather broad and 
sweeping terms. 

672
00:37:40,520 --> 00:37:42,880
And I personally believe that's 
exactly what they did and that 

673
00:37:42,880 --> 00:37:44,040
they did a pretty good job of 
it. 

674
00:37:44,040 --> 00:37:47,640
And what they basically said was
that states must not enforce 

675
00:37:47,640 --> 00:37:52,000
laws that either make untenable 
distinctions between people 

676
00:37:52,000 --> 00:37:55,840
that's the equal protection 
clause, or that restrict their 

677
00:37:55,840 --> 00:38:00,040
freedom in ways that are 
inconsistent with being a 

678
00:38:00,040 --> 00:38:02,000
citizen of a fundamentally free 
country. 

679
00:38:02,000 --> 00:38:04,040
And that's what I think the 
privileges or immediate clause 

680
00:38:04,040 --> 00:38:06,960
should have been understood to, 
to protect. 

681
00:38:07,240 --> 00:38:09,480
But as I said, the Supreme Court
essentially wrote that provision

682
00:38:09,480 --> 00:38:12,920
out of the 14th Amendment, five 
years after the amendment was 

683
00:38:12,920 --> 00:38:15,360
ratified, and to their 
everlasting shame. 

684
00:38:16,800 --> 00:38:21,280
I like your interpretation, and 
clearly I like the world in 

685
00:38:21,280 --> 00:38:24,840
which let's just pick one off 
off the tree. 

686
00:38:25,120 --> 00:38:30,640
My free speech is guaranteed 
even as a resident of Arizona as

687
00:38:30,640 --> 00:38:32,800
opposed to a resident of the 
United States. 

688
00:38:32,800 --> 00:38:36,880
Right? 
But the framers of the 14th 

689
00:38:36,880 --> 00:38:39,200
Amendment could have said, but 
did not. 

690
00:38:39,520 --> 00:38:43,080
We do hereby apply the Bill of 
Rights to the States. 

691
00:38:44,720 --> 00:38:46,040
Yep. 
And, and we don't have to guess 

692
00:38:46,040 --> 00:38:48,160
about this, James. 
We know that they intended to do

693
00:38:48,160 --> 00:38:51,440
at least that much. 
There was extensive testimony 

694
00:38:51,440 --> 00:38:54,040
that the Congress received about
how newly freed blacks were 

695
00:38:54,040 --> 00:38:56,280
being stripped of their weapons 
when they came home from 

696
00:38:56,280 --> 00:38:59,800
military service precisely to 
make them easier to tyrannize 

697
00:38:59,800 --> 00:39:01,840
and oppress. 
So to me, there's not the 

698
00:39:01,840 --> 00:39:05,920
slightest doubt of, of a, you 
know, not only a congressional 

699
00:39:05,920 --> 00:39:08,960
intent, but of an original 
public understanding that the 

700
00:39:08,960 --> 00:39:13,360
14th Amendment would prevent 
states from just take that, for 

701
00:39:13,360 --> 00:39:16,240
example, from enforcing what, 
what the substance of the Second

702
00:39:16,240 --> 00:39:19,800
Amendment against state 
infringement. 

703
00:39:19,840 --> 00:39:24,480
And other ways that we know that
is that there were explicit 

704
00:39:25,200 --> 00:39:27,480
statements on the, on the 
congressional record that they 

705
00:39:27,480 --> 00:39:30,640
meant to basically 
constitutionalized both the 

706
00:39:30,640 --> 00:39:34,200
Friedman Bureau Act and the 
Civil Rights Act of 1868, both 

707
00:39:34,200 --> 00:39:37,520
of which protected various 
freedoms found in the Bill of 

708
00:39:37,520 --> 00:39:39,400
Rights. 
So I, I understand your 

709
00:39:39,400 --> 00:39:42,040
skepticism. 
I'm here to tell you that there,

710
00:39:42,080 --> 00:39:45,360
there wouldn't have been any 
point in, in ratifying the 14th 

711
00:39:45,360 --> 00:39:48,280
Amendment and the debates would 
have looked a lot different 

712
00:39:48,280 --> 00:39:52,160
about whether to ratify the 14th
Amendment if it was a relatively

713
00:39:52,160 --> 00:39:57,240
minor change in, in the, the 
constitutional status of 

714
00:39:57,240 --> 00:39:59,320
individuals vis a vis their 
state governments. 

715
00:39:59,320 --> 00:40:04,560
It was designed to be a, to work
a sea change of, of, of the, of 

716
00:40:04,560 --> 00:40:07,800
the status of individuals versus
state governments. 

717
00:40:07,840 --> 00:40:10,000
And it did. 
It happens to be that the 

718
00:40:10,000 --> 00:40:12,960
Supreme Court missed that 
basically because we, we'd 

719
00:40:12,960 --> 00:40:16,680
gotten, I think as a country, we
just sort of lost our zeal for 

720
00:40:16,680 --> 00:40:19,480
reconstruction by 1870. 
But it's 3:00 or so. 

721
00:40:19,960 --> 00:40:22,480
But anyway. 
It's it's the second, that's the

722
00:40:22,480 --> 00:40:24,720
second time you referred to the 
Supreme Court missing it. 

723
00:40:25,160 --> 00:40:26,400
What? 
What do you mean by that? 

724
00:40:27,360 --> 00:40:34,000
Oh well, so the the as cases 
were litigated invoking the the 

725
00:40:34,000 --> 00:40:37,560
newly ratified 14th Amendment 
that was ratified in 1868. 

726
00:40:37,560 --> 00:40:41,400
As James said, first case to 
reach the Supreme Court seeking 

727
00:40:41,400 --> 00:40:44,480
to apply the 14th Amendment 
against the state law was the 

728
00:40:44,480 --> 00:40:47,640
slaughterhouse cases out of 
Louisiana, where Louisiana 

729
00:40:47,640 --> 00:40:50,600
basically set up what amounts to
a monopoly on the butcher trade 

730
00:40:50,600 --> 00:40:55,880
to where if you wanted to 
butcher cattle within some 

731
00:40:56,440 --> 00:40:59,400
radius of New Orleans, you had 
to go through this one state 

732
00:40:59,920 --> 00:41:02,960
chartered monopoly company and 
pay them for the privilege of 

733
00:41:02,960 --> 00:41:04,720
doing it. 
And, and let's be clear, that 

734
00:41:04,720 --> 00:41:07,360
was a legitimate health and 
safety law because there really 

735
00:41:07,360 --> 00:41:10,760
was a lot of a problem with 
people throwing, you know, awful

736
00:41:10,760 --> 00:41:14,400
and, and guts and, and, and, and
body parts into the Mississippi 

737
00:41:14,400 --> 00:41:16,000
River. 
But of course, you know, being 

738
00:41:16,000 --> 00:41:18,200
Louisiana, they went about 
addressing that problem in the 

739
00:41:18,200 --> 00:41:22,560
most corrupt possible way. 
But but in effect, the butchers 

740
00:41:22,560 --> 00:41:26,200
asserted a a right to earn a 
living free from unreasonable 

741
00:41:26,200 --> 00:41:28,000
government interference. 
I think there's not the 

742
00:41:28,000 --> 00:41:30,600
slightest doubt that that is 
included among the privileges or

743
00:41:30,600 --> 00:41:32,360
immunities of citizens of the 
United States. 

744
00:41:32,360 --> 00:41:35,080
If you think about the 
institution of slavery, it is 

745
00:41:35,280 --> 00:41:39,240
precisely the the the whole 
point of slavery is to alienate 

746
00:41:39,240 --> 00:41:42,680
people's productive labor to 
yourself and away from them. 

747
00:41:42,680 --> 00:41:44,640
That what it what else is that 
besides the unreasonable 

748
00:41:44,640 --> 00:41:47,800
restriction of somebody's 
ability to to put food on their 

749
00:41:47,800 --> 00:41:50,480
own table? 
So I think no question 

750
00:41:50,480 --> 00:41:53,160
whatsoever that the 14th 
Amendment was designed to 

751
00:41:53,160 --> 00:41:56,320
protect at least that. 
And the Supreme Court looked at 

752
00:41:56,320 --> 00:42:00,280
that and said, no, this is this 
this the privilege of immunity 

753
00:42:00,280 --> 00:42:02,920
clause is really just about 
protecting individuals against 

754
00:42:03,720 --> 00:42:07,840
federal efforts to or or against
state efforts to to deny people 

755
00:42:07,920 --> 00:42:11,880
access to to federal rights that
exist only by virtue of the 

756
00:42:11,880 --> 00:42:13,200
existence of the federal 
government. 

757
00:42:13,440 --> 00:42:15,600
Like your ability to claim the 
protection of the federal 

758
00:42:15,600 --> 00:42:19,080
government went on the high seas
or access federal sub treasury, 

759
00:42:19,080 --> 00:42:21,960
something I just happened to do 
make a real hobby of right. 

760
00:42:22,960 --> 00:42:25,200
This was a fundamentally 
preposterous interpretation of 

761
00:42:25,200 --> 00:42:28,800
the 14th amendment was designed 
to render it a dead letter. 

762
00:42:29,440 --> 00:42:32,080
If you ever want to see a 
majority opinion just completely

763
00:42:32,080 --> 00:42:35,920
destroyed by the descent, 
they're actually 2 descents in 

764
00:42:35,920 --> 00:42:38,600
this case, Just pick up the 
slaughterhouse cases. 

765
00:42:38,600 --> 00:42:41,520
Read the majority opinion, read 
the dissenting opinions. 

766
00:42:41,520 --> 00:42:44,600
And it's not even close. 
I mean, the majority opinion is 

767
00:42:44,600 --> 00:42:47,400
truly an embarrassment. 
It's it's just a, a complete 

768
00:42:47,400 --> 00:42:48,880
intellectual shambles and a 
fraud. 

769
00:42:49,160 --> 00:42:52,520
And of course, we did not fight 
the Civil War and we did not, 

770
00:42:52,960 --> 00:42:55,280
you know, ratify the 14th 
amendment because an 

771
00:42:55,280 --> 00:42:57,680
insufficient number of people 
were able to have access to 

772
00:42:57,680 --> 00:42:59,800
federal sub treasuries or to 
claim the protection of the 

773
00:42:59,800 --> 00:43:01,240
federal government went on the 
high seas. 

774
00:43:01,240 --> 00:43:06,640
That is preposterous. 
In in fairness, that case is is 

775
00:43:06,840 --> 00:43:10,640
presented as a travesty 
everywhere it's taught right. 

776
00:43:10,640 --> 00:43:14,080
So it's this is not 
controversial what what Clark is

777
00:43:14,080 --> 00:43:17,280
saying in the least. 
That's true, but when my Co 

778
00:43:17,280 --> 00:43:20,960
counsel in the Heller gun case, 
Alan Gura brought a follow on 

779
00:43:20,960 --> 00:43:24,400
case two years later, McDonald 
versus City of Chicago and gave 

780
00:43:24,400 --> 00:43:27,240
the Supreme Court the 
opportunity to reverse the 

781
00:43:27,240 --> 00:43:32,040
Slaughterhouse cases by writing 
on a blank slate as to not only 

782
00:43:32,040 --> 00:43:36,200
whether we have a a, a, a 
constitutional right of of gun 

783
00:43:36,200 --> 00:43:38,680
ownership that we can enforce 
against state governments. 

784
00:43:39,080 --> 00:43:43,640
Answer yes clearly, but through 
which provision of the 14th 

785
00:43:43,640 --> 00:43:48,600
Amendment and none other than 
Justice Scalia mocked Alan for 

786
00:43:48,600 --> 00:43:51,440
leading with the privileges or 
immunities clause, which 

787
00:43:51,560 --> 00:43:54,640
everybody now agrees was the 
provision designed to do what I 

788
00:43:54,640 --> 00:43:58,600
just described and instead told 
Alan, oh, you know, you should 

789
00:43:58,600 --> 00:44:03,240
be arguing under substantive due
process, which even I have 

790
00:44:03,240 --> 00:44:07,840
acquiesced in that doctrine. 
Side note, when I'm not rabidly 

791
00:44:07,840 --> 00:44:10,240
mocking it every time somebody 
brings it up. 

792
00:44:10,240 --> 00:44:14,080
So I, I, I think that whole, it 
was a travesty. 

793
00:44:14,080 --> 00:44:17,120
It was a shambles. 
But people should know that the 

794
00:44:17,120 --> 00:44:20,800
Supreme Court was given a clean 
opportunity in 2010 to reverse 

795
00:44:20,800 --> 00:44:24,760
Slaughterhouse and to embrace 
the most textualist and 

796
00:44:24,760 --> 00:44:27,880
originalist reading of the 
privileges or Immunities Clause.

797
00:44:27,880 --> 00:44:31,400
And not only do they not take 
that opportunity, only one 

798
00:44:31,400 --> 00:44:33,400
justice said they should have 
Justice Thomas. 

799
00:44:33,400 --> 00:44:35,480
And he wrote a wonderful 
concurrence in which he laid out

800
00:44:35,480 --> 00:44:38,440
the argument. 
But but even the the the court's

801
00:44:38,440 --> 00:44:44,760
staunchest, staunchest opponents
of substantive due process, when

802
00:44:44,760 --> 00:44:47,480
push came to shove, they embrace
substantive due process, held 

803
00:44:47,480 --> 00:44:51,280
their nose and said, yeah, this 
is the doctrine that protects a 

804
00:44:51,280 --> 00:44:53,680
right of gun ownership against 
state infringement. 

805
00:44:54,320 --> 00:44:55,840
As you can tell, I'm pretty 
worked up about it. 

806
00:44:55,840 --> 00:44:58,160
Still. 
I think Alan was ill served and 

807
00:44:58,160 --> 00:45:01,040
I think the country was ill 
served by a Supreme Court that 

808
00:45:01,040 --> 00:45:06,240
did not have the integrity to 
undo 100 and and 30 something 

809
00:45:06,240 --> 00:45:07,680
year old decision that was 
wrong. 

810
00:45:07,680 --> 00:45:12,160
The day was decided and has 
engendered endless mischief 

811
00:45:13,120 --> 00:45:16,360
since then because we can't even
agree whether the 14th Amendment

812
00:45:16,760 --> 00:45:21,240
protects rights not expressly 
listed in the text of the 14th 

813
00:45:21,240 --> 00:45:23,080
Amendment. 
Of course it does because there 

814
00:45:23,080 --> 00:45:25,800
was no other way to prevent 
states from tyrannizing newly 

815
00:45:25,800 --> 00:45:27,280
freed blacks and their white 
supporters. 

816
00:45:27,280 --> 00:45:29,840
But we've never, the Supreme 
Court has never attempted an 

817
00:45:29,840 --> 00:45:33,680
honest interpretation of, of, of
that, of that provision of the 

818
00:45:33,680 --> 00:45:35,600
14th Amendment. 
I think it's really depressing. 

819
00:45:35,600 --> 00:45:39,040
Why do you think that is Clark? 
So I think, I think there I 

820
00:45:39,040 --> 00:45:41,040
don't want to be reduction 
overly reductive. 

821
00:45:41,040 --> 00:45:44,400
I think there are a few things 
going on here. 1 is that you 

822
00:45:44,400 --> 00:45:47,200
don't get to be a justice on the
Supreme Court by being somebody 

823
00:45:47,200 --> 00:45:49,120
who upsets apple carts or rocks 
boats. 

824
00:45:49,760 --> 00:45:53,800
It's very helpful to have at 
least some alignment with the 

825
00:45:53,800 --> 00:45:56,240
government. 
You are not going to be put in 

826
00:45:56,240 --> 00:45:59,560
the stream, you know, the sort 
of the the path towards being a 

827
00:45:59,560 --> 00:46:02,400
Supreme Court Justice unless you
you are pretty well connected 

828
00:46:03,080 --> 00:46:07,720
with with senators and, and you 
know, sort of have won the 

829
00:46:07,720 --> 00:46:12,440
confidence of a president. 
And just as an institution, the 

830
00:46:12,440 --> 00:46:17,080
judiciary is extremely reluctant
to open any new doors to the 

831
00:46:17,080 --> 00:46:20,920
enforcement of of unenumerated 
rights. 

832
00:46:20,920 --> 00:46:23,280
That means rights not 
specifically articulated than 

833
00:46:23,280 --> 00:46:25,520
text of the Constitution. 
They are much, much more 

834
00:46:25,520 --> 00:46:31,680
comfortable opening doors to the
discovery of unenumerated powers

835
00:46:32,240 --> 00:46:35,240
for government than they are 
opening the door to the 

836
00:46:35,240 --> 00:46:37,600
enforcement of, of unenumerated 
rights. 

837
00:46:37,840 --> 00:46:39,680
And so I think it's a 
combination of all those things.

838
00:46:39,800 --> 00:46:42,640
And I, you know, I guess I would
say the last thing is to, to 

839
00:46:42,640 --> 00:46:47,000
give them their due. 
It is difficult to know once you

840
00:46:47,000 --> 00:46:49,200
open that door. 
OK, well, what rights are we 

841
00:46:49,200 --> 00:46:51,840
going to protect under this 
open-ended provision, this 

842
00:46:51,840 --> 00:46:54,040
privileges or immunities clause?
And which rights are we not 

843
00:46:54,040 --> 00:46:56,160
going to protect? 
Right? 

844
00:46:56,320 --> 00:46:59,160
Does it protect your right to 
brush your teeth or not brush 

845
00:46:59,160 --> 00:47:02,800
your teeth when you go to bed to
wear a hat or not wear a hat? 

846
00:47:03,920 --> 00:47:06,160
And, and I get that that's a 
concern. 

847
00:47:06,160 --> 00:47:10,040
I just don't think that that 
concern is as weighty as wholly 

848
00:47:10,040 --> 00:47:14,760
failing to protect rights unless
they're specifically articulated

849
00:47:14,760 --> 00:47:16,440
in a kind of a bullet point 
form. 

850
00:47:16,440 --> 00:47:18,760
And I explained earlier why I 
think that was would have been 

851
00:47:18,760 --> 00:47:21,680
impossible under the 
circumstances that prevailed in 

852
00:47:21,680 --> 00:47:25,520
the wake of the Civil War. 
I I've caught in the wind lately

853
00:47:25,680 --> 00:47:29,880
and yeah, I don't know the 
details of a a new gun case kind

854
00:47:29,880 --> 00:47:33,520
of working its way through this 
sausage making process. 

855
00:47:34,000 --> 00:47:38,000
Any chance that this can get 
revisited in a beneficial way? 

856
00:47:38,560 --> 00:47:42,640
No, not by the Supreme Court. 
Kind of figured it was worth 

857
00:47:42,640 --> 00:47:43,960
asking. 
Yeah, yeah. 

858
00:47:44,000 --> 00:47:46,920
I mean, I don't want to sound 
unduly cynical, but as I said, 

859
00:47:47,560 --> 00:47:52,200
if the justices are going to 
open a door to some boundless, 

860
00:47:52,240 --> 00:47:54,840
it's definitely going to be in 
favor of more power and not in 

861
00:47:54,840 --> 00:47:56,960
favor of more rights. 
That's just not something that 

862
00:47:57,440 --> 00:47:59,720
you're you're, you're not going 
to be the kind of person who 

863
00:47:59,720 --> 00:48:01,720
would do that. 
It will have been filtered out 

864
00:48:01,720 --> 00:48:04,320
of, of, of, of running to the 
Supreme Court. 

865
00:48:04,720 --> 00:48:06,680
You know, although I have to say
to his credit, the most 

866
00:48:06,680 --> 00:48:11,160
libertarian justice on the 
court, Neil Gorsuch, you know, 

867
00:48:11,560 --> 00:48:14,320
he talks a good game. 
Whether he would ever actually 

868
00:48:14,320 --> 00:48:18,480
embrace privileges or immunities
as the correct source of 

869
00:48:18,480 --> 00:48:20,160
individual rights. 
Protection of the 14th 

870
00:48:20,160 --> 00:48:21,560
Amendment, I'm less confident 
of. 

871
00:48:21,840 --> 00:48:26,440
But, you know, he, he I think 
he's got better sort of 

872
00:48:26,440 --> 00:48:28,600
libertarian instincts than any 
other justice on the Supreme 

873
00:48:28,600 --> 00:48:29,920
Court. 
I have high hopes for him still.

874
00:48:30,680 --> 00:48:33,800
Yeah, I I kind of do too, but. 
We'll see what happens where the

875
00:48:33,800 --> 00:48:36,360
rubber meets the road correct 
there. 

876
00:48:36,360 --> 00:48:39,440
There's a very sad. 
Asymmetry here as I'm listening 

877
00:48:39,440 --> 00:48:45,400
to you, the the amendment 
process is so onerous and you 

878
00:48:45,400 --> 00:48:49,840
finally get all the ducks in a 
row and you get an amendment 

879
00:48:49,840 --> 00:48:52,280
written and passed. 
And then you can have a Supreme 

880
00:48:52,280 --> 00:48:55,160
Court do what you're describing 
and say, oh, no, it doesn't mean

881
00:48:55,160 --> 00:48:57,160
that It means something else. 
Oh, yeah. 

882
00:48:57,240 --> 00:48:58,520
And it's not just amendments, I 
mean. 

883
00:48:58,520 --> 00:49:03,400
Keep in mind that the, the, the 
original unamended Constitution 

884
00:49:03,400 --> 00:49:07,920
states that no state shall make 
or enforce any law which shall 

885
00:49:07,920 --> 00:49:10,600
abridge the obligations of 
contracts. 

886
00:49:11,240 --> 00:49:15,080
And they had a very specific 
situation in mind, which was the

887
00:49:15,080 --> 00:49:19,880
effort of lenders, I'm sorry, 
borrowers in the wake of the of 

888
00:49:19,880 --> 00:49:22,280
the Revolutionary War to 
essentially rewrite the terms of

889
00:49:22,280 --> 00:49:25,440
their loans because there are 
generally going to be more 

890
00:49:25,440 --> 00:49:27,600
borrowers than lenders. 
And so they have the, you know, 

891
00:49:27,640 --> 00:49:29,640
sort of the democratic numbers 
on their side. 

892
00:49:30,520 --> 00:49:33,600
And, you know, took in, in 
fairness, you know, many of them

893
00:49:33,600 --> 00:49:35,880
have been off fighting the 
Revolutionary War instead of 

894
00:49:35,880 --> 00:49:38,360
home harvesting crops. 
And so they didn't have the 

895
00:49:38,360 --> 00:49:42,760
money to repay their loans, but 
that's, that's what that 

896
00:49:42,760 --> 00:49:48,440
provision is doing there. 
And in the in the early 20th 

897
00:49:48,440 --> 00:49:51,360
century, not too early, but you 
know, in the time of the Great 

898
00:49:51,360 --> 00:49:53,240
Depression, what do you think 
happened? 

899
00:49:53,360 --> 00:49:56,520
Well, farmers started trying to 
rewrite the terms of their loans

900
00:49:56,680 --> 00:49:58,880
because they're a hard time 
repaying. 

901
00:49:58,880 --> 00:50:01,120
And I'm, you know, I think all 
of us probably have some 

902
00:50:01,120 --> 00:50:04,200
sympathy there, but they are 
trying to do the exact thing 

903
00:50:04,640 --> 00:50:07,240
that that provision was designed
to forbid. 

904
00:50:07,240 --> 00:50:10,040
And the Supreme Court, in a case
called Blaisdell said, well, you

905
00:50:10,040 --> 00:50:12,080
know, this is a kind of a 
national emergency. 

906
00:50:12,080 --> 00:50:14,840
So we're going to pretend as if 
this provision doesn't really 

907
00:50:14,840 --> 00:50:18,000
have any substance. 
And the Court has never gone 

908
00:50:18,000 --> 00:50:21,400
back and, and, and overturned 
that case. 

909
00:50:21,400 --> 00:50:25,480
So even a provision that was in 
the original Constitution that 

910
00:50:25,480 --> 00:50:29,440
has a high degree of clarity and
specificity to James's point, if

911
00:50:29,440 --> 00:50:31,040
the language is clear, enforce 
it. 

912
00:50:31,320 --> 00:50:35,280
The Supreme Court is still 
capable of imbuing that language

913
00:50:35,280 --> 00:50:39,480
with enough uncertainty or 
variability to meet the 

914
00:50:39,480 --> 00:50:43,440
government's preferred ends in 
any given case and to defer 

915
00:50:43,440 --> 00:50:48,040
reflexively to the to the 
contrary policy preferences of 

916
00:50:48,120 --> 00:50:51,480
of political actors. 
And as I like to say when I. 

917
00:50:51,720 --> 00:50:56,800
Taught such things in college 
campuses, and thus the federal 

918
00:50:56,800 --> 00:50:59,960
government found in favor of the
federal government. 

919
00:51:00,560 --> 00:51:01,640
Well, that happened to be a 
case. 

920
00:51:01,640 --> 00:51:04,560
Placed out was the was the US 
Supreme Court finding in favor 

921
00:51:04,560 --> 00:51:07,720
of of a of a Minnesota law, if I
if I remember correctly. 

922
00:51:07,720 --> 00:51:11,080
But of course, it was just a few
years later, or I guess about a 

923
00:51:11,080 --> 00:51:16,880
decade later, that the Supreme 
Court decided that the Article 

924
00:51:16,880 --> 00:51:21,120
1, Section 8 power to regulate 
commerce among the states, among

925
00:51:21,120 --> 00:51:23,320
the states, among the states. 
Empower. 

926
00:51:23,320 --> 00:51:28,120
The US Department of Agriculture
to dictate to individual farmers

927
00:51:28,120 --> 00:51:31,040
how much wheat they could grow 
on their own farm for their own 

928
00:51:31,040 --> 00:51:35,840
consumption. 
My my biggest complaint. 

929
00:51:35,840 --> 00:51:39,160
With that has always been the 
difference between the words 

930
00:51:39,160 --> 00:51:43,360
between and among. 
Right between is two among is 3 

931
00:51:43,360 --> 00:51:45,840
or more. 
But the the the Supreme Court 

932
00:51:45,840 --> 00:51:48,720
just threw all of it out and 
said no, no, no, even 1 little 

933
00:51:48,720 --> 00:51:52,400
parcel of land is just fine. 
Yeah, and and of course, the 

934
00:51:52,400 --> 00:51:54,080
word. 
Commerce is problematic there as

935
00:51:54,080 --> 00:51:58,760
well because as Justice Thomas 
demonstrates with characteristic

936
00:51:59,560 --> 00:52:02,680
power and clarity. 
In a concurring opinion, he 

937
00:52:02,680 --> 00:52:07,400
wrote in a 1995 case called USB 
Lopez. 

938
00:52:07,400 --> 00:52:10,200
This is the the famous gun 
within 1000 feet of a school 

939
00:52:10,440 --> 00:52:12,680
case where it was one of the 
only times the US Supreme Court 

940
00:52:12,680 --> 00:52:18,520
has struck down a federal law as
as exceeding Congress's commerce

941
00:52:18,520 --> 00:52:22,520
power. 
Just Thompson Clark. 

942
00:52:22,520 --> 00:52:25,640
Wasn't it the first time? 
That the commerce power had ever

943
00:52:25,640 --> 00:52:29,320
been undermined in in any 
significant way well since the 

944
00:52:29,320 --> 00:52:31,400
New Deal. 
Yeah, yeah. 

945
00:52:31,480 --> 00:52:32,520
But I mean there. 
Were cases that. 

946
00:52:32,520 --> 00:52:35,760
Predated the New Deal or you 
know, in the run up to the to 

947
00:52:35,760 --> 00:52:38,040
what they told the go ahead. 
It had been. 

948
00:52:38,080 --> 00:52:39,120
It had been. 
Decades. 

949
00:52:39,800 --> 00:52:43,720
Yes, that's right. 
It had been about. 50 years, 

950
00:52:43,720 --> 00:52:47,200
about 1/2 a century, right? 
And so they get to Lopez and the

951
00:52:47,200 --> 00:52:51,480
government's theory, and I kid 
you not, was that the, the 

952
00:52:52,320 --> 00:52:55,600
criminalizing the possession of 
a of a gun within 1000 feet of a

953
00:52:55,600 --> 00:52:59,360
school implicates Congress's 
power to regulate commerce among

954
00:52:59,360 --> 00:53:02,400
the states. 
Because if, if guns are near 

955
00:53:02,400 --> 00:53:04,640
schools, then students won't be 
able to concentrate on their 

956
00:53:04,640 --> 00:53:06,480
studies. 
They will be less intelligent or

957
00:53:06,480 --> 00:53:08,960
less well educated, therefore 
less economically productive. 

958
00:53:09,280 --> 00:53:12,040
And and if you aggregate all of 
that diminished academic 

959
00:53:12,040 --> 00:53:15,560
performance, it'll have a net 
negative effect on on economic 

960
00:53:15,560 --> 00:53:16,960
productivity. 
And I'm not making that up. 

961
00:53:16,960 --> 00:53:19,520
That's not a character. 
That's their argument if 

962
00:53:19,600 --> 00:53:22,920
anything. 
You're not hacking at it badly 

963
00:53:22,920 --> 00:53:26,680
enough. 
It's the dumbest argument I've 

964
00:53:26,680 --> 00:53:29,320
ever seen at the level of the 
Supreme Court. 

965
00:53:29,720 --> 00:53:32,320
Well it got 4 votes. 
Yeah, so. 

966
00:53:32,440 --> 00:53:35,160
It was, it was a close call, but
but Justice Thomas wrote a great

967
00:53:35,160 --> 00:53:38,160
concurring opinion where among 
other things, he he went back 

968
00:53:38,160 --> 00:53:45,000
and looked at at at founding era
dictionaries and case law, 

969
00:53:45,000 --> 00:53:47,440
etcetera. 
And he zeroed in on the word 

970
00:53:47,440 --> 00:53:52,880
commerce and he and he, he 
proved how even you know, pro 

971
00:53:52,880 --> 00:53:56,200
government types, a relatively 
pro government types like 

972
00:53:56,200 --> 00:54:00,360
Alexander Hamilton consistently 
distinguished between commerce 

973
00:54:00,360 --> 00:54:03,400
on the one hand and other 
productive activities like 

974
00:54:03,400 --> 00:54:08,360
agriculture and and and 
manufacturing on the other. 

975
00:54:08,880 --> 00:54:12,560
And, and so, so when they use 
the word commerce among the 

976
00:54:12,560 --> 00:54:15,680
states, they, they the best 
argument in my view is the one 

977
00:54:15,680 --> 00:54:18,440
Thomas makes, which is that they
were specifically excluding 

978
00:54:18,640 --> 00:54:22,480
agriculture and manufacture. 
And the only thing that they 

979
00:54:22,480 --> 00:54:28,280
meant to include is when goods 
or money or some other, you 

980
00:54:28,280 --> 00:54:31,840
know, economic factor is 
actually moving among states. 

981
00:54:31,840 --> 00:54:36,280
And of course, as you know, 
James, it this this nonsensical 

982
00:54:36,280 --> 00:54:40,240
interpretation of the Commerce 
Clause did not stop with the, 

983
00:54:40,520 --> 00:54:43,400
with the, the Wickard case, 
which is the one we were talking

984
00:54:43,400 --> 00:54:44,840
about the, the, the wheat 
farmer. 

985
00:54:45,400 --> 00:54:50,120
And just as recently as 2005, 
the Supreme Court held that the 

986
00:54:50,560 --> 00:54:53,600
commerce power, together with a 
nice dollop of necessary and 

987
00:54:53,600 --> 00:54:58,320
proper, which is another 
provision in Article 1, was 

988
00:54:58,320 --> 00:55:01,360
sufficient to empower the 
federal government to 

989
00:55:01,360 --> 00:55:06,720
criminalize the purely local 
cultivation and non commercial 

990
00:55:06,720 --> 00:55:11,200
distribution of a plant. 
And of course that plan was 

991
00:55:11,200 --> 00:55:14,080
canvas and and correct me if I'm
wrong. 

992
00:55:14,080 --> 00:55:16,200
Clarence Thomas was on the wrong
side of that one. 

993
00:55:16,600 --> 00:55:18,200
He was on the right side, 
Justice Scalia. 

994
00:55:18,200 --> 00:55:22,080
Was on the wrong side close. 
It was it was six to three. 

995
00:55:22,240 --> 00:55:23,920
This is the Gonzales V Rage 
case. 

996
00:55:23,920 --> 00:55:25,880
And, you know, I think if you 
want to sort of really see the 

997
00:55:26,240 --> 00:55:29,680
high watermark of 
disingenuousness and lack of 

998
00:55:29,680 --> 00:55:33,600
principle, just look at the 
ability of even a conservative 

999
00:55:33,600 --> 00:55:37,480
justice to say, Hey, you know 
what, I am, I yield to no one in

1000
00:55:37,480 --> 00:55:40,040
my commitment to the, to the, to
the, both the text and the 

1001
00:55:40,040 --> 00:55:42,240
structure of the US 
Constitution, but not if it 

1002
00:55:42,240 --> 00:55:43,880
threatens the the federal drug 
war. 

1003
00:55:43,880 --> 00:55:46,960
Can't, I can't go that far. 
And it's a it's a, it's a 

1004
00:55:46,960 --> 00:55:49,880
fundamentally silly ruling. 
The idea that if you grow a 

1005
00:55:49,880 --> 00:55:53,040
plant in your backyard and you 
don't give it to anybody and you

1006
00:55:53,040 --> 00:55:55,120
just, and it doesn't matter. 
It doesn't matter if it's a 

1007
00:55:55,120 --> 00:55:59,520
marijuana plant, you know, or, 
you know, a grape Bush and 

1008
00:55:59,520 --> 00:56:01,280
you're, you know, making your 
own wine from it. 

1009
00:56:01,280 --> 00:56:04,960
It's not something the federal 
government has any ability to 

1010
00:56:04,960 --> 00:56:07,560
regulate. 
I remember when that case. 

1011
00:56:07,560 --> 00:56:11,120
Came up, we all thought finally 
there's going to be a little bit

1012
00:56:11,120 --> 00:56:17,680
of rationality around this issue
and it wasn't to be for another,

1013
00:56:17,680 --> 00:56:21,360
what, 10-15 years before states 
just started saying, oh forget 

1014
00:56:21,360 --> 00:56:24,640
we're going to do it anyway. 
Well, somewhat. 

1015
00:56:24,640 --> 00:56:26,240
Speaking of which I was. 
Actually present in the 

1016
00:56:26,240 --> 00:56:28,880
courtroom and Randy Barnett, 
Professor Randy Barnett argued 

1017
00:56:28,880 --> 00:56:31,400
the Gonzalez free rage case. 
And I believe it was Justice 

1018
00:56:31,400 --> 00:56:34,640
Ginsburg who had asked him a 
question, the essence of which 

1019
00:56:34,640 --> 00:56:38,000
was, well, listen, you know, 
even if it's the case that, you 

1020
00:56:38,000 --> 00:56:43,000
know, this particular marijuana 
was not bought or sold, it is 

1021
00:56:43,000 --> 00:56:46,160
the kind of thing that some 
people would buy or sell. 

1022
00:56:46,160 --> 00:56:48,640
So that that makes it an object 
of commerce. 

1023
00:56:49,040 --> 00:56:52,080
And without missing a beat, 
Professor Barnett said, well, 

1024
00:56:52,080 --> 00:56:54,560
you know, that would apply to a 
lot of things, including sex. 

1025
00:56:56,080 --> 00:56:57,560
Does that mean? 
That the pro government has the 

1026
00:56:57,560 --> 00:56:59,240
ability to regulate. 
That and, and I'll tell you 

1027
00:56:59,240 --> 00:57:02,520
what, that's the thing. 
Our friends who embrace this, 

1028
00:57:02,520 --> 00:57:06,840
the capacious interpretation of 
the Commerce Clause can never 

1029
00:57:07,040 --> 00:57:10,800
answer when you ask them what is
your limiting principle? 

1030
00:57:10,800 --> 00:57:14,880
Tell me a thing or an activity 
that would not be reached by 

1031
00:57:14,880 --> 00:57:17,800
your interpretation. 
Justice Breyer couldn't do it in

1032
00:57:17,800 --> 00:57:20,400
the Lopez case when he wrote the
Descent and you and they threw 

1033
00:57:20,400 --> 00:57:23,960
down the gauntlet, they said 
tell us a thing that is beyond 

1034
00:57:23,960 --> 00:57:26,160
thorough power. 
So you've got this, this, you 

1035
00:57:26,160 --> 00:57:30,840
know, you got this, this 
untenable position where Supreme

1036
00:57:30,840 --> 00:57:33,600
Court Justice says, well, 
clearly the, the, the the 

1037
00:57:33,600 --> 00:57:36,440
federal government is one of the
enumerated and limited powers. 

1038
00:57:36,920 --> 00:57:39,160
But then I have this 
interpretation of those powers 

1039
00:57:39,160 --> 00:57:42,520
that is not limited. 
And somebody asks a perfectly 

1040
00:57:42,520 --> 00:57:45,360
fair question. 
OK, well, explain your position.

1041
00:57:45,800 --> 00:57:47,080
Tell me a thing. 
They can't regulate. 

1042
00:57:47,080 --> 00:57:49,400
Well, you know, that's, that's a
question for another day. 

1043
00:57:49,400 --> 00:57:51,440
Well, you just gave away the 
whole game, didn't you? 

1044
00:57:52,800 --> 00:57:54,000
And on. 
That. 

1045
00:57:54,000 --> 00:57:58,160
Happy note, Clark. 
It's been really good to see 

1046
00:57:58,160 --> 00:57:59,600
you. 
Again, it's been way too long. 

1047
00:57:59,880 --> 00:58:01,640
This is great, too long. 
You can tell I had a lot of. 

1048
00:58:01,640 --> 00:58:03,920
Pent up. 
Energy I needed to yeah so thank

1049
00:58:03,920 --> 00:58:06,520
you for the opportunity we're 
we're going to make sure we. 

1050
00:58:06,520 --> 00:58:10,000
Get you back after somebody else
does something really stupid and

1051
00:58:10,960 --> 00:58:13,760
the same basic thing can go on. 
I'll see you next week. 

1052
00:58:13,760 --> 00:58:15,920
But I I for a yes, That's right.
I have. 

1053
00:58:15,920 --> 00:58:19,520
I for one, have been thoroughly 
amused and I enjoy every minute 

1054
00:58:19,520 --> 00:58:21,160
of your cup. 
Same here. 

1055
00:58:21,160 --> 00:58:23,160
Thank you, James. 
And Ed, thank you. 

1056
00:58:23,240 --> 00:58:23,920
Thank you, Clark.
