Hi everyone. Welcome back to logical bible
study. This is the Catholic podcast
where we take an in-depth. Look at the scriptures, we do a
verse by verse exegesis of the Gospel reading at today's mass
and it's totally listener-supported.
So if you like what you hear, please subscribe on iTunes,
Libra review. Subscribe on YouTube as well.
If you're listening on YouTube and please continue to share it
around. I'd also ask you to prayerfully
consider becoming a patreon supporter of the ministry.
And if you do, you get access to a whole lot of exclusive
content, including bonus episodes of parts of the gospels
that you'll never hear at Mass. We do a verse by verse exegesis
of those texts and they're available to anyone who decides
to financially support the ministry.
So if you've been benefiting from this ministry for a while
and you want to See a grow? You want to express?
Your thanks for what we're doing.
Then please consider becoming a patreon supporter and the
information for that is in the show nodes today, we're looking
at Luke chapter 11 verses 47 to 54.
Jesus said a less for you who build the tombs of the prophets
the menu ancestors killed in this way.
You both witness what your ancestors did and approve it.
They did the killing you. Do the building?
And that is why the wisdom of God said I will send them
prophets and apostles some they will Slaughter and persecute so
that this generation will have to answer for every prophets
blood that has been shared since the foundation of the world,
from the blood of Abel, to the blood of Zechariah, who was
murdered between the Altar and the sanctuary.
Yes, I tell you this generation will have to answer for it all.
Alas for you lawyers who have taken away.
The key of knowledge, you have not gone in yourselves and have
prevented others going in. Who wanted to when he left the
house, the scribes and the Pharisees began a furious attack
on him. And tried to force answers from
him on innumerable questions. Setting traps to catch him out
in something. He might say, So a really
interesting passage today and there's a bit to talk about
here. Let's start by thinking about
the context. So Jesus, at this point is
moving From Galilee to Jerusalem for the Final Phase of his
ministry and his going through various towns on the way and
he's been invited to eat at a Pharisees house.
The Pharisee notices that Jesus doesn't perform.
The usual ritual Washings before eating and he questions, Jesus
about it. Jesus.
Then used that as an opportunity to tell the What their biggest
issue is so in verses 37 on words of this chapter and you
would have heard this in the last few days of the podcast.
Jesus says the biggest issue with the Pharisees is they focus
on external Purity rather than internal Purity.
And in yesterday's episode just before today he has said the
Pharisees actually make it more difficult for people to come to
God, rather than easier. Their job is supposed to be to
help people get to God, but they're actually doing the
opposite. So, all of that has Has
happened. And now we get to verse 47 and
Jesus says, a less for you or more literally there.
Whoa, to you and we talked about what the words mean in
yesterday's episode alas for you who build the tombs of the
prophets. The men, your ancestors killed.
So the Jews, the Jewish leaders in Jesus time, they claim to
honor the Old Testament prophets and they built elaborate tombs
and memorials for them and said, lots of prayers and decorated
these terms. So they did honor the prophets
or at least they thought they did.
In fact, the Jewish leaders in Jesus time, they distance
themselves from the action of the previous Jewish leaders, so
they consider themselves different than their
forefathers. They say to themselves, we would
never kill a profit but that's not how Jesus understands it.
Because in verse 48, Jesus says to them in this way, you both
witness what your ancestors did and approve it.
They did the killing you. Do the building as in the
building of the terms there. So Jesus sees Is the fact that
the Pharisees, build the tombs of the prophets?
He sees that as a symbolic of the fact that the Pharisees are
actually complicit in the acts of their forefathers.
Their forefathers do the killing, and the Pharisees, do
the building, but there's more to it.
As Jesus is going to go on, to say, it's really how the
Pharisees are going to treat the future messengers of God.
That makes them the most complicit.
It makes them the most, like, their forefathers because as
we'll see, Jesus says, the Pharisees are actually going to
treat future profits in exactly the same way as their
forefathers treated the previous prophets.
So they're not much different from their fathers at all verse
49. Jesus now says this and that is
why the wisdom of God said and then he has an extended quote,
the wisdom of God, that's an interesting phrase and in a lot
of Bibles, this'll be capitals, the wisdom of God.
So who is the wisdom of God? It seems to be a reference to To
the word of God himself as in it's something that God himself.
Spoke at some point, the wisdom of God, something that came out
of God's mouth. Now, the next quote though that
apparently, the wisdom of God said, according to Jesus, these
words are never recorded in scripture.
So when did God say this? Maybe God said this to Jesus in
heaven as a conversation between the Trinity or maybe it was part
of a Jewish Tradition at the time that it was something God
had said it's not entirely clear.
But Jesus says, these are the very words of God.
Now there's a further complication though because in
the original Greek, there's no such thing as a quotation mark.
So we don't actually know when The court finishes.
And when Jesus starts to add his own comments, on top of that.
So here in verse 46, 48, Jesus basically says, here's a quote
that God has said, but we don't know when the quote finishes,
and when Jesus starts to talk himself, so it's kind of
complicated what further complicates it though, is that
if you look at Matthews version of this speech in Matthew
chapter 23, it just has Jesus saying these words rather than
saying that God set them just Jesus comes right out.
And says them himself. So, there might be, if we put
Matthew and Luke together, this might be a very subtle hint that
the gospel, the gospel authors did understand Jesus to be God.
And in fact, to be the wisdom of God, which, of course we believe
as Christians. But let's work with the text.
We have now different Bible translations will have the quote
ending in different places. Even the ones I looked at
preparing for this episode, a slightly different from how the
lectionary has it. But here's the entire quote as
today's election area puts it. So this is Currently something
God said, I will send them prophets and apostles.
Some they will Slaughter and persecute so that this
generation will have to answer for every prophets blood that
has been shed since the foundation of the world, from
the blood of Abel to the blood of Zechariah, who was murdered
between the Altar and the sanctuary.
So it's a fairly long quote there from god.
Let's try and break it down a bit.
So the first thing in this quote, God says, is, I will send
them prophets and apostles. Now, the reference here is
firstly to the Old Testament prophets.
So God says I will send them prophets and he's done it.
But then there's this second phrase, I'll send them Apostles.
This is almost certainly referring to the Twelve
Apostles. As in the New Testament era, the
apostles are going to be a continuation of the ministry of
the prophets in the Old Testament, which is interesting.
You've probably never perhaps considered this part of Luke
before where God himself says, I will send Them prophets and
apostles. In fact, Matthews version of
this text in Matthew, 23 says, Jesus says to the Pharisees,
some of these Apostles you will kill and crucify and Scourge in
your synagogues. So clearly the apostles that God
is talking about here are the 12 apostles, God here promises to
send the Jewish leaders, the apostles, just as God sent Old
Testament prophets to reveal his will.
Now, in the New Covenant, the apostles are going to be God's
prophets, who were Went to reveal, God's will to the Jewish
people, the quote continues, some they will Slaughter and
persecute and of course, in the Old Testament when ever a
prophet was sent by God to bring a message, the Jewish leaders
didn't treat the prophet particularly.
Well, there will almost always rejected and they were often
killed by the Jewish leadership. So we know that the Jewish
leadership in the Old Testament, hated the prophets of God, and
here, Jesus says, they're going to treat the early, Christian
leaders, the apostles, the same way.
They will be slaughtered and persecuted by the Jewish
leaders. So it's quite a remarkable
prophecy, here of Jesus, he's saying the coming Apostles will
be treated in the same way as your father's treated, the
prophets verse 50, so that this generation.
Now this phrase, this generation, it means the Jewish
leaders in Jesus time. This generation will have to
answer for every prophets blood that has been shed since the
foundation of the world. What the Greek.
They're actually says, is this generation of the blood of all
the prophets will be required of this generation.
What does this mean here? Jesus says that the Jewish
leaders in Jesus time rejected Jesus and the rejected the
apostles, but Jesus himself is the last and greatest in a long
line of prophets who God has sent to the Jewish leaders, to
turn them back to him, we'll think about it.
If they reject Jesus, the fullest revelation of God's will
then really bike. Attention, the Jewish leaders,
reject, all of God's prophets. So in that sense, they're
accountable for the deaths of all of the prophets, there's
more to it though. Because as we'll see, Jesus is
going to say what makes them more.
Accountable is the way they treat the future Apostles as
well, but it's pretty strong. Strong language here, isn't it?
Jesus says the Pharisees will have to answer for every
prophets blood that has been shed that since the foundation
of the world. Now this is despite the
Pharisees claim that they honor the prophets and that they're
not accountable. Notable for their deaths.
Jesus says, you are in fact, accountable and you will be held
accountable. Then in verse 51, he says, from
the blood of Abel to the blood of Zechariah, who was murdered
between the Altar and the sanctuary.
Why does Jesus bring up here able and Zechariah?
It turns out that this is kind of like a BRAC.
These are brackets indicating the entire period of the Old
Testament that the Pharisees will be accountable for because
this is a period in what in which, a lot of righteous
prophets were killed. So, he first mentions, the blood
of Abel. Most people know, the story of
Cain killing Abel will able is the first righteous person to be
killed in the entire Old Testament.
It's very early in the Bible, Genesis chapter 4, Cain kills
Abel. Even though able is righteous.
And then Jesus says, from the blood of Abel to the blood of
Zechariah, who is murdered between the Altar and the
sanctuary. Who is this is Zechariah, that
Jesus talks about there's two different views here.
Well, Matthew actually gives us a bit more information about
who's Zachariah is, if you look at Matthew chapter, 23, Jesus,
there says, that Zechariah is the son of berechiah, who is
Zechariah the son of berechiah. He is the prophet Zechariah from
the Old Testament. There is a book in the Old
Testament called the book of Zechariah.
That is the Zechariah. That is apparently in mind here.
Now, his death is not. Mentioned in scripture, we don't
find out how he dies in the Old Testament, but Jesus he says he
was murdered between the Altar and the sanctuary and indeed.
In Jesus time, there was a rabbinical tradition that says
that this Zechariah was killed in the temple so that would
certainly fit but there is an alternative view amongst summer
Scholars, though. Some Scholars think that this is
a different exact ariya. The son of jehoiada, there's a
different sector. I in the Old Testament, he's
mentioned in and Chronicles chapter 24 verses 20 to 22 and
this Zechariah, the son of jehoiada.
He was definitely murdered in the sanctuary that actually says
that in the Old Testament. So that would certainly fit very
well actually, because in the time of Jesus, the Old Testament
in Israel, had Genesis, as the first book of the Old Testament
and second chronicles was the last.
So if this second Zechariah the one in second chronicles is the
one that Jesus has in mind. Well then it's a very good way
of saying that the Pharisees are accountable for the deaths of
all the prophets in the entire Old Testament, from Genesis
through the second chronicles, from the start of the Old
Testament. The end, perhaps there's been
some sort of some Scholars, think there might be like a
copyist area here, where originally in Matthews version,
it says, Zechariah the son of jehoiada and maybe, at some
point, a copyist has changed it to Bear a Kya.
So perhaps we've lost the original manuscript here but
either way, it doesn't really matter.
Jesus is saying that Zechariah whichever Zechariah, we identify
it. As he is the last righteous man
in the Old Testament to be killed.
So in this way, Abel and Zechariah servers, brackets for
the group of righteous people, whose deaths the Jewish leaders
will be responsible for, so they are the brackets.
Jesus goes on in verse 51. Yes I tell you this generation
will have to answer for it all. Or again you can translate that
as each. She'll be required of this
generation. So the blood guilt that the
Pharisees have accumulated from the Old Testament era will
finally spill over in the coming days.
This is what Jesus says, and the Jewish leaders, the Pharisees
are going to be judged. When does this happen?
When at the Jewish leaders in Jesus day punished for their
treatment of the prophets and the apostles Clearly, if we
understand history correctly, it's in the destruction of the
temple in 70 AD, the jewish-roman war between 1866
and 1870 was brutal. Many of the Jewish leaders were
killed and the New Testament. Clearly depicts the destruction
of the temple. As at least partially it's a
judgment of God. God is showing his judgment on
the Jewish leaders for continually rejecting his
profits and particularly for rejecting the Messiah.
Now, that might sound a bit harsh.
Why would Jesus? Why would God allow pretty much
all of Jerusalem to be wiped out?
Just because of the Pharisees. Well, if you study the Old
Testament whenever God judges Israel historically suffering in
Israel is a collective experience that falls on both
the righteous and the wicked. As a consequence of collective
guilt, we don't have this concept as much in Christian
theology anymore, but in the Old Testament, the Jewish leaders
were responsible for The welfare of all the Jews.
And if the Jewish leaders were guilty, basically, all of Israel
was considered guilty in a sense, because of collective
guilt, this idea of the destruction of the temple, being
a judgment of God. That's actually explicitly
brought out in Luke chapter 21. And their Jesus says this
generation shall not pass away until all is fulfilled.
So, we'll look at Luke chapter 21 when we get there.
Now, there's something interesting here.
Let's go back and read the entire sort of phrase here and
see if you can pick up on Jesus main point here.
So, going back to verse 47 here, this is what it says.
You build the tombs of the prophets, the men, your
ancestors killed in this way. You both witness what your
ancestors did and approve it. They did the killing you do the
building. And that is why the wisdom of
God said I will send them prophets and apostles, they will
have to answer for every prophets blood that has been
shared since the foundation of the world, from the blood of
Abel to the blood of Zechariah. Yes, I tell you this generation
will have to answer for it all the key thing there that's
really interesting and this is something we should do.
If we're looking, at the literal sense is look at the grammar
that's users particularly words like therefore and so we'll up
there at the start of verse 49. There's a therefore it says,
therefore, that is why the wisdom of God said, what's going
on here? What's the therefore, if we
understand that correctly, it seems that Jesus is saying that
the reason God is going to send the Pharisees future prophets
and apostles is so that the Jewish leaders in Jesus day can
be held accountable for killing all of God's righteous
Messengers and therefore their punishment will be justified.
So in other words, God is saying that already at the time.
Jesus is speaking here, the the Pharisees are guilty for the way
they have treated, the Old Testament prophets, but to prove
that quite literally, he's going To send them more profits in the
form of Apostles and they will treat them terribly too.
And that will serve as proof. But they are, in fact guilty and
they deserve the punishment interesting, isn't it?
But that's actually what the verse says.
It says, the Reason God is going to send them Apostles is so that
they can be proved guilty, really interesting.
And that's why I think looking at the literal sense of
scripture reveals a lot of interesting stuff about theology
that we might miss, if we just skim over it.
Going to verse 50 52 Jesus in the all turns to the lawyers and
says, alas for you lawyers. So the lawyers would be the
Jewish experts in the Old Testament.
These are kind of like the high-ranking.
Pharisees Jesus says, you have taken away the key of knowledge.
Knowledge, about what will Jesus doesn't say here, but it most
likely means knowledge of the kingdom of God and God's Will.
And the image here of key is sort of brings to mind like a
door. It's like the Pharisees have the
key. Should the door to the kingdom
of God, but they're not using it.
They're not letting people get to the door.
The Pharisees have taken away access to the knowledge of the
kingdom of God. From the Jewish people,
basically, by their elaborate and many laws and requirements.
They actually make it harder for people to come to God.
So, in other words, they have locked up the kingdom of God
from the Jewish people by their complex system of rules and
regulations, that's the opposite of what they should be doing.
Jesus goes on, you have not gone in yourselves so he's He's going
to get pretty harsh here. Jesus says, the Pharisees have
not entered the kingdom of God because they have not listened
to his Messengers. Who have explained his will.
They haven't listened to the prophets or Jesus himself nor
will they listen to the apostles.
So they have not entered the kingdom even though they have
the key to and Jesus now says, and you have prevented others
going in who wanted two or more, literally there.
What it says, use you have hindered.
Those who were entering, this is probably the Pharisees greatest
sin. They roll their gods appointed
leaders and said, I supposed to help guide the Jewish people to
God, but they've done the very opposite here.
Jesus says, they actually prevent the Jewish people from
getting into the kingdom. It's not that the Pharisees are
two lakhs or that they lack missionary Zeal.
It's just that their interpretation of Judaism and
their complex system ends up distorting God's Will and it
makes it harder for the Jews to understand God, and His will.
And, in fact, it makes them harder to understand the Messiah
and to come to them. Sia.
So, in that sense, the Jewish leaders are blocking people from
getting into the kingdom, of God.
Think about how different it would have been if the Pharisees
had accepted Jesus as the Messiah.
Probably most of Israel would have accepted Jesus as the
Messiah, but they look to their leaders for cues and since the
Jewish leaders largely rejected him, Israel, largely rejected
him verse 53. So that's the end of the
conversation between them. Luke now says when Jesus left
the house, the scribes and the Pharisees began to Furious
attack on him what it actually says.
That's not the best translation. It's not a furious attack.
It says, they began to press him hard.
Now, keep in mind by this point, the Jewish leaders basically
Want Jesus dead. They've had enough of him.
Luke goes on. They tried to force answers from
Jesus, from him, on innumerable questions.
Again, what the Greek there says is they provoked Jesus to speak
of many things. So they're trying to trap Jesus.
They trying to get him to talk about things that will get him
into trouble because they're looking for an excuse to punish
him basically and to get him out of the way verse 54, they set
traps to catch him out in something, he might say.
And again, the Greek, there says they lie in wait for him.
And we know that for the last part of Jesus ministry, the
Jewish leaders are constantly looking for opportunities to
trap Jesus. And there's several scenes that
were probably quite familiar with where the Pharisees
actually come up with several trap questions which they think
will incriminate Jesus. But he gets away with all of
them. And one example of that is,
should we pay the tax to Caesar or not?
They think that's a good trap question but Jesus gets out of
it. So that's the end of Luke
chapter 11. It's a pretty long one and we'll
look at Luke chapter 12 in the coming days.
The only catechism reference to today's passage is in paragraph
five seven, nine. And this is the same one that we
looked at yesterday, and it's well worth repeating because it
gives you a completely different perspective.
On the positives, the positive aspects of the way, the
Pharisees went about things. So catechism of the Catholic
Church paragraph, 579 the principle of an integral
observance of the law, not Only in letter.
But in spirit was dear to the Pharisees, by giving Israel,
this principle, they had led many Jews of Jesus time, to an
extreme religious Zeal. This is Zeal, were not to lapse
into hypocrisy. Could only prepare the people
for their unprecedented intervention of God through the
perfect fulfillment of the law by the only righteous one in the
place of all sinners. So I'll include that paragraph
in the show notes as well. Thanks for listening today.
Please share this podcast around so that more and more people and
Catholics in particular can learn to dive into the word of
God in a really academic faithful.
Systematic way and will continue to move through Luke in the
coming days.